Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

anybody see Antique Road Show?

Posts

anybody see Antique Road Show?

#1

anybody see Antique Road Show?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Did I see gaps in that drawers's dovetails on the "5$ figure" desk? I don't get too excited about flauntable dovetails on a drawer but I don't have gaps like I thought I saw on the last drawer shot. And "$5 figures" for that desk? I don't hear of reproductions going for that.

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#2

Which episode/city?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#3

Not Uncommon

Hank Knight in SC

>A couple of years ago, I took the "furniture tour" at Wintertur. As it happened, I was the only one on the tour, so the docent took lots of time wih me and let me get up close and personal with many of the pieces in their collection. One of the things that struck me, and there were many, was the careless work on drawers. Most of the pieces had gaps in the dovetails. I first thought it was attributable to the age of the pieces, but on close inspection, it was just crude joinery. In fact, I found what I would classify as crude work in many of the unseen aspects of most of the pieces. Apparently the old masters didn't waste time on the parts you don't see.

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#4

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I have worked on a number of pieces from the early 1900's that had terrible dovetails but the drawers were still solid. Go figure. I guess those guys weren't posting pictures of their work on the internet :) I would guess that the labor scenario has not changed all that much and normally the aprentice would be putting drawers together because it is such monotonous work. I would guess that a lot of these guys were not into woodworking very long and some of them were probably just temporary help. I think the Antiques Road show is not bad for a television production, but you have to keep in mind they do need an audience.

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#5

gappy dovetails

Adam Cherubini

>Bill,

I've not seen a lot of that. You will see it more frequently in New England furniture and especially Boston. Philadelphia drawers are usually fairly good. There may be a gap or two, but usually not more.

New reproduction furniture routinely sells in the 5 digit range. Secretaries and larger carved pieces will be in the mid to upper 5 digits. And they aren't always nice and are never hand made.

Adam

P.S. The Designer Craftsmen show is coming up in a few weeks (check my website for details). This is the place to see what really is on offer, and what people are charging for their work. Bill, I think you'd get a lot out of it, if you can make it.

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#6

Focus on furniture not joinery

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>In the nineteenth century the dovetails on drawers were not seen 99% of the time. Dovetails on drawers were done because it is a good joint not just showing off.

The money side is all that counts. Examine the backs and bottoms of drawers and they are scrubbed with no attempts to remove the marks, no one saw them.

Back then it was the furniture, today its the joinery.

Stephen

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#7

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I will echo the other's responses about what was important in the 18th century. I'm not sure how many of us would want the old guy coming back and looking at our work. Today we see a lot of dead cloudy surfaces, muddy stains, and cold, plastic looking finishes. We see mouldings that are close to the originals, but lack style and crispness and life. We've seen a lot of hideous reproductions.

In today's market the dovetails are important. People who cannot judge other aspects use this as a measure of a guy's skill. Some people expect to see finish on interior parts. You cannot put down a craftsman for trying to sell his wares.

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#8

My Gappy Dovetail Design......

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

Well here is my first DT's, not an accurate version of the Philidelphia style, more Martian I think.....Gappy enough...

Photobucket

Take care,

Jim

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#9

clarification-it was an in process reproduction

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I tuned in late so I am not sure the city but I think the person's shop they visited was in Savannah or Charleston. The shell carving looked mighty fine.

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#10

Re: My Gappy Dovetail Design......

Adam Cherubini

>Jim,

I don't mind the gaps, but those dts look backward????

Adam

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#11

There back!

Scott Burr in cold Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#12

Re: My Gappy Dovetail Design......

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Very Good Adam..

:-)

I also did not mark the waste side and thought I was doing okay till I tried to assemble it, LOL....a great first lesson, Mark The Waste.

It hangs on the wall in the kitchen, across from where I sit, I see it every day, twice a day, I am reminded often.

4 1 1/2" #8 Robertson screws and some glue are doing well.

Take care,

Jim

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#13

Re: There back!

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Oh yeah Scott,

Not the kind of thing I like to use as a bench mark piece, but I have come a long way.....some say they have never seen worse first HCDT's, so they are inspired...

OH, the sacarfices we make to inspire others...LOL,

Take care,

Jim

Re: anybody see Antique Road Show?

#14

In my experience

Adam Cherubini

>Jim,

In my experience, things like this get less and less noticeable, but they never really disappear. There's something I hate about everyone of my pieces. I think that's just the way it is.

Adam