Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

New sharpening system...

Posts

New sharpening system...

#1

New sharpening system...

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>Well, I'm in the market for a new sharpening system. This is a result of some stones being stolen (I suspect from the open house inspections when my house was sold!) and from the remaining ones being dragged off the bench and dropped onto a concrete garage floor yesterday :-(.

I could just replace my stolen/damaged stones with King stones (they worked fine for me) but as I have to replace them all I might as well consider all the alternatives.

For instance, what about a set of Shapton GlassStones as an alternative? I've read a lot about their Pro series waterstones but I know nothing about the GlassStones.

How do the Norton stones compare to the King stones? I've only ever had King stones.

Has anybody used the "Japanese Super-Stones" from Tools for Working Wood? They sound similar to the Shapton Pro waterstones.

I've used scary sharp before and frankly I didn't have a lot of success. Too much abrasive failure for my patience.

I haven't used oil stones before so I wouldn't even know what to buy as a set.

Re: New sharpening system...

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: New sharpening system...

Jack Guzman from Maine

>For a small upgrade you will like the Norton stones. Same medium,better quality.I use both King and Norton,only because I'm too cheap to buy all Nortons. I believe the shaptons,while many rave about them,are a whole different medium.I'll never go there, but only because they are way too expensive.If they were more affordable I think I would get some. Mainly because I've heard they are so much better. I stopped at Japan Woodworker's booth at a woodworks show and I think I unintentionally insulted the displayer with my reaction to the prices.---Jack

Re: New sharpening system...

#3

possible reason for failure

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"I've used scary sharp before and frankly I didn't have a lot of success. Too much abrasive failure for my patience."

The ill informed person(s) that popularized this old approach to sharpening recommended silicon carbide abrasive. Especially in the coarse grits, silicon carbide is much too brittle for sharpening hard tool steels. As a result, it crushes quickly and quits cutting. You will get substantially longer abrasive life from aluminum oxide or alumina-zirconia abrasive papers.

Can't help on the stones as I only use a 1000 grit water stone for sharpening kitchen knives.

What kind of low life would steal a man's stones! Maybe you can buy them back on ebay?

Re: New sharpening system...

#4

Re: New sharpening system...

Adam Cherubini

>In my opinion, if you are looking to experiment, you really have to go back and try sand paper again. I don't know that switching to shaptons or the like will give you a radically different sharpening experience. I think I've at least tried everything and for some jobs, I find sand paper best and fastest. I think you need to have that experience. For me, sharpening is a life long learning process. I can see myself using different means for different grits and different tools in the future.

Otherwise, I think Bill is right. Folks have have trouble with SS or find it lacking probably aren't doing something right. This is not to say that it is the best system and anyone preferring other media are stupid. But it works, and works fairly well.

If your blades are in fair shape (not restoration type work), I would start with a sample pack or even a few sheets of 3M micro abrasive PSA film sheets from toolsforworkingwood.com. This is absolutely the cheapest new sharpening system you can try. Joel also has great prices on new Norton oil stones (I'm looking to buy some myself, actually). Mount that film to corian, or glass, or a marble tile from your local home center. When you remove the film, use mineral spirits to clean off the glue. Joel sells many grits but I prefer the 40 micron and then one finer (15 or 5) or I use a stone for the finer work. Frankly, I couldn't tell much difference between the .3, 1, and 5 micron sheets. Don't forget that you can mount these films to curved surfaces for gouges or the like. I've had some success with this for turning tools.

Adam

Re: New sharpening system...

#5

Re: New sharpening system...

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>In my opinion, if you are looking to experiment, you really have to go back and try sand paper again.

To be honest, experiments (note the plural!) are something I am trying to avoid. Not because there is nothing to learn but it is expensive. While sandpaper may be cheap to get started it is expensive over the long term. The 3M PSA sheets are $1.90 each and about half that without the PSA.

I don't know that switching to shaptons or the like will give you a radically different sharpening experience. I think I've at least tried everything and for some jobs, I find sand paper best and fastest. I think you need to have that experience. For me, sharpening is a life long learning process. I can see myself using different means for different grits and different tools in the future.

I would agree that sharpening is a life long learning experience, I'm just trying to lessen the angle of the learning curve a bit by asking questions first.

Otherwise, I think Bill is right. Folks have have trouble with SS or find it lacking probably aren't doing something right. This is not to say that it is the best system and anyone preferring other media are stupid. But it works, and works fairly well.

My problem has been the media itself losing its bite too quickly. I was using silicon carbide paper but I haven't been able to find the alternatives that Bill mentioned. I also found it difficult to stop nicking the paper and tearing it without gluing it down. Given the short life of the abrasive, gluing it down became a royal pain in the rear. That left cloth backed abrasive and that is also very expensive.

Joel also has great prices on new Norton oil stones (I'm looking to buy some myself, actually).

I saw those but I have no idea what I should buy as I have no experience with oil stones. If you were to buy a new kit of Norton oil stones, what would you buy? Also bear in mind that I have to ship them to Australia so I might as well buy all that I need in one scoop.

Don't forget that you can mount these films to curved surfaces for gouges or the like. I've had some success with this for turning tools.

This is one undeniable benefit of PSA film and I might buy a pack for just this purpose. I'm not an experienced turner but I've never felt the need to spend too much effort on the in-cannel of a turning gouge. I tend to go straight from the grinder to the lathe. Carving gouges and molding planes are another story. They really would benefit from this approach. I have a set of waterstone slipstones but I wouldn't say they were my best purchase. They are really too soft.

Re: New sharpening system...

#6

Re: New sharpening system...

wilbur

>Hi Mark,

I've tried sandpaper and I've tried Shapton Professional stones. I was actually taught the sandpaper method first when learning how to use hand tools, but I've found that I like using the Shaptons better.

Both systems have their weaknesses. The weakness of waterstones, Shapton or otherwise, is that if you aren't careful, the stone may get a small dish in the middle of the stone, leading to a convex surface on your tool, which leads to all sorts of problems. The weakness of using sandpaper, as you have noted, is the ongoing requirement to buy more sandpaper, and the issue of keeping the paper flat on your reference surface.

The way to get around the waterstone dishing issue is to make sure you keep reflattening your stone at regular intervals. You may have heard the statement, "The more you sharpen, the less you sharpen," meaning that if you touch up your blade frequently, you won't have to have a big long resharpening session later on. The same holds for flattening a waterstone. I tend to reflatten every few minutes. This doesn't take that long -- just a few seconds during the course of sharpening.

The way to get around the issue of ongoing costs with sandpaper, the nicking and keeping the paper flat is....well....actually I haven't found a good solution for that. I'd rather just reflatten my waterstones.

I haven't had a chance to try out the Shapton Glass stones, but there are favorable reports from people that have tried both the Glass stones and the Professional stones. The Glass stones are a little cheaper. If you are looking for a good starter set, I'd go with the 1000-5000-8000 in the Professional series, or the 1000-4000-8000 in the Glass stones. But either way, make sure that you have a good way of flattening your waterstones, which you probably already have, since you already use them.

Re: New sharpening system...

#7

Don't glue use mineral spirits

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>It acts as a lubricant, extends the life of the abrasive, holds the sheet down and avoids tears, will not rust your tools.

I don't know how you can avoid the experimentation. Nobody can "feel" for you.

Oilstones can work better for you than you know. No rust but there is the oil. Diamond is faster, though just as messy and can corrupt your mediums fast if you get too haphazard with application.

If you're use to waterstones I would recommend staying with them and buying the best ones for you. Don't worry about cost. I've already spent way more than I should by experimenting. However, it is a hobby after all.

Re: New sharpening system...

#8

coated abrasive sources, more advice

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Places that supply places that work metal will be able to locally supply your coated abrasive needs. If the German company behind the US company Klingspor has a branch in your country that is a one stop source for anything you need. Enter them through their industrial supply portal rather than the retail store and get 30-40% discounts. At least here in US this company will slit any abrasive they make to any size and PSA coat it.

3M sheets will be available from some distributor, probably locally. Call national 3M number and ask for distributor list.

If you are taking more than a few strokes to complete sharpening on an abrasive sheet then you are using too fine a grit. People tend to take too big of steps between grits with the result that they have to grind forever to get previous scratches out. Rule of thumb as advised by manufacturer- don't skip more than one grit size in a sharpening/grinding sequence. I got many sharpenings from a 2 1/2 x 12" strip of abrasive. All this is described in our abrasive sheet Article in the Articles section.

Note how up to now I have resisted promotion of diamonds- the cheapest, fastest way to sharpen anything. Search previous posts as I am not plowing that ground again. But to summarize: I hollow grind on bench grinder, I straighten this edge with a few strokes on an extra fine fixed diamond stone costing a few dollars and then hone a few strokes using 1-2 cents worth of diamond powder on a cast iron plate. The bench grinder step is repeated only occasionally as the honing bevel gets large. If you want to extend you lathe tool sharpness, as well as lathe tool life, hone a few strokes with an extra fine diamond stone, or 15 micron diamond paste on a cast iron stone, after grinding on bench grinder. If you are cheap and consider sharpening a waste of valuable woodwrking time, this is the way to go.

Re: New sharpening system...

#9

Bill, Re: Cast Iron Plate

Tom Colligan

>You could save some of us some redundant research if you'd point out where's the best place to purchase a cast iron plate for sharpening and what size.

And, would this be solely for diamond paste or would it be useful for other steps as well? Tia, Tom.

Re: New sharpening system...

#10

The Kevin French method

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Although I have yet to use these, I have two pretty flat cast iron tablesaw tops that I plan to try out for this purpose. Haven't checked them with a straightedge, so I could be wrong about the flatness; but the price was in Kevin French territory - that is, just the gasoline to bring them home.

Re: New sharpening system...

#11

Re: Bill, Re: Cast Iron Plate

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You could save some of us some redundant research if you'd point out where's the best place to purchase a cast iron plate for sharpening and what size.

If someone would set up to make these to sell, more people would be using them. A few of us got together, bought the cast iron and had it machined at a machine shop. Doing it In quantity, they were less than the price of a water stone. I like long sharpening surfaces. 12" x 2 1/2" x 1/2" is ideal.

And, would this be solely for diamond paste or would it be useful for other steps as well? I don't know what "other steps" you mean? In any case I charge the plate with 1 micron diamond powder. 3 micron might work just as well; waiting on Steve Elliot to tell us that for sure. There are other things to know. Search the archives.

Re: New sharpening system...

#12

Japanese steel plate for sharpening

wilbur

>One of the ways that Japanese chisels and planes are sharpened is by using a kanaban, which is a flat piece of steel. You put silicon carbide powder of varying grits with a little water on the plate. This method is not as well known as waterstones, and is usually used mainly for flattening the back of chisels and plane blades. I'm sure that you could use diamond paste on these as well.

Kanaban are available at Japan Woodworker for about $43-77, depending on the size (10-1/4" x 2-3/8" to 13-3/8" x 5-7/8").

Re: New sharpening system...

#13

steel not equivalent to cast iron

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Diamonds don't embed well in steel. Cast iron is essential. To work the diamonds need to embed and become immobile in the substrate. They also need to embed just the right amount so that some sticks up to abrade what is passing by (your tool steel)

Re: New sharpening system...

#14

How about a big old round frying pan upside down?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: New sharpening system...

#15

Re: steel not equivalent to cast iron

wilbur

>After looking around some more, Joel over at TFWW and Toshio Odate might disagree with that assessment. TFWW has a less expensive, though smaller and thinner kanaban ($20), and the suggestion is to use diamond paste, which does apparently embed into the steel plate just fine.

Re: New sharpening system...

#16

Re: steel not equivalent to cast iron

Wendell @ Murphy, Tx

>I tried the similar plate from Japan Woodworker with the 1/2 and 1/4 micron Norton water based diamond paste. It did not work for me at all. The plate got all gummy. I tried cleaning the plate several times assuming it was some rust preventive coating, but it never got better.

Wendell

Re: New sharpening system...

#17

Source: cast iron plates for making diamond laps *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Bill said: "Doing it In quantity, they were less than the price of a water stone. I like long sharpening surfaces. 12" x 2 1/2" x 1/2" is ideal."

If you don't mind a heftier thickness (believe me, these stay put), Metal Express will sell a single 12" x 2 1/2" x 1 1/4" cast iron plate (gray class 40 - smooth, even grain - lots of graphite flake) for 15.71 USD. If you buy just one you'll need to have it ground for you or DYI -- flatten by hand against a surface plate; grind, file, scrape, sand, and so on.

If you want three (to use the method of flattening without a surface plate) the price is just 12.86 USD each.

Put your OCD to good use on this great cabin fever project (worked for me).


Metal Express Gray Class 40 Cast Iron

Re: New sharpening system...

#18

That would be "DIY" instead of "DYI"

David Barnett - SW Florida

>

Re: New sharpening system...

#19

And that should be 2 1/4" wide, not 2 1/2". Sorry.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>On the other hand, you can get a 3 1/4" wide plate for 20.65 USD. Three of these, though, at 12+ lbs each, would be challenging to rub together to produce your flattened troika... unless you have Popeye arms.

Re: New sharpening system...

#20

David's Source for cast iron

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>David, one problem with ordering cast iron from them, at least for me, is the high cost of shipping. I ordered a round recently of 7" diameter and 1" thickness and the shipping and handling was more than the piece. Multiple pieces make much more sense. Also, getting off my lazy backside and finding a local source would prove economical.

Re: New sharpening system...

#21

Good point, but USPS Flat Rate Box is only $8.95

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...anywhere in the USA. For short stuff I always call and specify either the 13 5/8" x 11 7/8" x 3 3/8" or the 11" x 8 1/2" x 5 1/2". Many suppliers* will ship this way upon request. Otherwise, yes, it can get pricey. I buy glass frit and metals this way all the time (esp. cutoffs on eBay) -- sometimes smallish (30 lbs) stone slabs for carving, too. Several years back I bought a few 50 lb boxes of lead. Didn't exactly please the postal carrier, I don't think. She was a little thing.

*I don't recall buying anything short enough for flat rate from Metal Express, however.

Re: New sharpening system...

#22

Let me know if you find that local source.

VLParisian

>