Re: Question about Camellia oil
Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI
>Apologies for the length of my response; Megan really wants me to wait until 8 or later before I start hammering on the trim in the utility room.
I understand totally where you are coming from because I am married to a frugal sort. If she can save a penny somewhere she sure will. Two days ago at the grocery store Megan and my daughter Mary both spotted a penny on the floor at the same time and dove for it simultaneuosly; it humored me. I probably would have picked up the penny too but certainly not because I was interested in spending it. It just doesn't seem right to throw away money. I inherited my money management skills from my father which translates in Pennsylvania Dutch to "I have no money" . I think about money quite a bit because I need it to survive in our world. My philosophy on money is that it was made to spend. They print it by the truckload. So whenever I spend money I am sure to get more money unless I die.
So far as using the same oil on woodworking tools that is used to oil the valves on brass instruments I know nothing. We have a piano, violin, guitar, and harmonica in our household; no brass instrument valves that I am aware of. It would be worth looking into.
The thing with my shop is that it is heated with a kerosene forced air heater, commonly known as a salamander. I noticed a few years back that when questions were asked about these it was always mentioned that they put moisure in the air. I am not a doctor so I really didn't comprehend this at first. Actually I am discovering that I'm not very bright at all which is strange considering how well I did in the public school system; the more I think about this though I realize that it is self explanatory. But back to moisture in the air, when the shop was kept warm and I worked in it every day it was not much of a problem at all. But when it cools down for a few days there is the crux of the matter. All the moisture in the air condenses on the nearest surface because cold air cannot hold as much moisture as warm air. So of the 2 gallons or so of kerosene it takes to heat my shop for a day I wonder how much humidity is put into the air? Not a doctor so this is another subject I am ignorant on. I did notice that the Veritas shoulder plane that Megan (the miser) bought me a few years back has rusted a little on the front where apparently I missed when I was applying wax. This tool is kept inside my wooden tool box and that is where it rusted. The bible talks about not putting your faith into earthly items that are eaten by moths or corrupted by rust. I realize these things are only things and I am the caretaker for a very short period of time only and I can't take any of it with me. But I don't think there is anything wrong with delaying the corruption of rust. The issues I have with wax, and I like wax, is that it does not apply very well to the tools. I use Johnson's paste wax and will continue to do so on any flat cast iron surfaces I happen to find in my shop. I use the infamous cotton rag and put some on and wipe down the surface; you can kind of see where it is applied, but I don't think it is a very even application. Especially on planes. I found the camellia oil much easier to apply than the wax, I think it will do a better job of protecting the tools because it provides an oil barrier. I think the oil tends to hang together; I am not sure what the term is but whenver you put a drop of oil on something it does not spread out thin, it tends to hang together. If you spread wax with a rag I don't think it has as much of a coagulation if that is the correct term as oil does. The only thing required to prevent tools from rusting is to prevent exposure to oxygen. This is what oil does. Wax does the same thing, also using petroleum based products, but in a paste form versus a liquid form. I think the advantage of camellia oil is the liquid form. So far as the type of oil and the cost that is up for debate. I think you could very well use olive oil or something else much less costly than camellia oil. As mentioned there are concerns about it turning rancid. Since it is not a petroleum based product I would have conerns about it's actual protective abilitys in providing an oxygen barrier. I should do an expirement; something I might never get to because there is so much to do and so little time.
The actual cost of the camellia oil of course is not in the oil itself, nor the bottle. It is the cost of doing business in the USA. Labor is the single biggest factor in the cost of everything; everyone has to earn a living. Then there is the cost of advertising, having a storefront and paying utilities for it etc., etc., ad infinitum. I think if the bottles of camellia oil were imported and sold by the millions they would probably cost about $4 each. You ask some really good questions which I do not really have answers for. I added a few of my random thoughts on the subject.