Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Three stones...Can somebody explain to

Posts

Three stones...Can somebody explain to

#1

Three stones...Can somebody explain to

VLParisian

>this slow head how to flatten a stone (or for that matter cast Iron etc.) using three stones(or whatever).

Victor - trying to wrap my slow head around the idea.

Re: Three stones...Can somebody explain to

#2

Re: Three stones...Can somebody explain to

David Charlesworth

>Victor,

If you rub two stones together, using pencil lines scribbled all over as an indicator, and they appear to agree with each other, they are not necessarily flat.

It is possible and likely, that you will have one convex and one concave surface of a very large sphere. They will agree perfectly and touch/match if reversed.

Now indroduce a third surface and get it to agree with one of the previous ones. It will clearly not match the remaining first surface.

If you get all three surfaces to agree with each other they must be perfectly flat.

This is how the first ever reference surface was made. It is an old engineer's technique, performed with cast iron plates,files, scrapers and engineer's blue, which is not unlike blue oil paint!

Hope this helps,

David Charlesworth

Re: Three stones...Can somebody explain to

#3

Re: Three stones...Can somebody explain to

Dean J in MN

>Call the three stones A, B, and C.

Rub A on B

Rub B on C

Rub C on A

As David said -- when they all agree with each other, they are flat.

-Dean

Re: Three stones...Can somebody explain to

#4

Thanks... Figured that must be it.

VLParisian

>But the "Why" eluded me.

Victor - I'm burning up in Houston

Re: Three stones...Can somebody explain to

#5

Or, as Columbus said, ...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Never go to sea with two compasses. Always take one or three.

Pam

Re: Three stones...Can somebody explain to

#6

Re: Three stones...Can somebody explain to

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Ah, another example of the philosophy of woodworking. That is an example of a syllogism. If A=B and B=C, then A must equal C. Only in this, we're using the logic to ensure that A will equal C.

I'm always amazed when applications of a principal actually show up somewhere.

Re: Three stones...Can somebody explain to

#7

Re: Three stones...Can somebody explain to

Alan Schwabacher

>It's actually more like A + B = 0 and A + C = 0 and B + C = 0, therefore A = B = C = 0.