Re: New sharpening system...
Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia
>In my opinion, if you are looking to experiment, you really have to go back and try sand paper again.
To be honest, experiments (note the plural!) are something I am trying to avoid. Not because there is nothing to learn but it is expensive. While sandpaper may be cheap to get started it is expensive over the long term. The 3M PSA sheets are $1.90 each and about half that without the PSA.
I don't know that switching to shaptons or the like will give you a radically different sharpening experience. I think I've at least tried everything and for some jobs, I find sand paper best and fastest. I think you need to have that experience. For me, sharpening is a life long learning process. I can see myself using different means for different grits and different tools in the future.
I would agree that sharpening is a life long learning experience, I'm just trying to lessen the angle of the learning curve a bit by asking questions first.
Otherwise, I think Bill is right. Folks have have trouble with SS or find it lacking probably aren't doing something right. This is not to say that it is the best system and anyone preferring other media are stupid. But it works, and works fairly well.
My problem has been the media itself losing its bite too quickly. I was using silicon carbide paper but I haven't been able to find the alternatives that Bill mentioned. I also found it difficult to stop nicking the paper and tearing it without gluing it down. Given the short life of the abrasive, gluing it down became a royal pain in the rear. That left cloth backed abrasive and that is also very expensive.
Joel also has great prices on new Norton oil stones (I'm looking to buy some myself, actually).
I saw those but I have no idea what I should buy as I have no experience with oil stones. If you were to buy a new kit of Norton oil stones, what would you buy? Also bear in mind that I have to ship them to Australia so I might as well buy all that I need in one scoop.
Don't forget that you can mount these films to curved surfaces for gouges or the like. I've had some success with this for turning tools.
This is one undeniable benefit of PSA film and I might buy a pack for just this purpose. I'm not an experienced turner but I've never felt the need to spend too much effort on the in-cannel of a turning gouge. I tend to go straight from the grinder to the lathe. Carving gouges and molding planes are another story. They really would benefit from this approach. I have a set of waterstone slipstones but I wouldn't say they were my best purchase. They are really too soft.