Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

Posts

I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#1

I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

Roy Anderson

>Does anyone have recommendations about hold downs? are there design features I should know about? Should they be forged steel or is cast iron o.k.? Who supplies them?

Any suggestions will be appreciated.

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Grammercy tools *LINK*

Jack Guzman from Maine

>You said hold downs.These are called holdfasts.If this is what you had in mind these are great.Just drill a 3/4" hole anywhere on your bench and pop it in.Quick set with a hammer.Holds good.---Jack


holdfasts at TFWW

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#3

Jake The Russian's *LINK*

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I have these and love them! The price was excellent as was the service. I wouldn't hesitate for a second to buy more of them again if I needed some. depending on the thickness of your benchtop will determine the length of shaft you'll need. My top is right at 3.5 inches thick, so I got the longer ones. Best darn money I ever spent on a woodworking tool I swear!

The link I am trying to send is to Chris's Blog, so if the link no workee either go to his site and do a search, or go to Google and do a search for "Jake The Russian" or Galena Forge.

The way I understand it Phil Koontz is the point of contact for Jake as Jake doesn't do computers.

No $$$$$$$$$$$ interest in Jake's sales, just a VERY satisfied customer.

T.O.


Jake's Holdfasts

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#4

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencat

Dean J in MN

>I have a fantastic set of holdfasts from Jake/Phil as well. I second the recommendation, they hold very well in my 4" inch maple top. (No easy task, I went through several other makers prior to getting the set from Phil.)

Santa just delivered a pair of Gramercy holdfasts -- I needed to scuff up the shafts to get them to set in my thick top. After that (about 15 seconds of work) they work just fine.

If you want to save some $$$ go with the Gramercy -- if you have a little extra and enjoy the mark of hand craftsmanship, get the ones from Jake/Phil. Either way -- you can not go wrong.

-Dean

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#5

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencat

Ray Binnicker

>I vote for the Grammercy ! Got a pair a year or two ago; a couple whacks in my 3" pine workbench top and they are there to stay until you whack'em again on the side to loosen'em. You can't beat the price, either.

Ray Binnicker

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#6

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencat

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>a couple whacks in my 3" pine workbench top and they are there to stay until you whack'em again on the side to loosen'em

Same with Jakes. I'm sure the Grammercy holdfasts will do the job, and have been well touted for some time now, but to my eye they have no style, no character, no Life to them, just cold and bland. Yeah, they are a little cheaper then Jakes, that's true, but is not a the handwork of a real-life blacksmith,especially in this day and age not worth a few dollars more then the work of a mindless machine?

T.O.

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#7

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencat

Paul M. in San Diego

>I have a pair of Jakes and love them. I've heard great things about the Grammercy as well.

Just PLEASE do not get the cheap cast iron ones. I got a cheap taiwanese cast iron holdfast that broke on the first whack when trying to use it. It was quite comical. I've never had anything break so quickly when using it as intended. The "grain" in that metal was so big that you can tell it was melted pot metal.

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#8

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencat

ThomD

>They are easily made if you have the heat to bend the bar. Probably the most comon source would be a an OXY Acet source. What makes them better or worse as far as holding a releasing is concerned, largely has to do with geometry. A degree or so, more or less, in the head or foot angle can make all the difference, and the recomendations of others only go as far as your having the same or very similar set-up. if you bend your own bars, you can make those adjustments yourself.

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#9

I've got both

Gem

>I've got 2 of the Gramercy and 2 of Jake's. Both kinds do their job, but I find that I reach for the Gramercy more often. Only take one whack, and are shorter when I don't need the length.

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#10

Consider the Veritas *LINK*

Hank Knight

>I have a pair of the Gramercy holdfasts and a pair of Veritas holdfasts from Lee Valley. With the Veritas you can control the clamping force with a turn of a knob - very handy - and they have no-slip shafts. I use both and the Gramercys are very good, but I find the Veritas much more user friendly and I use them more than the Gramercys. The Veritas, unfortunately, cost considerably more than the Gramsercys. Here's a link to the Veritas:


Veritas Hold-Downs

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#11

This is what I use too...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I'm wondering why I was considering it blasphemy to mention it.

Old school vs. new school I guess.

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#12

If someone wants the Veritas....

Paul Kierstead

>I'll sell it to them for US$40 + actual shipping. Note that shipping is from Canada and that canada post are a bunch of thieves, so if you live in the states or in the sticks in Canada, shipping could be expensive.

Excellent Condition. Reason for selling: Too fiddly for my tastes. I like whacking things.

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#13

Naw, too much, make it US$35

Paul Kierstead

>+ actual shipping.

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#14

Re: Consider the Veritas

Wiley Horne

>I haven't used the Gramercy, which I'm certain are excellent performance and value.

However, the Veritas clamp is a favorite tool. For one thing, it doesn't slip in any thickness of any wood--even a little--no how, no way, never. One of the few things in the world that's 100% reliable. I also like that it doesn't slide sideways as you apply pressure--can't mar the work. Also, I often use it like a hammer-in type, with mallet or if edge jointing, just with the heel of my hand.

I notice they make em with the short shanks now, which could be useful in some situations, like when there are drawers below the benchtop.

Wiley

Re: I want to get some hold downs, any recommencations

#15

Re: PM sent

Dave Mount

>