Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

Posts

Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#1

Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>While I was in quarantine from my house (son had throat surgery, I got the flu), I stopped by the local Woodcraft, and came home with a mortise gauge made by a company called Lu Ban. No country of origin shown on the box, but I take it from the name that it's Chinese. It was $11 less than Lee Valley's, which is made by Crown.

I am now having second thoughts.

The hole for the beam is kind of sloppy, with the result that the beam doesn't sit quite square to the head, but I'm not sure this is meaningful. Otherwise, it appears very similar to the Crown gauge.

Anyone have experiences with both who can speak to whether they're comparable or whether the Crown is worth $11 more?

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#2

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

Dean J in MN

>How about no slop, no slipping out of adjustment, and fit your tools perfectly? :-)

Some joker did an article about a Seaton fellow and gauges. He left out the part about mortise gauges... I highly recommend them!

-Dean


img

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#3

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

MikeW

>Hi Bill,

That fellow who wrote the article in Popular Woodworking is the guy above my post...

Here are the regular marking gauges--



We usually fight over who's bench it gets left on. They work incredibly well. Still need to get around to making a couple separate heads and 4 beams to fit my mortise chisels...but will one day.

Take care, Mike

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#4

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

Dean J in MN

>Mike --

4 beams for your mortise chisels? You must have more chisels than even I do! I took a note from the guys at Wmsburg (thanks to a photo from Adam) and modified the Seaton design a bit... Hope he doesn't mind!

Cheers

Dean


img

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#5

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

MikeW

>I figure there are 2 I use most, another that gets used ocassionally and one seldom. So, yep, four beams--cause I don't like pointy things near my wrists--may give me an idea . Two heads because I often enough use two.

Well, hardly anytime at the moment for woodworking, so it's all theory ;^)

Take care--time to smoke some ham...Mike

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#6

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

MikeW

>I should add that I actually get along with a vintage Disston mortise gauge and for "secondary" mortises, simply use a single pin marking gauge and go off the single line produced. Works fine.

Take care, Mike

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#7

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

Dean J in MN

>Yep -- I often use single pins for layout out the mortise, after all my chisel defines the mortise width. I use the above pictured gauges to lay out the tenons. (Hence, I call them tenon gauges).

Cheers and Happy Holidays to all!

-Dean

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#8

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

MikeW

>See, isn't the world a wonderful place of differing means and methods?

I set my mortise gauges slightly wider than the mortise chisels (and so would make the fixed beams reflect that). I chisel to one line and I plan on the wasteful time to pare to the other. But I do use the same mortise gauge for both M&T.

The reason? I can saw a lot more accurately than I can whack in a mortise . Nah, just what I have always done unless it is a 3/16" mortise (like I use on clocks). The second scored line registers the paring chisel. A couple thin slices and it's finished.

Well, time to stock the smoker...Mike

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#9

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

I assume that you mean the gauge on the right, below ...



These are either described as Chinese or Japanese in origin. As far as I know, the LV ones are made by Mujingfang, which makes them Chinese.

Amongst others (can't have enough marking gauges!), I have these two. I like the single cutting gauge best of the two. The double gauge has been used for marking mortices, but it is not ideal here since the cut lines will always be staggered ... unlike the Japanese mortice gauge, below ...



I do have the Crown pin mortice gauge you referred to, but find it very fiddly. There is a great deal of sense in making up a couple of mortice gauges that are dedicated to specific mortice chisels. I am going to make up a few. The one modification that I would make to the design in an earlier post is that there needs to be a longer extension past the pins to grasp with the other hand. Using two hands allows for firmer cutting pressure.

Another choice is the wheel gauge from Titemark. I have this as well as the LV wheel gauge.





Their parts are all interchangeable! So you can use the mortice wheels on the LV.

I must say that I have not used these mortice wheels much. The above picture shows the wheels set up in the ideal way to maintain clean shoulders. However the wheels cannot be used this way (otherwise they cannot mark mortices smaller than about 3/8"). They have to be reversed. The lines are very fine so it does not matter.

At the end of the day I just find it easier to mark the outer limits of the mortice with a knife, then (as Mike noted) use a single cutter to score each line.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#10

Thanks, Derek *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The gauge I bought from Woodcraft is modeled on the same British mortise gauge that Crown uses as its pattern. It's the gauge on the right, below (also at the link, to give Woodcraft its proper credit).

So my comparison, really, is between two iterations of the same tool; and my question was whether Crown's tool is a higher quality iteration and thus worth the extra money that LV is asking over Woodcraft's price.

I've thought about making the same kind of "custom fit" gauges recommended by several here; maybe I need to take this one back and keep thinking. One of the traps I'm struggling with is toolmaking vs. stuff making. I could so easily fall into making the tools to make things but never make the things. Shoot, I could spend the next six months just getting my shop into shape.


img

Woodcraft's product description

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#11

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

ThomD

>I haven't used the Mujingfang,one, but that Japanese style is my favorite, for proportions adjustability ( one place where a cheezy captured screw is the bomb). I hate the British ones regardless of quality. I would have a hard time seeing how someone could mess up the fit of these though, since it is entirely made by router.

I do wonder what business people have (including me) buying these mortised marking gages to make mortises, well after the first one anyway.

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#12

Re: Toolmaking vs stuff making

Dean J in MN

>I find the small amount of time spent making these little tools to be a great way to exercise your skills. They act as little warm-ups prior to taking on the next big project. I tend to work in cycles -- major project, small tool, repeat. The small tool reminds me of the basics and is a chance to recharge. Plus -- I really enjoy using the sqaures, gauges, rules, straight edges, etc which I made. You always know who to complain too if they don't work! So, I don't see it as a toolmaking vs stuff making. They compliment each other.

Cheers!

Dean

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#13

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I do wonder what business people have (including me) buying these mortised marking gages to make mortises, well after the first one anyway.

I think this is one of the problems of not having an apprenticeship system, in which you get exposed to many different tools paid for by your mentors. By the time you're ready, you know which tools you need/want. OTOH, we're off working alone, no guides, looking for something superior to what we have. Therefore, we try many things, sell those that don't work for us.

Aside from that, what does it matter? Does conspicuous consumption offend your sensibilities? :)

Pam

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#14

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

ThomD

>I'm sure just about everyone's sensibilities are offended by some level or type of comspicuous consumption. Mine are not triggered by the purchase of a mortise gage.

I just find it amusing that we buy things that are essentially mortise and tenon projects in order to make mortises and tenons. It's not exactly like buying a bench where the time and effort required can be vastly beyond the scale of a beginer's shop. Nor is it so essential that one couldn't cut the first mortise or tenon to make it. That layout could be done with a ruler or gage blocks. It probably goes back to a time when each specialist respected the abilities of the other and didn't overlap their territory. Not exactly what the modern carpentry hobbie is all about though, is it?

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#15

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I guess, but it was devilish laying out mortises by hand, so to speak, all kinds of room for error. Then I started using a mortise gauge and setting it to the width of the chisel. Like night and day. And I could hardly have imagined or invented a gauge like the Kinshiro, what a joy, one of those tools that makes me feel masterful, even though I'm far from that. Not sure I could ever duplicate the performance of this gauge, and I've tried, even have a set of his blades waiting for another attempt.

Pam

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#16

Chris Scholz

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

Chris Scholz

>Most certainly Chinese. The transliteration of the characters for Lu Ban will most likely be quite different in Japanese.

Lu Ban was a scholar turned woodworker turned immortal (i.e. ascended to heaven) who lived around 500 BC. He is sort of the Asian equivalent of a patron saint of woodworkers. Much of the exquisite joinery and aesthetic principles goes back to his legacy. In Asia he (together with his wife!) is well know as the inventor of the plane, the chalk line, the umbrella, Feng Shui (encompasses aesthetic principles and other concepts). He also invented various automata and military implements.

Chris

---

Chris Scholz

Atlanta, GA

Galoot-Tools

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#17

Thanks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I did wind up taking it back - the more I looked at it, the more irregularities I found in the construction, and decided either to make my own or to buy one of LV's Crown gauges later.

Thinking, if I do make one, to make a scratch-gauge type, with cutters notched out in a V or a bead shape, sized to each mortise chisel. That way, I've got one tool (small shop) that can do multiple sizes.

Re: Chinese vs. British mortise gauges

#18

Re: Thanks

Dean J in MN

>

Thinking, if I do make one, to make a scratch-gauge type, with cutters notched out in a V or a bead shape, sized to each mortise chisel. That way, I've got one tool (small shop) that can do multiple sizes.

Bill --

That is an interesting idea -- having cutters for each mortise chisel. The only real issue I see with that is the marking of tenons. You have to mark end grain to mark the tenon -- I wonder how well a scratch type cutter will work for that? I see the real magic of mortise gauges in the layout of the tenon, as a single pin is fine for the mortise.

I'm not suggesting you don't try -- report back if you do; I'd love to hear how it works on the end grain portion of a tenon.

-Dean