Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

cabinet scraper or scraping plane?

Posts

cabinet scraper or scraping plane?

#1

cabinet scraper or scraping plane?

Doug Boor

>Hello, I have been thinking of changing my wood preparations and was curious if anyone had opinions for these two choices. Right now, I use a 4 1/2 smoother and then card scrapers either before assembly or after depending on whichever is easier. Most of the time the smoother is use before assembly and card scrapers afterwards. I was thinking instead of going right to the card scaper, of trying out a cabinet scraper or a scaping plane to smooth out anything the smoother leaves behind. Is this even something to think about, or are the card scrapers the easier and more versatile tool? Thanks

Re: cabinet scraper or scraping plane?

#2

Re: cabinet scraper or scraping plane?

David Charlesworth

>I have always found card scrapers an invitation to create local hollows in flat surfaces, as one tends to concentrate on the problem areas.

Scraper planes are much better for maintaining overall flatness as they oblige the user to take sets of shavings.

David Charlesworth

Re: cabinet scraper or scraping plane?

#3

Re: cabinet scraper or scraping plane?

Marc in Luxembourg

>Doug,

Currently I use two planes for final preparing of difficult timber. One is a low angle smoother with a secondary bevel bringing it up to a 60� effective pitch angle and second is a #212 - a small scraper plane. The first minimizes tearout and the second helps planing the knots without unflattening the work. I rarely use card scrapers. My #112 is covered with dust, I prefer planing at a higher pitch over scraping.

Marc


img

Re: cabinet scraper or scraping plane?

#4

It's a matter of choice...

Scott Burr in fridgid Ben Lomond, CA

>Depending on what type of surface you acheive betweeen planing and scraping. Please work with what serves you the best, thats all that matters.