Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

How I spent $80 today

Posts

How I spent $80 today

#1

How I spent $80 today

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Figuring that since today was the last flea market day of '07 I'd go ahead and go even tho the weather was over cast, and I didn't have much green to spend. Pickings where pretty much non-existent until I got to the table of one particular seller, where I dropped of 80 smackers. Coarse, I may of missed allot of good stuff since I didn't get there until almost 11 a.m., but who knows.

At any rate, this one seller had some planes at various prices and few other assorted tools, but nothing special--except for one I thought. Got to talking, then dealing, then haggling, and got him down from $105 for the lot down to $80, and I think that for basically $20 apiece I done pretty well. What do you all think?

The Everlast is 1.25 inches, the #4 is a type 5-8, the #6 is a type 10-15. All the wood on them are in very nice condition too boot. I really didn't need the 4 or the 6, but for the price I got them anyhow. ;~)

T.O.

T.O.


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#2

Am I counting wrong?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I count three tools, Todd - how does three times $20 equal $80? Or am I missing one?

Nice tools.

I'm intrigued by those heavy black things in the background, right behind the front knob on the No. 6. Are those clamps?

Re: How I spent $80 today

#3

2 of 2

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I don't know what it is for foe sure but I think it's a Birmingham. The sole is corrigated as in the upper side of the body. It is Stanley #8 size. One the lever cap is No. 12. The "patina" isn't really all that bad, I've seen worse on newer planes that's for sure. The tip of the tote is a bit ratty, and the knob is loose a bit tattery, but still, for it's age I think not to bad.

Anybody know just what it is off the top of their heads?

Is it so valuable that I shouldn't zap it and put it back into the battle against wood?

T.O.


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#4

I don't know Todd....

Scott Burr in cold Ben Lomond, CA

>I think you did not so well... Sorry to say. the planes are worth nothing IMHO 'cepting the Birhaming. The the evelast is spent, down to the logo almost. I would have passed on the lot. That's just me!

Happy New Year!

Re: How I spent $80 today

#5

I don't know Scott....

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I kinda though that the suspected Birmingham was worth the $80 buy itself and thus I got the other 3 items for free. Well, at least that the way I rationalized it in my mind anyhow. ;~)

Thanks for the Honesty tho Scott, I appreciate that much more then fibbing just to make me feel good. I tell it as I see it myself, and I can take it, which for me, is the preferred way to go thru Life. Lots of folks don't like hearing the Truth, but I do. Lots of folks don't like it when I laugh at them either, but I do it with clear conscience as I will be the first one to laugh at myself, and tell of something stupid I did or thought.

Now, for me to spend $80 at a flea market is just about totally unheard of as I tend to be very careful with my dollars lately a.k.a. cheap bass-ted, but still I don't regret this purchase.

I'm not a fan of tools behind glass, but in this case I think it is the best place for it as I feel that the way the frog attaches to the sides is not of good design and would ultimately break under not to much load.

Until I get a better idea of it's value I'm not going to clean it either as I'd hate to diminish the re-sale vale of it should I decide to sell it.

T.O.

Re: How I spent $80 today

#6

Re: 2 of 2 *LINK*

Walt q

>Todd,

Not a Birmingham...but even better!!

it's a Siegley!! circa 1893-1896+ early style(later one's had "Siegley" cast into the heel end of the sole)

very hard to find these in any condition and your appears to have good bones..though cosmetically it looks a bit rough

IMHO...minimal clean-up...I don't think it'll be a top shelf collectable but it's a good example of a rare patented plane

very nice and definately gloatable at twice the price..excellent score...you got good eyes..

the link brings you to my Siegely page for a later #5

walt Q


Siegley #5 later version

Re: How I spent $80 today

#7

Hey Todd....

Rob Brophy...lost in Niagara

>One of those #12 jointers followed me home years ago and it is still around here somewhere. I asked around about the plane at the time and it was suggested that it was a late Siegley, perhaps even one of the ones assembled by Hahn (?) from spare bits. This info is from memory and covered in cobwebs, so I could easily be wrong.

It's a good find and well worth the 80 bucks Todd.

Rob

Re: How I spent $80 today

#8

Wrong, wrong, wrong....

Rob Brophy...lost in Niagara

>...shoulda read Walt's post before hitting the send button.

It makes sense that it is an early plane: prelateral, fancier lever cap, and that nifty adjustable mouth feature.

To quote SNL's Emily Litella..."Never mind".

Rob

Re: How I spent $80 today

#9

We're a lot alike Todd!

Scott Burr in cold Ben Lomond, CA

>Your logic makes sence to me. Can you believe it!

I feel the truth is always better, even if it hurts.

Let's see a pic when the plane is cleaned up.

Rock on Todd!

Re: How I spent $80 today

#10

Re: 2 of 2

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>thanks for the info fellas. I knew it had to be early, but did think it was a bit earlier. I also knew that the odds of me ever seeing another one where pretty slim which helped with my decision in buying it. I also must admit to thinking that it might bring a fair dollar if and when I ever decided to sell it, which brings up the question of potential value. Any ideas? I don't really know where to go research the value of Seigleys at the moment.

I think it'll clean up quite nicely, but am not sure if I will clean it at this point. Anybody want to see more pics of it?

The seller wanted $35 for it by itself, but was anxious to make more money for the day, and I really did like that #6 as well but he wanted $50 for it which I felt was way to much. We started dickering with the and #6 and the Seigly. After much back and forthing, where somewhere along the line the #4 got thrown into the mix he made his last offer of $80 plus the he's throw in the Everlast. I felt that I was already beating him pretty hard as it was so I accepted the $80 offer by rationalizing that it was only $20 a piece, and that the Seigly was worth the entire $80 by itself. I must also admit to practicing my poker face abit for if the day ever comes I find a $5.00 #1 I can look the seller in the eye and ask if they'll take $3.00. ;~)

Got a fellow rust addict down here that I plow around with, and one day we went to a new flea market to us, and he stopped by a little stand that was selling mostly what I call "womens stuff" and dang if he didn't find a sweet little Keen Kutter block plane and he called out for me to come see it. The seller comes up and says "That's $5.00, and my buddy says in his best deadpan voice-- for I knew he really really wanted that Keen Kutter-- he says, "Will you take $3.00" which the seller did. It was one of the greatest moments of self control I had ever witnessed, and knew that was the way to play it when I found a $5.00 #1. Coarse, it still may be easier said then done. ;~)

T.O.

Re: How I spent $80 today

#11

Re: 2 of 2

Walt q

>Todd,

shoot us a few more pictures and I may be able to ball park an expected price

walt

Re: How I spent $80 today

#12

OK, Give me some Time tho

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>

Re: How I spent $80 today

#13

The Sole 1 of 9 

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#14

Back of Frog 2 of 9

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>The thumb wheel and it's rod seem to fused together. I'm not positive about that tho. Sometimes I think they are turning independently, and others times they are turning together.


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#15

Mouth Closing Slide3 of 9

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I'm thinking that with so patience and a certain amount of finesse these screws may be removable, bit I ain't holding my breath


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#16

Front of Frog 4 of 9 

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#17

Knob 5 of 9

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>The knob is completely dried up and slides up and down on it's post a bit. In the base of it there is what appears to be a bug hole.


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#18

Blade & Chipbreaker 6 of 9 

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#19

Screws in Chipbreaker 7 of 9

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I really doubt that these two little screws could be removed with breaking them.


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#20

Re: Screws in Chipbreaker 8 of 9

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>This pic is to show the threads of the two little screws in the Levercap, which I mistakenjly called the chip breaker in the last pic. they are pretty rough and doubt they could be removed without breaking them.


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#21

Top of knob 9 of 9

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Really don't look to bad, but it is dry.

I certainly appreciate the help and advice on this plane fellas. I don't think it's a user tho as I feel it's too fragile at the frog. Should I clean it(or not) and put it on a shelf, or sell it off to a collector as an artifact for preservation and prosperity?


img

Re: How I spent $80 today

#22

Your very own personalized Artifact *LINK*

Marv

>Todd,

I would restore it and make it functional. I would even make a new tote and knob.

Get some Liquid Wrench and squirt it on those screws. Might take a couple days of keeping them wet.

And get some Evapo-Rust. This stuff is great for removing rust from all non-ferrus metals, especially cast iron. It's a bit pricey but it really works.

www.evaporust.com

Good luck,

Marv


Rust Remover

Re: How I spent $80 today

#23

Re: Your very own personalized Artifact *LINK*

Walt q

>Todd,

I still say it's got good bones but as a top shelf collectable it has a lot to be desired...I think you can go two ways with it.

If you want to sell it: minimal clean up...soak it down with PB Blaster or even Greased Lightning for a few days and work it with a green scrubby pad or a soft wire brush (non-electric), what you want is to get off all the flaky stuff...you might even lightly use an SOS pad to impart a bit of a shine to the cap...that's more of a preservation clean-up...a Siegley in that condition and minimally cleaned may go for $125-$150 (your mileage may vary),. heck, you get two people out there that have to have a decent example of a rare plane and who knows.....it is certainly rare enough and you don't see many on the bay...

If you want to keep it...well the skys the limit...as Marv said..zap the rust with your method of choice, replace the knob and tote, wire wheel the bits and pieces and re-japan it...they're not the best users in the box but it is certainly servicable....all the planes in my modest museum at the store can be used and have sharpened blades but are cleaned very little. Sort of a kick for people coming into the shop being able to actually use one of the "rare" ones. Hey, they're tools and were made to be used!

I'd personally clean it minimally and hold onto it...it'll never decrease in value and may actually appreciate in value over the years.

BTW...is this the "saw man" Marv I met at LFOD in the fall?

still waiting for you to drop by the shop.

Walt Q


Brass City Plane Museum

Re: How I spent $80 today

#24

Re: Your very own personalized Artifact

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>thanks for the add'l info Walt. After much thinking about it I'm leaning pretty hard towards zapping it, and seeing if I can get those screws in the mouth adjuster and lever cap out. I feel as you do, if it can't used then why keep it around. Might as well get it back into usable condition.

I tell ya' I really really thought about it hard last night. I got to thinking that even if I do zap it, and thusly de-value it in the eyes of hardcore collectors is it going to matter in the Grand Scheme of things? Will the Earth come to a screeching stop if I took a hammer to it and reduced it to fragments the size of a peppercorn? Will spieces suddenly quit going extinct? Will people stop being cruel to animals and to each other? Somethings such as this plane are just not important enough to stress over because afterall, at the end of the day when the brass tacks are counted it's just another man made inanimate object now isn't it.

Thanks again all for the add'l info.

T.O.

Wondering what's so dang special about brass tacks anyhow?

Re: How I spent $80 today

#25

Walt...

Marv

>Hi Walt,

I'm the Marv who talked to you on the phone a few months back when Thomas Chase came to see your Disston #12. We only spoke briefly as you lead me down your long list of tools on your website until I found the saw. Nice saw, by the way....

Take care,

Marv