We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Reading the article on 'Handplanes I can't live without' by Garrett Hack. turns out that only 3 of the 8 were LNs and the other 5 OLD Stanelys and Bedrocks.
This is what he told me a while back, quality Old is still good, but buy the LN 4 1/2 and the 60 1/2.
>The LN"s have thicker irons. Also "a while back" (and sometimes now) it was cheaper to buy a LN than a old Stanley. Case and point, when I got my 112. LN's were a lot less than Stanleys.
>Scott, Garrett told me that the LN 4 1/2 & the 60 1/2 are just far superior to anything out there. All the rest, (Bench Planes), if I was willing to put the work into a plane and up grade the blade that a 'Good' Stanley would be close enough in quality to an LN that the price difference may not be worth buying one.
>I've had similar experiences. After 2 years in school at NBSS, and a year since, my favorite planes include:
-LN 60.5, high angle 4
-old SW stanley #3, hock blade and chip breaker
-old Stanley 5 1/2, L-N replacement blade and CB
-old Type 11 stanley 4.5, hock replacement irons.
I took my high angle #4 from L-N, and tuned up an old SW Stanley #4, per the article by David Charlesworth. Flattened relevant surfaces, bedded the frog with a file ground into a small scraper, and some carborundum powder. I also fitted it with an aftermarket iron and cap iron. The high angle 4 was a bit harder to push, but both planes performed pretty much identically.
That said, I had a lot of luck with the old Stanley SW blades. They're made of the old-school laminated steel, and they take, and hold, a remarkable edge. I used one to plane a piece of curly maple to a fairly reflective surface. (Held at an angle, I could see TV antennas from across the street reflected in it)
The old stanleys are not to be underestimated, and it's not as hard to tune them up as you'd think. It just takes a little patience.
>The 4.5 and 60.5 are the planes that see the highest use in my shop, so it is worth the extra money to have a tool that is more apt to be flat and true right out of the box. Since I don't have the LN 4.5 my beat up 604-1/2 will have to suffice. My LN 60-1/2R probably sees more use as a regular block plane than it really should. My only concern with it is wearing out the very fine mouth without any adjustability.