WE MOVED...
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Is this a bargain? *LINK*

Posts

Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#1

Is this a bargain? *LINK*

Marv

>I think I can afford these.

The videos are not very good but you can get an idea how the blades are straightened and how well they cut.

Marv


Japanese Saws

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#2

Re: Is this a bargain?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Mifuqwai is a very trustworthy seller, but it's often difficult to know what you're buying. In this case, I think you're buying one saw of your choice, priced according to the length, you specify rip or cross cut. Seems like a good deal, but not of write-home impact.

If you need help with length to choose, let us know what you want to do with it.

Pam

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#3

Forgot to mention, his name is Tomonori Nakaoka.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#4

Did you know?

Adam Cherubini

>"Mr.Daizo Mitsukawa is a one of Japanese government authorized younger flokclaft person."

My government (USA) doesn't support folkcraft people and that really frustrates me.

Adam

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#6

Flokclaft = Folk craft ???

John H. in Baltimore

>

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#7

Re: Did you know?

Rob Lee

>Adam...

Nothing bests like doing!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#8

Re: Did you know?

James Watriss

>Unfortunately for the US, I think that was his point, Rob.

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#9

Re: Did you know?

Marv

>If our government supported "folk-craft" people, where would it end? WE, the government would then have to support other specialist as well. And if WE did that, how could WE afford to spend billions on exploring outer space and keep our people in Korea and all around the world? And the first thing ya know, WE'd have to spend more on education and people who shouldn't be collecting SS disability plus all the pork barrel and other government waste. Opps....sorry, didn't mean to get into important stuff here. Just a thought.

Wiley....you should bleep this.

Marv

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#10

Re: Did you know?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>"What you talkin' about Willis?

Rob, your response to Adam went right over my head. Would you elaborate?

T.O.

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#11

Re: Is this a bargain?

Marv

>Pam,

I have seen on several woodworking tool websites where they are selling Japanese saws for less than $25.00. At his price they become throw-aways when dull. Saws at this price are no doubt stamped from sheetmetal and produced on a semi-production basis. Perhaps not hollow-ground or thinner in the middle so as to not require setting of the teeth.

The question that begs to be answered is....what can a $240.00 saw do that one of those $25 saws won't do? Are the cheap saws thicker, hence a wider kerf? Set teeth that won't produce as smooth a sawed surface? Is it the feel of the tool? Too often we find that we are paying extra for a name, especially if the tool is made by hand. Could it be all in the way the teeth are sharpened as it is with western saws? For example, I can sharpen an old no-name saw and make it cut nearly as good as say, a Disston extra taper No.12.

I can afford to pay $240 for a saw, however, I doubt if I ever would for the same reason I wouldn't pay $1600 for one. Probably not talk'n apples and apples here though. The higher priced one is more of a collectible. I suppose if I were a cabinet maker, of which I'm not, I would be looking into the best and most practical tools. I would be focusing on functionality, primarily. The word "best" is a subjective word when we use it in this manner. If the cheap saws did the job, that's what I'd buy.

Collecting is such a luxury. However, I do indulge when ever my extravagant urges win over my more practical side.

Thank you for your post,

Marv

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#12

Oh forget it

Adam Cherubini

>Its was a silly post about how the sawmaker from Osaka wrote "folkcraft" phonetically. I'm bending oak by boiling it (as was done) and I had a few minutes (like now) while it was heating through. I have no knowledge of or opinion of Federal programs for craftspeople.

Adam

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#14

Re: Did you know?

Rob Lee

>Ok.... mine was a joke too...

Sounds "wise" (in a Kung Fu-ish way).... but is really meaningless... a paraphrase of one of my favorite poor translations..."Nothing bests this drill like doing" was the exact phrase...just always remembered it...

I also remember that while people can make amusing grammatical errors - I would be quite proud to be able to make similar errors myself in Japanese, Cantonese, or Taiwanese...all I can do now is say "Hello" and order beer(s) (in at least six languages!)...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#15

Re: Did you know?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Well, you've learned the important words :-)

DC

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#16

Re: Flokclaft?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Tomonori, or whoever does the translations for him, has a bit of a spelling problem. Do you know how to say it/spell it in Japanese?

Pam

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#17

The Smithsonian is very supportive of the crafts.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#18

Re: Is this a bargain?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>There are major differences between hand made and machine made Japanese saws. I'm not going to debate again. You asked if it were a bargain. I said no, but it's a fair price, a good deal.

Pam

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#19

That and

Bill Houghton, rainy Sebastopol, CA

>(after ordering enough beers) "Where is the restroom, please?"

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#20

Chris Scholz

No grants---says who?

Chris Scholz

>...not that a would agree with all our government is doing, who would? But what you are saying is simply incorrect.

10 min. of casual search comes up with at two open grant solicitations with total value of US$5,000,000 that could contain aspects of traditional woodworking:



  • the SEC-OED-2009-2001282 (Environmental Literacy Grants for Formal K-12 Education, could contain a hand-tools program for K12 education, total amount: $4,000,000).

  • NLG-FY08 (National Leadership Grant, Institute of Museum and Library services, total amount: $1,000,000).


Chris

---

Chris Scholz

Atlanta, GA

Galoot-Tools.com

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#21

Re: Is this a bargain?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>These are very personal questions. Personal decisions which we make every day in the end decide how we live. The way we live determines whether or not we are happy with our life. Basically what you are asking I think I have come to realize is a religious decision. A life of unhappiness is basically a wasted life. We are given a certain amount of days, the quantity of which is unknown to us, and it would be a shame in a way to waste any of it. My own personal decision is that I just don't buy the cheapest of anything, or just about anything. I find that simply doing something the easiest way rarely brings a sense of satisfaction about the job done. There is always more to a project than what you can see. One could argue that there is no sense in spending $250 on a saw if you can get a saw for $25. In my own personal experience I find that I have more fun using a tool that I sacrificed something for, either time spent searching for it or time spent earning money to pay for it.

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#22

Re: Is this a bargain?

Marv

>Hi Moses,

Jeeez, can't believe I'm writing to Moses!! *grin*

I suppose if we move the right words around we can relate most anything to a question of "religion". But due to the possibility of Wiley bleeping my post, I wont' go there.

I love top quality tools. I buy them when ever I can easily afford them or when I get that "splurge urge". But when trying to be strictly practical I will go for the tool that gives me the most bang for the buck. Before I retired I could be much more flexible with my spending, but now with a fixed income I'm forced to think in other terms. We all have a different set of circumstances that effect our decisions and choices. This forum is a great convenient source of good information that can help each of us make the best individual decision. That's pretty much the bottom line for me.

Marv

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#23

Marv,

Wiley Horne

>please feel that you can (and should) reply to Moses on the terms he has introduced. You have plenty to say to us, that we need to hear. I found Moses' remarks very moving.

Wiley

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#24

Re: Is this a bargain?

Marv

>Moses,

Have you written any new commandments or perhaps ammended existing ones?

May I suggest a few more?

11- Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's tools.

12- Thou shalt not steal thy neighbor's tools.

13- Do onto other's tools as you would want others to do onto yours.

14- Do not borrow another man's tools and return them in a less condition than when you borrowed them.

15- Thou shalt buy your own tools and not ask to borrow your neigbhor's.

16- Thou shalt buy only quality tools, not cheap junk.

17- Thou shalt not worship false tools in anyone's name.

18- As an older and experienced craftsman, you shalt pass onto at least one younger person your knowledge and skills that you have acquired during your lifetime. If you do not, your life, to a large extent has been wasted.

Marv

Re: Is this a bargain? *LINK*

#25

Re: cheap tools

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I really like the one "Thou shalt not buy any cheap junk." The idea of disposable tools goes against my grain. Buying them only encourages more production. Recently I bought a PVC pipe cutter, and there were 2 cutters side by side, one at $10 and the other cost $30. I looked them over and decided that even though the $30 pipe cutter had plastic handles it had to be a better tool because it cost 3 times as much. I took it home and on the 6th cut that handle busted. I was mad. (We will leave it at that). Now I had to go back to the store, return the cutter and get a new one. About 1 hour of time minimum plus $8 worth of gas. I was doing this on a Sunday afternoon and was supposed to be somewhere by 6 pm and the busted tool basically shot my chances of finishing the job before 6. I went back and traded in the $30 pipe cutter and bought the $10 cutter and it worked much better than the more expensive cutter plus it had metal handles that an elephant could step on and not break.