Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

holding down long/wide boards?

Posts

holding down long/wide boards?

#1

holding down long/wide boards?

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Hi Everyone

OK, I've got a newbie style question here. I started working on my tool cabinet over the weekend and need to surface some rough sawn cherry. Before I hit the slippery slope, I'd face joint one side and then throw it through the surface planer. But now I work while my daughter is napping or asleep and need to use a less noisy method for surfacing wood.

I know the basic steps to surface, and have the proper equipment. But what gets me is how to hold the board down to the bench!

Trapping the board between a dog mounted on my bench and my tail vise holds it. But not as well as I like. Also if you use too much pressure, the board will bow up.

Using a hold down (like a Veritas) would work. But that means that you would not be able to get to the part of your board where the hold down is.

Is there a shop built hold down you can use to trap the board by the sides and hold it while you have access to the entire top? I've seen something like this for small parts. I checked the internet and found a really interesting set of simple stops I can make. But I wonder how effective they'd be when using a scrub plane, or surfacing cross grained with a camber bladed jointer. They look like they'd work fine when the wood has one side surfaced. But what happens when both sides are rough and have bows or dips? How the hell do you hold it down then?

What method do How do you hold down wide boards while surfacing?

Can someone give me some pointers here? I'm not above spending some time making some bench accessories or turning up my bench. Hell, I just took 30 minutes of "project time" to make a new shoot board as well as spending 45 minutes scraping the top of my bench to make it as smooth as possible!

See ya around,

My ugly mug


Dominic

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#2

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Dom, I usually trap the board I want to plane by clamping scraps around it that are thinner then the board I want to plane so that the plane won't cut into the scraps. Yeah, sometimes a clamp gets in the way but so it goes. One thing about using handtools, you get to be "inventive" sometimes. ;~) Sounds like you're really getting into it tho.

T.O.

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#3

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

wilbur

>The technique on that page you linked to will be fine. All you have to do plane into the "corner" of the pieces holding the board in place. For rough/bowed boards, just use thicker stops. You'll be surprised how well such devices work. I've used a similar setup on a Workmate-type bench with two plastic bench dogs.

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#4

Thanks guys!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I'll make a set of those stops after dinner tonight and give that technique a try.

Thanks again for the help.

Dominic

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#5

Use Go Bars

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#6

What are "Go Bars"

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Sounds like a type of chocolate energy bar.

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#7

Re: What are "Go Bars"

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Go bars are not candy bars, he he. They are flexible pieces of wood used to hold down large work. They are long enough to 'go' from the work on the bench to the ceiling, with a little left over.

A block of wood is placed on the work and the go bar flexed pushing up on a ceiling beam and down on the work. The bowed boards then exert a great amount of pressure downward on the work. Multiple go bars can also be used.

They are made of springy wood like ash, hickory or osage orange.

Stephen

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#8

Your on the right track Dom...

Scott Burr in fridgid Ben Lomond, CA

>Simple stops like you linked should work just fine. Let's not forget to add some shims to the high spots between the bench top and the bottom of the board so it doesn't bow during planing.

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#9

Gobars aren't the solution for Dominic's problem.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#10

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

Dean J in MN

>How do you hold down wide boards while surfacing?

I just plane against a stop, and if needed a batten (or battens if the board is long) held in place with a holdfast. So I guess you could say I use my plane to hold the board down , and the stop to keep it from shooting off the end of my bench. I think that part, using your plane to hold down, is easy to overlook.

How wide? For example, I was just working on a case side which is about 36" x 19" -- I just planed against my stop, and scoot the board over when I need to reach the far side. Nothing says the entire board has to be on your bench, I just let part overhang and hip check it to hold it in place against the stop.

For things in the more normal width range I can often get away without a batten, if I need to do some diagonal planeing I use the batten.

Cheers,

Dean

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#11

He he

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#12

Re: holding down long/wide boards? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I made a couple of L-shaped battens for this purpose, held in place by dowels in the bench holes (yeah, had to drill a couple of new holes). This works better than the two separate battens for me. One is about 1/4" thick, the other 1/2".

There's another solution that I haven't tried yet, for very thin stock, involves putting a couple of 1/4" strips on the sole of a wooden plane. This holds the piece in place without other support. You can see an approximation of this in St. Roy's show with John Reed Fox, season 6.

Pam


St. Roy with John Reed Fox

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#13

eh,...ok

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#14

For some reason,

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Thanks for the tip Pam. I also appreciate the link to the video/ However, I can't get the dang video to play! I keep getting the same message:

"Unable to locate server. The server does not have a DNS Entry"

Does anyone know a work around for this?

Dominic

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#15

Re: For some reason, *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>You probably need to download and install the Real Audio player.

Pam


Real Audio

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#16

I already have it

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Pam,

I installed V10.5 not long ago. That's the version that will work with W2K (which is the OS I'm using currently).

Dominic

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#17

Re: I already have it

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Don't know what else it could be, the video works fine for me.

Pam

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#18

Snapshot of the plane bottom

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Dominic, took a screen shot of the plane bottom for you.

Pam


img

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#19

Thanks Pam!!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#20

why not Pam?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Pam,

After thinking this over, I can not understand why go bars wouldn't work, surely it won't bow the board up in the middle.

Granted you would have to move them on occasion but it still works. I have planed table tops larger than the surface of my bench and it was one of the few 'clamps' I could use.

You out of hand dismissal of the technique is rather cavalier, without offering a solution. (But my response to your post was equally irresponsible)

Stephen

Re: holding down long/wide boards?

#21

Re: why not Pam?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I thought it would be obvious, Stephen, once you reread his original post. Dominic wants a way to hold a board down for planing, so it would require more than an occasional rearrangement. It would be downright obnoxious.

That said, gobars are great devices that I first read about on Alburnam. Thanks.

Pam