Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Sweet (DEC10)

Posts

Sweet (DEC10)

#1

Sweet (DEC10)

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I was reading some of the fine print in the Popular Woodworking received yesterday (could we change the name of the magazine and keep the contents?). I noticed that the end subscription date was supposed to be on the address label above your name and since I thought it was about time to renew I looked at it. I looked all over the label but the only date I could figure out was listed as DEC10. That would mean December of 2010. I immediately contacted the household Knower of All Things. Her reply; "Yep, that's right honey, I renewed it for 2 years."

Other reading I have snuck in this week is "Workbenches" which can't really be elaborated on much more than it already has. A very nice book. I expect the next book to be dedicated to the european style workbench ;) Monday evening when I came home David Pye's book "The Nature and Aesthetics of Design" was waiting for me. The type of book that I can't lay down so I finished reading it Tuesday evening. Highly recommended. Pye's "Art and Nature of Craftsmanship" has been ordered but won't be printed until sometime this summer I guess.

"The Nature and Aesthetics of Design" was very intersting to me because I have always been the Form Follows Function kind of designer. I put a lot of thought into my designs but the book gives you a different starting point. It also states things I have known for some time but found myself unable to express well such as the fact that popular style is mostly bunk. I like the book just as well as Krenov's books and Nakashima's "Soul of A Tree". Should make the next 40 years more interesting than the first.

Re: Sweet (DEC10)

#2

Re: Sweet (DEC10)

Jeff S.

>Moses,

You will very much enjoy The Nature and Art of Craftsmanship as it sets out to give some tangibility to what is and what is not "craftsmanship". Value judgements? Absolutely!

Re: Sweet (DEC10)

#3

Yes, yes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>One of the formative books of my adult shop life.

Re: Sweet (DEC10)

#4

Has someone reprinted Pye's works?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I thought "The Nature and Aesthetics of Design" was out of print. Has someone recognized that it should never be out of print? If so, who?

Re: Sweet (DEC10)

#5

Re: Has someone reprinted Pye's works? *LINK*

Jeff S.

>Bill,

Linden Publishing has printed Pye's work in the recent past. The Nature and Aesthetics of Design is still available, but The Nature and Art of Workmanship is not, though an Amazon search indicates that it will be re-published and Moses indicated that this would be in the summer. That is good news.


The Nature and Aesthetics of Design

Re: Sweet (DEC10)

#6

Re: Has someone reprinted Pye's works?

David Barnett - SW Florida

>This is the same edition I have. "The Nature and Art of Workmanship" has a yellow cover. These books are large trade paperbacks. I hope they're not republished in a smaller size which would detract from the illustrations.

("Me, too..." alert):

Pye has profoundly influenced my approach to design, aesthetics, and craftmanship. I'd highly recommend them to anyone who makes his or her own design choices and certainly to anyone who makes things by hand or machine. Also, "Aesthetics" can be read before "Workmanship", so no need to wait.

Re: Sweet (DEC10)

#7

Isn't there a British artist named Pye

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>that did some great illustrations of 19th century life? I have seen a book but can't seem to find it now.

Stephen

Re: Sweet (DEC10)

#8

Thos. Pye, historical painter, Dublin school

David Barnett - SW Florida

>

Re: Sweet (DEC10)

#9

My Mistake, William Pyne

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Sweet (DEC10)

#10

Re: Has someone reprinted Pye's works?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>There were several used copies of "Aesthetics" on Amazon, which is where I think 5 percent or so of my income is spent. I think one of them was only priced at $1300 or something low like that; it is probably still available ;) Megan ordered it for me at around $15 I think and the used copy I received was actually new; I am not sure why they were selling it as used other than probably other book retailers can't sell books as new on amazon. My copy was reprinted by Cambium Press in 1999. It has a lot of blank space on the pages which at first I thought was a waste of paper but it does make it easier to read and leaves plenty of room for notes in the margins.