Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Planing Problems

Posts

Planing Problems

#1

Planing Problems

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I have 2 problems with my bench planes and I'm hoping you all can help me out. First, I have a Bedrock 605 with a Hock blade. As I use it, the blade retracts. It takes a little while, but as I go the blade slowly retracts. I have to readjust the thing pretty often.

Second, I'm getting terrible tearout. I was flattening my Bailey Block benchtop and both my 605 and my LV BUJ were tearing the heck out of the thing. I was also having some problems with the 605 tearing up some Sapele when I was flattening a glue up. I usually keep the 605 tuned more as a smoother to flatten my glue ups (although I was using it more aggressively with the bench top since it was not anywhere near flat).

I sharpened both blades a number of times thinking that might be the problem, but no help. On the bench top, it's certain strips that just tore to heck. I suspect varying grain direction and even some figured wood there. But, I think I should still be able to plane it without getting the huge amounts of tearout I was.

Thanks for any suggestions

Jay

Re: Planing Problems

#2

Re: Planing Problems

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I am not sure how much experience you have; I hope I don't say things you already know. The blade adjuster usually has some slop in the mechanism. It may be that when you added a thicker iron to your bedrock that the slop got a little worse. We generally end any adjustment with a move in the down direction, so the iron is being held by the adjuster. Otherwise it will slip some as you plane. For the tearout, try moving the cap iron closer to the edge.

There are several things you can do with your bevel up plane to help with tearout. I will let someone else comment, though, because I have not used one for more than 30 years.

Re: Planing Problems

#3

Re: Planing Problems

Dave Mount

>Multi-layered laminations like your benchtop are often very difficult to plane for the reason you state, that adjacent pieces can have the grain running in very different directions, and some may be really diving. In addition, the face of the bench is probably edge grain, and the tangential cut through the ray plane of the wood is often difficult as the rays can tear out.

Skewing the plane often helps; you can do this by taking diagonal passes (which you probably want to do anyway as part of the flattening) or by simply holding the plane at an angle as you make passes parallel to the laminations. The skew is particularly helpful with the ray problem as this keeps the cutting edge from hitting the entire length of a ray at the same time.

Something else you can do is to increase the effective cutting angle by honing a small backbevel on your iron. Raising your cutting angle to 50-53 degrees by honing a 5-8 degree backbevel (only a small one is needed) should reduce the tearout, though it may also make the plane harder to push.

Closing the mouth up as tight as you can will help if you haven't done so already.

Of course a sharp iron is perhaps the most important thing of all. We all have different definitions of sharp, but sharper is better when it comes to tearout (well, when it comes to most any planing I guess). Unfortunately, it is a hard thing to quantify in a written discussion, and "sharp" is not a bright white line, it is a continuum. What is sharp for me would probably be unbearably dull to some others, and this would be reflected in our relative abilities to plane difficult grain.

Good luck with it,

Dave

Re: Planing Problems

#4

Re: Planing Problems

James Watriss

>Re: the 605, I'm really not sure what the problem is. My suspicion is that the screw holding your lever cap is not tight enough. There should really be a solid "snap" when you put the lever down. The tighter the blade is held, the better off you'll be. Alternately, you might want to make sure... and I mean SURE... that your frog is being securely held. If the securing pins are loose for whatever reason, the frog will slide back, and up, a little bit, and that might cause the problems you describe. Without seeing the plane, it's hard to say.

Re: planing the block top, you're right. Changing grain is the most likely culprit. Thanks to good glues and whatnot, they don't have to worry too much about which direction the grain is running. They mill up the wood and glue it up. Changing directions in maple can be a serious hassle. But honestly, planing any factory-made butcher block is a hassle. I've had similar problems on other tops. If it was a top made by someone who knew it was for a woodworking bench, they'd orient the grain such that the thing would be planable. But if you're planing near a seam, you may be planing in the right direction for one strip of wood, and be all wrong for the one right next to it.

Best bet, honestly, is to try to go cross-grain, and hope for the best, or try a sander. I'm sure it's not what you wanted to hear, but it is what it is. You could try to rebevel the blade in the bevel up plane and go for a scraping action, and see what that gets you, but that's a lot of work, to get ready for even more work, because scraping that much area is going to take a long time. I think the sander is a better bet for that kind of material. Get it flat enough for what you want to do, without trying to get every last bit of tearout. Trying to take down the entire bench top that far will take a long time, for uncertain reward.

Re: Planing Problems

#5

Re: Planing Problems

Hank Knight

>James has given you some good advice. It's a workbench, not a piece of furniture. A little tearout won't hurt anything. I built my bench using a Bally Block laminated maple top and I had the same tearout probelms you're having. It drove me nuts. I planed for a week and ended up using an infill smoother and a #112 scraper plane. I still didn't get rid of all the tearout. I finally gave up. 3 years later, the tearout is still there, among the gouges and dents I've put in the top myself. I love my bench and don't notice the tearout at all.

My $.02. Good luck with your bench.

Hank

Re: Planing Problems

#6

Re: Planing Problems

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>My experience level is that I'm a power tool guy that is incorporating more hand tools into my work. I have used the 605 to flatten glue lines on panel glueups before the sander and I use block planes and a rabbeting plane quite a bit to fit things and clean up joints. The 605 is the first bench plane I got setup and working. So it has seen a decent amount of use. I don't know that I've ever used it long enough in one session to realize the blade retracting problem. But, thinking back I have probably had it as long as I've been using the plane.

I'll try your suggestion to ensure the blade is set to advancing to better hold. Thanks.

Jay

Re: Planing Problems

#7

Re: Planing Problems

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>Thanks for the response. I tried some of the things you mentioned that didn't involve resharpening angles. I have a LV Low-Angle Smoother that I haven't really used yet. I got a 50 degree blade with it, so I'll have to sharpen that up and give it a shot.

Thanks, Jay

Re: Planing Problems

#8

Re: Planing Problems

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>Thanks Guys. I made sure the cap screw was tight, to the point it is difficult to snap it shut. I will double check the frog screws to ensure nothing funny there.

I do realize this is a bench, but the tearout is to the point now where it feels like you could get splinters from it. I'd like to get it a little better, but making it furniture-like is not necessary. I am using this as a learning experience to improve my planing and am hoping that cleaning up the mess I made will help me in the future when it does matter. Making "shop furniture" has been my method of learning new techniques since I started out so there are many mistakes and issues with some of my shop stuff.

Thanks,

Jay

Re: Planing Problems

#9

Re: Planing Problems

Dave Mount

>Hi again Jay--

Couple things. While your low angle smoother with a high angle grind may reduce tearout, it may also be a less desirable tool for flattening the benchtop because it is shorter than the jack, and may therefore ride up and over high spots that you actually want to selectively plane off.

Seeing that you're a mostly power guy getting into hand tools (I traveled the same path) you may not be aware that you can also increase the pitch of your 605 with a back bevel on the iron. With your 605, the flat side of the iron sets the cutting angle (well, that and the frog of the plane). Most folks hone this side of the iron dead flat. However, if you put a very small bevel on this flat side of the iron (the side away from the primary bevel), you can increase the cutting angle of your 605. This back bevel doesn't need to be much, just 1/64" or 1/32".

I echo the other comments about just living with the tearout on the bench -- after all, it's a work surface not furniture. However, if it's really bad enough that you think you could get a sliver from it, I think you can do better than that by following up on the many tips in this thread. You may need to set your plane for a finer cut. Generally, the finer the cut, the lower the "scale" of the tearout -- a finely set plane may tear out, but the tearout shouldn't be as deep because the thinner shaving will break before tearing into the wood as far.

Best,

Dave

Re: Planing Problems

#10

Re: Planing Problems

James Watriss

>I can relate to wanting to get splintery stuff out of the picture. But I think when it comes to planing exercises, the butcher block tops are not going to give you a realistic experience... as I think you're starting to understand. :) It would be something else entirely if it was a top you laminated up yourself, with some care given to grain direction as you were gluing up.

Next time you want a good planing exercise, I'd say start with buiding a small rollaround tool chest, or something else that incorporates panels or you to practice on.

Back to the bedrock...

I'm going to break it down as simply as I can, which means I'll inevitably say something that sounds like I'm talking down, which I'm not. I'm just trying to hit everything.

If the cap is really that tight, I'd loosen it up a bit. Something's not right somewhere else. I'd look at the following things:

-Frog being secured, which I mentioned.

-Backlash: When you adjust the iron out, I'm assuming you adjust it forward, and then don't touch the adjusting knob. If you back off the knob at all, then the yoke won't

If the cap is that tight, you're probably feeling it in the yoke. If the adjustment doesn't feel really tight, something's not really contacting.

-Chip breaker issues? Maybe the chip breaker screw isn't tight enough. Maybe the CB isn't fully flat on the iron. The chip breaker is what's supposed to contact the yoke, and hold the adjustment. I the yoke is working fine, and holding the chip breaker like it's supposed to, then maybe the chip breaker isn't holding the blade like it's supposed to.

-Lateral adjustment? Is the blade retracting all along its width, or just in one corner? Stupid question, I know, but it occurred to me that if you're workign on that butcher block, it's possible on conflicting grain to get one side pushed in...?

-Blade seated fully on the frog? If everything is bolted down so tightly, there's no way that blade should move if it's properly bedded.

-Stupid, stupid question: How do you know that your blade is backing into the plane?

Re: Planing Problems

#11

Re: Planing Problems

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My grandfather's benchtop is two Douglas fir 2z12s laid flat and held together with cleats, and it looks like it was left out in the rain for a year before being dragged behind a truck. On that bench (well, and with power tools), he made more furniture than I probably ever will. Sometimes we get too fussy.

Re: Planing Problems

#12

Re: Planing Problems

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>A couple good points there. I may have only finger tightened the CB to the blade. I'll check that out.

I know the blade is backing into the plane because I would set it to be pretty aggressive to take a warped corner down and it would be working more like a smoother in a couple dozen passes and eventually taking nothing. At that point, when I run my finger over the blade projection, it isn't.

I think you've pointed out two possibilities for me. First the CB tightness, then the fact that I may not be adjusting the blade from zero to where I want it to be. I often take a swipe and realize I've gone too aggressive and back it off. That would leave the slop in the CB slot to allow the blade to back off. I suspect user error and there are at least two possibilities I'll have to examine. The second seems pretty likely since I could usually just push the blade down and retighten the cap and be back where I started.

Thanks for all the help. I'll try it all out when I get some more shop time.

Jay

Re: Planing Problems

#13

Re: Planing Problems

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Jay

I believe that Dave is on the right track, but I would like to suggest something a little different.

I agree with Dave that the multilayered nature of the top will make it difficult to determine the direction of the grain. As a result, even a high cutting angle will likely be ploughing into the grain and creating tear out.

My solution would be to use a low cutting angle (as low as you have) and plane across the grain - not at a diagnonal, but perpendicular to the boards. This should treat all the grain the same, no matter the direction in which it is running. The aim here is to flatten and level the bench top and remove all the splinters. To smooth it you may need to run a ROS over the top.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planing Problems

#14

Re: Planing Problems

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I agree that the bench doesn't have to look good to function well. I just want to learn something so my furniture doesn't look like my bench.

Jay

Re: Planing Problems

#15

Re: Planing Problems

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>Thanks Derek.

The bench is flat aside from the pock marks and gouges from the tearout. It feels like I'll get splinters from what I've felt brushing the chips off the top the way it is. I hit part of it with some 80-grit on the ROS the other day and it helped, but the tearout is deep. Hopefully some wipe on finish will seal the pits enough to make wiping the shavings off the bench comfortable. I do plan to continue to try and smooth it out more with planes for the learning experience. During the flattening process, the diagonal passes I made had less tearout than the passes with the grain meant to smooth everything out. The annoying habbit of the plane to auto-retract made things worse as I couldn't set it and go. I was constantly farting around with the adjustment and occasionally made it too aggressive and really tore a chunk out.

I was hoping that this much planing would make me more comfortable toward using planes for final smoothing of my projects, but not so much. Combined with my frustration trying to flatten a Sapele glue up with plenty of tearout, I feel like I've taken a step back. On that panel I had to make what I planned to be the top the bottom. Luckily both sides of that wood were nice.

I ordered the Chris Schwarz video Coarse, Medium, Fine. Maybe that'll help. I have some of the sapele left, so I'll make a panel to play with once the bench is functional.

Jay

Re: Planing Problems

#16

Re: Planing Problems

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Don't know if it's already been suggested, but one problem may be that your blade is simply not sharp enough. If your trying to ram a dull blade into that hard wood something's gonna give somewhere. With the dull blade in mind, and thus not cutting, you may be thinking that it's not set deep enough and set it deeper, thus making the situation even wirse. Even a sharp blade that is set too coarsely will create some tearout. I've never planes one of these butcher blocks, so I can't speak nor Sapele for abrasiveness, but it could be a case of after one or two swipes you blade has dulled to the point where it wound take a shaving, and thus the tearout.

You mentioned that you wanted to "learn something". Well Jay, I'd say that you have and that you are. Kind of along the lines, of "I don't know what's right yet, but I know what's wrong". Don't feel badly tho, such things happen to all of us no matter the years of experience we may have. That's part of the Nature of working with wood.

I have some tearout in one spot my softwood benchtop as well. I took a scraper and smoothed around it the best I could and let it go at that. The tearout is a result of some grain swirl. You'll encounter such problems many many many times over the years, so you'll have to decide what you can live with and what you can't. Sure, we all strive for perfection, and in the beginning we obsess over it to the point of being paralyzed, but over Time we realize that nothing is perfect. While perfect is desirable, I feel that often times can be boring as well.

Keep at it and let us know how things work out. Between the tool, your skill(s) with it/them, the wood(s), and your own mentaility there are many learning curves. Enjoy the ride, it will be frustrating as well as joyful. :~)

T.O.