Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

Posts

Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#1

Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The following is in response to an earlier question on sharpening and what is "best". What I do seems fast and convenient to me, but then I don't have anything to compare to, except myself. While I might claim it is fast and convenient, without data no one else can compare either.

I needed to bevel the top edge of a box I am building and while I would have cheerfully done the bevel with a router, I didn't have a bit that would do the angle I wanted. I knew a razor sharp iron would be needed on the end grain or the end grain would wind up fuzzy and not stain well. I did not want to sand the resulting planed bevel or it might round over and destroy its crispness.

My LN low angle block was the weapon of choice for this task and it was "dull as a hoe", as they say. Since I needed to sharpen it I thought I would keep track of the effort and report.

Step 1 I began on a wheel, 100 grit very soft bond. My grinder is variable speed (VFD drive 3 phase) and I run it about half of 3600 rpm. I ground up to the edge, leaving about 0.010" or less of the original bevel at the edge. Basically, I nearly removed the bevel resulting from the last honing. I use very light pressure to keep from burning so this operation took two or three minutes (I failed to think to time it). (I think I may move back to 80 grit some time in the future to make this part go faster.)

Step 2 I took 10 pull strokes on a 6" very fine fixed diamond stone lubed with water. This operation resulted in about a 1/32" bevel. (this stone does not result in grit carry-over to the 1 micron like a 15 micron loose diamond charged stone would. Others don't worry about carry-over)

Step 3 I then took 10 pull strokes on a 12" cast iron plate charged with 1 micron diamond, lubed with WD40.

Step 4 I rubbed the back of the iron on the cast iron to remove any wire edge that didn't sharpen away in step 3.

Step 5 I tested sharpness. (I admit this may be a strange test) I see if I can effortlessly clip the tops of finger prints off. The edge failed this test.

Then I did what I should have done to begin with. I examined the edge with a 10X lens to see its condition. I can't emphasize enough how useful a 10X lens is to assess edges. I could see that to begin with the edge was crumbled in places and quite rounded over from wear. Because I only ground to the bevel in step 1, step 2 was the only step that affected the original "dead" edge. Step 2 removed too little material and didn't remove all the damaged/worn edge. Even though I felt a wire edge forming after this step it wasn't enough. The lens would have shown me this fact, had I thought to use it.

So I repeated steps 1-5 except this time in step 1 I ground all the honing bevel away and examined with the lens to see that all the dead edge was gone before proceeding to step 2. The edge passed step 5. I got a bright surface on the end-grain bevel. I was reminded how effortlessly a SHARP plane works. Note to self: sharpen more often, especially after using plane on shooting board.

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#2

additional note

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In step 1, note that I ground to the honing bevel without totally removing it on the first try. If some of the honing bevel is left one is ensued that the edge is straight going into step 2. If the iron is very dull then more metal needs to be removed in step 1, as was the case in the sharpening described above. If the honing bevel must be ground away to remove the dead or damaged edge then care is needed to keep the ground edge straight. If the edge gets crooked during wheel grinding then it will take excessive honing in Step 2 to to get it straight again. This situation wears out the diamond stone and my patience.

If I am careless or out of practice (Step 1 does take some practice to perfect) I have gotten a crooked edge off the wheel. This problem shows up quickly in Step 2. The honing bevel will not be uniform across the edge and low spots will not be honed. In this case don't grind forever on the extra fine diamond. Use the honing bevel as a guide and go back to the wheel to remove the high spots. This task turns out to be easier than it may sound.

The bottom line: I use the power grinder to remove the rounded and/or crumpled worn edge, and the diamonds to hone the newly established edge. Variants of this approach will obviously work using other components. If I had stacks of money I would use a Tomerk for Step 1 (well I wouldn't any more, but it would have been easier to learn to do Step 1). And, other abrasive formats can be used for removing the tiny amount of metal necessary to hone the bevel, though it has been shown that only diamond is effective for honing the very abrasion resistant tool steels.

I should acknowledge the contributions of Phil Smith in developing this approach to sharpening. .

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#3

Thanks!

Paul Kierstead

>Very interesting and useful information there. I am prone to the "working forever with a fine stone fixing a mistake in a rougher stage". Actually, I am kinda prone to that with planing too; I have been working on both problems. Going back a step definitely helps a lot.

I have frequently been surprised at how crappy my edges looked when magnified. I am also alarmed at the difference after sharpening, indicating I am a lazy bum apparently.

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#4

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks, Bill, very interesting. What would you recommend for step 1 if you didn't want a hollow grind? A coarse diamond stone?

Pam

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#5

don't know

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When I tried fixed diamond "stones" they wore out quickly when I used them for major metal removal, such as what I called Step 1. Coarse loose diamond on cast iron or acrylic (the coarse works great on acrylic) is fast but carry over to the next smaller grit is a problem. I guess the bottom line is that I don't have a useful opinion on your question.

If there is a practical problem with a hollow grind, slight as it is, I have not encountered it in my use of these hand tools. It certainly has the non-obvious advantage of making hand-held(jig-free) sharpening vastly easier as well reducing the amount of metal to be removed in honing (steps 2&3) with its many advantages. If anyone(like me for example) has trouble hand holding while honing and you haven't tried it on a hollow ground edge, give it a try.

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#6

Something like this, maybe?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=44884&cat=1,43072

Got one of these, works great, I used a reversible motor so I can make the belt run in either direction.

With a 80X zirconia belt it eats O1 and A2 seemingly as fast as a grinder. On harder alloys zirconia is not hard enough (a piece of M2 ate the belt in about a minute). But there are diamond belts available from Viel Tools.

DC

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#7

Re: additional note

Peter Evans in Sydney

>Bill, if the edge is that bad, rather than grinding right up to the edge (you are especially game with a 100 grit wheel) I slightly grind at 90 degrees(46 grit 'J' white 8" wheel, 2850 rpm) to ensure a clean square edge. Then I do the normal 25 degree grind leaving a thin flat at the edge (to avoid over-heating the edge, it happens so quick!), which is easy to hone - on waterstones in my case.

Of course I try and hone before this stage, but laziness...

Cheers

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#8

Or, mount a belt grinder in a vise and go to it.

VLParisian

>

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#9

Re: Or, mount a belt grinder in a vise and go to i

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>That's exactly what I'm thinking of trying, VL. Denis, good idea, but the width isn't sufficient.

Pam

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#10

Re: Or, mount a belt grinder in a vise and go to i

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>In what sense, width not sufficient? Trying to understand your point here.

I use that belt grinder the same way I use a wheel grinder, I move the blade side to side and gauge my progress with a small engineer's square. With a light touch it's not hard to get a straight edge, or cambered one if that's what I want.

Am I missing something?

DC

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#11

Re: Or, mount a belt grinder in a vise and go to i

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I suppose you're right, I spoke too soon and carelessly. Interestingly I already have one very much like it, bought it years ago with a small table saw and other stuff. I didn't much like it; but the LV one is much better made, has more support behind the belt.

However, I vowed several months ago to not spend one more penny on sharpening gear beyond sandpaper and oil. I've got several natural waterstones to test, have the belt sander with belts. Accordingly, I could spring for some diamond paste since I already have a couple of flat surfaces that aren't being used, such as that table saw's.

Pam

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#12

Re: Or, mount a belt grinder in a vise and go to i

Paul Kierstead

>However, I vowed several months ago to not spend one more penny on sharpening gear beyond sandpaper and oil.

Good luck with that. I said that to myself a while back. So far, only a double sided diamond stone and a truing stone (to replace broken one, to be fair) have snuck by it, by the siren call of the diamond paste (and a plate) is calling....

Re: Some quantitative data on diamond sharpening

#13

Re: Or, mount a belt grinder in a vise and go to i

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Nah, nah, I haven't bought anything sharpening since making that vow. Now, for the year or so leading up to that I bought many natural Japanese water stones. Guess it all averages out. :)

Pam