Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Camellia oil (!)

Posts

Camellia oil (!)

#1

Camellia oil (!)

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I am spelling it camellia because that is how it is spelled on the bottle. I have also seen it spelled camillia but am rejecting that spelling. I have been meaning to buy some for two years or so but have just used Johnson's paste wax on my tools instead. Now my paste wax is getting a little low so while I was ordering stuff for Christmas anyway I actually remembered to order some of the oil from Tools for Working Wood. I really was missing out on the good stuff and am posting this note in apreciation of my fellow WC'ers. If it were not for you guys I would never have heard of this stuff. I got a spray bottle of the oil and have been using a small cotton rag to squirt some of the oil on then wipe down the tool. It is just right; you can clearly see where the oil was wiped on but it spreads on very thin leaving a nice shine on the tool. There is a plane setting here on my desk that was oiled 3 days ago and the nice sheen of oil on the plane still looks the same as it did when it was first oiled. Camellia oil will be stocked in my shop for the rest of my life so long as it is available.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#2

Re: Camellia oil (!)

Tony Zaffuto

>Make yourself a plane wick--much more convenient and also very traditional looking!

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#3

Re: plane wick

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>You know they were out of stock of the oil wicks when I ordered the oil. And I just did a search on plane wicks in the hand tools archive and came up with nodda. A converstaion asking about plane wicks but no info on them. I have a lathe and am wondering if I turned a neat base with a hole in the center and then wrapped a cotton rag and stuffed it into the hole. Questions I guess would be a good material to use for the wick and whether you would put oil in the bottom and then stuff the wick on top of it or just squirt some oil on top of the wick. I was reading through some old Pop Wood mags and looking at the parrafin wax plane wick article but that one is not something I'm interested in making.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#4

Pop. Wood. Oct. 2005 issue

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>What made you miss the article is possibly the name, as they call it an "oil wicke". If you search the Pop. Wood site you will get a picture of the device.

HTH,

DC

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#5

Re: Pop. Wood. Oct. 2005 issue

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Course you could also grab a section of bamboo, leave the divider for the bottom, cut it off at the height you want, stuff in some cotton and camellia.

Pam

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#6

Question about Camellia oil

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am a frugal sort and have a question about this oil. What does it do that any light petroleum oil won't do, for example the oil used on brass instrument valves? Or WD 40, a mix of esters sort of like the vegetable oils?

In terms of composition, camellia oil is not much different than olive oil. The composition ranges of these two oils substantially overlap. Someone with a frugal streak, and an inclination to experiment, might do a comparison of the performance of these two vegetable oils.

Is it common to oil planes and such, and why? I don't and as long as my shop humidity stays below about 60% I have never had anything rust.

The thought of oil near wood does not seem like a good idea, though I suppose a very thin coat won't be a problem. I can see that a vegetable oil might likely be less a problem than a petroleum oil. Still, unless there is a compelling reason to oil woodworking tools, it would seem best to not do it.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#7

I agree...

Scott Burr in cold Ben Lomond, CA

>Oils like this are best left in the kitchen. A good waxing and a bit of parafin on a plane sole is all I need. Even here by the ocean, I don't have a rust problem.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#8

Couple of observations....

Wiley Horne

>Hi Bill and all,

I use camellia oil to protect my saws. Not planes. Saws. I absolutely do not want a speck of rust on these saws. In our climate (which ain't all that bad, I will admit), camellia oil works. I have an 8 oz. bottle, and it will last at least a decade, for $15. 4 oz. would last years also. Cause 3 drops on each side of the saw blade is all it takes.

Moses was not kidding when he said that it spreads out thin and then stays put--for months. Camellia oil is amazingly user-friendly. I spread it with my finger, and when I'm done, I wipe my finger off on my jeans, and that's it.

You've asked good questions, but this is a product that is not messy, does not smell, does not have to be washed off of anything--in other words, it pleases. It's a product that works (for me), and that costs $15 for a lifetime supply (for most people). In other words--problem solved.

I think maybe camellia oil has kind of a vibe that to some folks sounds esoteric and vaguely yuppie/trendy, and its very mention therefore aggravates them. But in China and Japan, it's very common and not at all exceptional. Used for lots of things. There probably are perfectly good vegetable oils at the corner grocery that will also do the job--but I don't want my saws to rust while I'm finding out.

Wiley

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#9

Re: Couple of observations....

Edward in Vancouver

>It's been my observation that all vegetable oils--olive, canola, grapeseed, whatever, will turn gummy within a few weeks when exposed to the air. Within a month or two, surfaces coated with vegetable oil will develop a "patina" with a viscosity similar to chewing gum...

I am not a woodworker, by trade I'm a Chef, I've reamed out staff for using vegetable oil on oilstones (you don't want to know...) for using vegetable oil to lubricate expensive machinery like electric meat slicers, or to use veg oil to "protect" wood topped tables and cutting boards (it turns rancid AND gummy)

Leave the vegetable oil in the kitchen

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Question about Camellia oil

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Bill,

You are lucky. I battle rust constantly.If I have a plane on a shelf and an inch of the sole overhangs the shelf and it sits for a time unused I find the exposed edge coated with surface rust.I try to keep everything oiled but I forget sometimes.Camellia oil has made it alot easier to keep this pest at bay for me.Not only is it simple and quick to use ,it doesn't smell or affect the wood I use the tools on.

I don't know about vegetable oils but WD40 is not even close to optional.Get a bit of WD40 on your hands and then eat a sandwich without washing them.---Jack

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#11

Re: Question about Camellia oil

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Apologies for the length of my response; Megan really wants me to wait until 8 or later before I start hammering on the trim in the utility room.

I understand totally where you are coming from because I am married to a frugal sort. If she can save a penny somewhere she sure will. Two days ago at the grocery store Megan and my daughter Mary both spotted a penny on the floor at the same time and dove for it simultaneuosly; it humored me. I probably would have picked up the penny too but certainly not because I was interested in spending it. It just doesn't seem right to throw away money. I inherited my money management skills from my father which translates in Pennsylvania Dutch to "I have no money" . I think about money quite a bit because I need it to survive in our world. My philosophy on money is that it was made to spend. They print it by the truckload. So whenever I spend money I am sure to get more money unless I die.

So far as using the same oil on woodworking tools that is used to oil the valves on brass instruments I know nothing. We have a piano, violin, guitar, and harmonica in our household; no brass instrument valves that I am aware of. It would be worth looking into.

The thing with my shop is that it is heated with a kerosene forced air heater, commonly known as a salamander. I noticed a few years back that when questions were asked about these it was always mentioned that they put moisure in the air. I am not a doctor so I really didn't comprehend this at first. Actually I am discovering that I'm not very bright at all which is strange considering how well I did in the public school system; the more I think about this though I realize that it is self explanatory. But back to moisture in the air, when the shop was kept warm and I worked in it every day it was not much of a problem at all. But when it cools down for a few days there is the crux of the matter. All the moisture in the air condenses on the nearest surface because cold air cannot hold as much moisture as warm air. So of the 2 gallons or so of kerosene it takes to heat my shop for a day I wonder how much humidity is put into the air? Not a doctor so this is another subject I am ignorant on. I did notice that the Veritas shoulder plane that Megan (the miser) bought me a few years back has rusted a little on the front where apparently I missed when I was applying wax. This tool is kept inside my wooden tool box and that is where it rusted. The bible talks about not putting your faith into earthly items that are eaten by moths or corrupted by rust. I realize these things are only things and I am the caretaker for a very short period of time only and I can't take any of it with me. But I don't think there is anything wrong with delaying the corruption of rust. The issues I have with wax, and I like wax, is that it does not apply very well to the tools. I use Johnson's paste wax and will continue to do so on any flat cast iron surfaces I happen to find in my shop. I use the infamous cotton rag and put some on and wipe down the surface; you can kind of see where it is applied, but I don't think it is a very even application. Especially on planes. I found the camellia oil much easier to apply than the wax, I think it will do a better job of protecting the tools because it provides an oil barrier. I think the oil tends to hang together; I am not sure what the term is but whenver you put a drop of oil on something it does not spread out thin, it tends to hang together. If you spread wax with a rag I don't think it has as much of a coagulation if that is the correct term as oil does. The only thing required to prevent tools from rusting is to prevent exposure to oxygen. This is what oil does. Wax does the same thing, also using petroleum based products, but in a paste form versus a liquid form. I think the advantage of camellia oil is the liquid form. So far as the type of oil and the cost that is up for debate. I think you could very well use olive oil or something else much less costly than camellia oil. As mentioned there are concerns about it turning rancid. Since it is not a petroleum based product I would have conerns about it's actual protective abilitys in providing an oxygen barrier. I should do an expirement; something I might never get to because there is so much to do and so little time.

The actual cost of the camellia oil of course is not in the oil itself, nor the bottle. It is the cost of doing business in the USA. Labor is the single biggest factor in the cost of everything; everyone has to earn a living. Then there is the cost of advertising, having a storefront and paying utilities for it etc., etc., ad infinitum. I think if the bottles of camellia oil were imported and sold by the millions they would probably cost about $4 each. You ask some really good questions which I do not really have answers for. I added a few of my random thoughts on the subject.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#12

Camillia oil

VTAndy4

>does not turn rancid or gummy. (And I would not use it in my kitchen).

-Andy

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#13

oil chemistry.... predicting performance

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Animal and vegetable oils are esters of fatty acids and glycerin. An ester is a chemical combination of an acid and an alcohol. This combination destroys the acidic property of the acid. Glycerin has three places to make an ester. These oils are "triglycerides" which means all three places have been made into esters. A typical oil will be made up of several different acids. Different plant and animal fats and oils vary in the relative amounts and kinds of their constituent acids.

The properties of these oils depend on the kind and relative amounts of the acids that make up the triglycerides. Some acids have reactive parts. Oils that have a large amount of these acids, for example Tung and Linseed, react when exposed to air and form a polymer film. Other oils have less of these reactive acids and they at best make a gummy film, which is bad news for oil stones but advantageous for cutting boards

Olive and Camellias oil have almost none of the reactive acids so they will not react with air to make a gummy film. As noted earlier, there is a large overlap of chemical composition between olive oil and camellia oil, so to a first approximation these oils will have similar properties, at least in the sense of them being a lubricant or antiruster. ( the relative amounts of the various acids comprising these oils varies with place and time the plant was grown) They may well smell different due to trace components, which I doubt will have any bearing on their use on steel.

It is the variation in the nature of the constituent acids that makes some oils a solid at room temperature (tallow) and others liquid (cotton seed). In the same way some oils survive high temperatures better than others, etc. So, it is no more correct to assume that all vegetalble oils will become gummy than it is to assume they all will be equally successful frying chicken. On the other hand, oils with similar composition will have similar properties, be it frying chicken or popping grain.

While the names of the acids may appear daunting, it is easy to look up the composition of the various fats and oils with the aide of Google, or a fats and oils text should you be near a technical library. The amount of linolenic acid is an indicator of the oils' ability to react with air and make a gummy or servicable film.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#14

Re: Question about Camellia oil

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Here in eastern Pennsylvania it would be difficult to keep humidity under 60 percent without climate control. I have many friends who have become millionaires from their woodworking businesses, but none of them have air conditioning in their shops. The humidity is awfully high in the shops in summer. I'm not sure I have ever been in a woodworking shop that had AC. When I got up on this foggy and rainy morning the humidity was 93 outside and 80 in the shop; it is falling as the shop heats up. I'm sure it was this way in the eighteenth century as well.

Since I use oilstones in many applications, the tools tend to get a bit of oil at every sharpening. I do oil my carving tools when I finish a big carving job and will not be using them for a while. I use the same oil as for the stones. Tools that are used daily are not in danger of rusting.

I am not sure I want to get in an argument about this, but I abandoned wax in favor of oil on my plane soles about 25 years ago. I think oil and grease are more traditional lubricants, and the thought of using wax again makes me somewhat ill.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#16

rust and oxygen, how iron rusts

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>this is turning out to be an interesting discussion. I enjoyed your tale. I think I would like your family.

Oxygen is a small molecule and it readily diffuses through plastics, oils, waxes but not metals and glass. Which is why you won't find beer in a plastic bottle and plastic ketchup bottles are 5 layer affairs that are very expensive to make...but that is another tale. (If it is still bottled in glass or metal it is because of oxygen permeation)

Rust is prevented by excluding water from the iron surface. If someone is really interested I can go into more detail later, but in summary rusting is the same phenomena as a battery discharging. On one microscopic part of the surface iron is giving up electrons (dissolving) to make rust while near-by oxygen (in one common case) is accepting the electrons from the rusting iron. To get the current to flow between these regions the surface of the iron must conduct. Water is essential to provide conduction. So, just like your car battery won't work if it is empty of water, iron won't rust if the surface is bone dry. (Amounts of water too small to see are sufficient to make rusting possible).

Oil, wax, paint, Arizona all exclude water from the surface and in that way prevent rusting. Big swings in temperature beget big swings in humidity and that begets rusting.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#17

A discussion of "oil" , wood & finishes

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have learned something thinking about this discussion. Petroleum oil and wax is chemically as different from vegetable oils as apples and rocks. On the other hand, the oils we use in wood finishes, or the waxes in shellac, are as similar to vegetable oils as apples and pears. Hence, it is reasonable to assume that camellia oil would have no adverse effect on any finish that could be used over waxy-shellac or linseed oil.

On the other hand petroleum based waxes and lubricants could affect the adhesion of finishes applied over them. These materials would look like a rain coat to a typical finish, especially lacquer.

Bottom line, my aversion to oiling a tool is unfounded if a vegetable oil or fat is used. Being contrary, I will do an experiment with lard and olive oil and see how it works. I keep both on hand for cooking, while I have no easy source of Camellia oil. BTW, a shop in Cody WY specializing in leather object restoration/preservation uses olive oil on the leather. And olive oil was the traditional lubricant used on diamond charged cast iron lapping plates.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#18

Wisdom ...

Paul Kierstead

>Actually I am discovering that I'm not very bright at all ...

Every year I discover more things that I don't know. This rate significantly exceeds my rate of learning new things.

I am pretty sure this is what we call wisdom, though I still have difficulty believing I have any.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#19

Olive oil and lapping plates

Bob Hackett

>I wonder if using olive oil as a lube for lapping plates has anything to do with the fact that diamond particles are graded using it and so it`s sure to be compatible.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#20

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Not chemistry, surface tension....

Jesper, Denmark

>There has been a lot of discussion in this thread of the chemistry of oils and waxes. I suspect the real function of eliminating the water from the tool surfaces is surface tension, not chemistry. Preasumably, the Camellia oil has a very low surface tension, so that it creeps in under any water film on the tools and forms a layer between the metal and the water, thus preventing the rusting.

An effective (but maybe not practical) way of preventing the rust is to keep the relative humidity below 50%. This is a fact, but I am not quite sure of the real function. Maybe it is that the molecules of water adsorbed on the surface of the tool are too far apart to behave as a liquid film, thus non-conducting and no rust.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#21

correlation of chemistry and surface tension....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The surface energy of a material is not independent of its chemical composition, rather the composition of a material is what determines its surface energy. Hence, two materials that are essentially the same composition will have the same surface energy.

To prevent rust the water repellent coating must wet(spread) the surface of the steel, and wetting is dependent on the surface energy of the steel relative to the liquid.

Interestingly, WD40 (AKA water displacement agent #40) is a mixture of esters of greasy stuff just like the vegetable and nut oils and waxes. Perhaps any greasy ester, such as Camellia oil, has the property of being a good moisture displacement material.

It is easy to see if a material will wet another. I placed a drop of daughter's trombone slide oil and a drop of olive oil(a surrogate for Camellia oil) on a piece of polished cast iron. Both spread across the surface indicating that each wet the iron. Not wetting would have resulted in these oils beading up like water on a ducks back, or in my case, water on a sheep's back. Wetting and adsorbed-water displacement are no doubt related but that is something I don't know anything about.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#22

Re: correlation of chemistry and surface tension..

BobStrawn

>There are three camellia oils, Camellia japonica, sinensis and oleifera. The oleifera is used as a cooking oil in some areas of China, so it is available much cheaper. For example, www.republicoftea.com has cold pressed extra virgin tea oil,30 0Z for $24.50.

I suspect it could be had cheaper still, as in some cases olive oil has often been adulterated by adding camellia oil secretly in order make a profit, and still pass most of the testing methods for determining purity.

What I want to know is if cold processed is better or worse for metal preservation? Are sinensis and oleifera good substitutes for japonica?

Bob

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#23

Re: Question about Camellia oil

charlie belden

>This thread seems to have gone in two directions - lubrication/reduction of friction and rust inhibition. What meets the needs of one may or may not meet the needs of the other.

Plane soles are waxed - or oiled - primarily to reduce friction. Planes with large footprints create more friction to overcome. Hand work, especially preparing rough sawn stock, is a work out. If you have much of it to do, and do it day in and day out, anything that will reduce the effort required to get boards "four square" is worth using. If wax or oil - that doesn't affect the finished wood surface, or screw up the tool - reduces the work it's worth using.

Frankly I use power tools if I've got a project

worth of stock to prepare even though I have the luxury of time which permits all neandering. Hand planes are my Zen tools, the ones that can be used at 2:00 am if I need a part or want to do some subtle little details - or when feedback - tactile, scent etc. is needed (power tools lack subtle feedback).

So, lubrication is more of an aesthetic rather than a pragmatic thing.

In terms of rust inhibition ( you can slow it down but there's no practical way short of chroming surfaces) - one of the woodworking

magazines in the last 6 months did an evaluation of about a dozen of the "rust inhibiting" products on the market from wazes, to oils to "special formulations". The methodology involved cast iron samples which had been stripped clean and surfaced. The various products were applied - as directed - left for the recomdended period of time, wiped or buffed and then tested. The tester applied drops of water to differet areas of the sample and let it sit for various lengths of time, recording observations of the amount of visible rust at different time intervals - up to several days.

Now I don't recall the rankings but I do remember that camellia oil was very low on the list when it came to inhibiting rust. For that I use Waxalit - or Mother's Gold car wax.

Re: Camellia oil (!)

#24

Magazine test

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>As I recall, it was Popular Woodworking, and, if memory serves, they didn't include wax in their testing, to my surprise; I find a good coat of wax helps a lot in resisting rust, even though it supposedly is pretty permeable to moisture (thus, a pure wax finish doesn't slow down moisture exchange in wood, like a film finish would).