Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT 'bay selling strategy?

Posts

OT 'bay selling strategy?

#1

OT 'bay selling strategy?

cooper suter

>I have a higher dollar woodworking item I'm likely to put on the 'bay.

How do you view the over holiday period for selling?

Are most people looking at 'bay @ work when they should be doing something else, or are they looking at home?

The other confusing factor is that this item doesn't have a clear target audience.

It's ideal hypothetical high bidder would probably be a professional woodworker, but w/an appreciation for classic stuff.

Business buyers going to be looking at the bay, or drinking eggnog for the next week?

Thanks, Coop

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

#2

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Well Coup, I'm of the opinion that folks are not only still watching e-bay at this time of year, but are willing to spend some big $$$. I say this because as of late AI have/had been watching several books and I'll be danged but in the final minutes/seconds they soared. Was watching one last night and in the final seconds it went from $38.00 to $56.00! No, I did not win the book.

I know nothing of selling on e-bay, but I'd say list it with a Reserve and see what happens.

T.O.

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

#3

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

Marv

>Hi Coop,

I'm a seller on "da Bay". I never use a reserve. When I'm searching for something I won't even look at an auction with a reserve unless it's something that is very rare. It's an auction. Start with a reasonable starting price and let people bid it up. A few sellers will state how much the reserve is. Now that's ok, at least I'm not playing games with unknown numbers. There is no reason to be secretive about it as most sellers who use reserves are.

Ebay is kind of a fickle place to do business. It's all based on luck. It all depends on who might be looking at your auction at any given time. A few months back I sold a handsaw for $760.00. Nothing unusual about the saw, it's just that two people started competing with each other. A couple weeks ago I sold a very special custom saw that sold for only $98.00. It should have sold for much more but the right bidders weren't looking at it.

One thing that I've learned though, and that is, don't time your auction to end on Superbowl weekend or Christmas or New Years.

I don't like selling this time of year due to the post office being swamped. Shipping this time of year is a bit risky. But that's probably just me.

Good luck,

Marv

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

#4

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I'm not a big fan of the reserve idea either. I think if a seller whats a particular minimum for an item then they should simply start the auction off at that dollar amount.

Now, with that said, as I said before, I know nothing about selling on der-bay and perhaps this reserve idea works better then starting at the desired minimum. I personally see it as a nusiense tho.

T.O.

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

#5

I'd wait till after the Hollydaze

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I'd put a reserve on it also if it's a high dollar item.

"Are most people looking at 'bay @ work when they should be doing something else, or are they looking at home?"

Both, and I'm hangin' here too!

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

#6

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

Marv

>Hi Todd,

My experience watching alot of auctions, when a seller starts his auction at a price that could also be a reserve price, it usually will not get a bid. I have found that starting all auctions at a reasonabley low bid people will bid it up, even when the bidding gets the price higher than if it had started with a reserve or the minimum that the seller wants. For some reason people just like to compete.

I start all of my reconditioned handsaws at $9.95. If it's an exceptional saw, it will usually attract some early bidding, then taper off until toward the end of the auction.

Marv

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

#7

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

Todd Hughes

>If it is a high dollar desirable item i don't think it makes any difference. I recently sold a pretty good plane [Stanley 196] went for about $1500 which is about what i figured. Didn't realise it till after i listed it that it ended on Thanksgiving...Did I get hurt? I don't know, went for about what I figured. I think now days proxy bidding [automatic sniper programs] are so commonmost people place thier bids long befor the last day. I do sort of wish I had went with the 10 day auction though;

If I am sure there will be lots of interest in somthing ...and I don't have much in it , I start the auction low with no reserve. The 196 I started at what it original sold for back when new [think it was $5.76] with no reserve because I knew it would go good.,,,,that and I only had about $40 in it.

I do use a reserve for some items esp somthing that might not have alot of interest amoung lots of people but maybe just one guy. In this case your reserve acts as a second bidder. Say you list a lever cap for a no.8 plane...Maybe alot of people don't need it but if one guy needs it he needs it. Starting it off at low with no reserve and you run the risk of him getting it with no competition. Use a reserve and it is like a second person bidding against him. I sell probably 95% of what I list , including reserve auctions, which I think is much better then the ebay norm.

To start your auction off high with no reserve is the kiss of death and is probably the surest way of not selling your stuff. No one wants to be the first in the water. Think about live auctions, the auctioner always starts out high and goes down till he gets a bid. no one every makes a high opening bid. The more action [bids] your auction gets the better you will do as it builds up competition....lots of people don't like to get outbid and will bid higher then normal because of it.

One thing I don't understand is when people will email me and ask what my reserve is for somthing. Most times I tell them if i feel like it and remember but why go to the trouble to email when they could easly just bid as high as they want to go and they would hit the reserve or not? After all if they don't hit the reserve they ain't going to have to pay or anything...Kind of don't make sense but guess some people don't think it though....Todd

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

#8

A buyer's viewpoint

Wiley Horne

>I agree with Todd. Anyone who is prepared to spend big money on a tool on ebay, is someone who is experienced on ebay and regularly runs his/her searches, no matter the time of year. From a seller's standpoint, a key thing is to make sure these people actually see the listing, so there have to be 'hooks' in the auction title that will get caught in the nets being cast by the buyers. You never know what you missed because your search didn't pick it up. In my searches, I include words to cover the more likely misspellings (Starrett, Starret, Starett), and alternate spellings (plough, plow) for example. If I were selling a plow plane, I'd make sure both spellings were in the title of the listing.

RISK. Aside from actually getting the item in front of peoples' eyes, the second biggest thing affecting price IME is how much risk the seller leaves in the deal. I think it's hard to get someone to pay top buck if there are doubts left in their mind as to the condition of the item. And you don't always write the seller to ask specific questions, because most sellers will post questions and answers--and sometimes it seems better to take the risk (and discount for it) than to cut everyone else in on the information.

Like if its a North Bros. 2100. I will go to the top floor, consistent with condition, especially on an 8", if I am satisfied there is minimal to no play in the chuck. But if the seller doesn't specify one way or the other, I discount for the lack of information, and don't usually write in to ask. If there's play in the chuck, the brace is still probably usable, but I'll never like it. If the seller doesn't specify how that 2100 is marked, and if the brace is pristine, I'm going to assume it's a Div. of Stanley one, and not ask. Because you almost never see a pristine one that is pre-war, and I've never seen a straight Stanley 2100 either. By the way, Todd H. _always_ specifies this information. In that situation, a seller who actually has a pre-Stanley and pristine 2100, is going to have to settle for 50% of what the item would have brought, if he had specified it. Occasionally, a buyer will bail him out and ask--but in general, it doesn't happen in my 4 or 5 years of tracking these things.

Or let's say its a plough plane. Something with moving parts, and its complicated. The photos have to be excellent to show the true condition of the threads, if its a screw-arm, or the condition and originality of the wedges if its a wedge arm. The best presentations on ploughs and (molding, moulding) planes will show all the moving parts disassembled and spread out. It's amazing how many times, someone will post a very promising molding plane, and not show the condition of the sole, the blade and the wedge. Sometimes the profile itself is uncertain.

In other words, the seller who really wants to get paid, is going to take the risk out of the deal for the motivated and experienced buyer. Because the buyer has got to discount for fuzzy or non-existent photos, for lack of discussion of key details, and so on.

On the positive side, something Todd H. does sometimes that works for me is to post photos out of vintage catalogs to illustrate some point or other. Extra info. like that gives you a warm, fuzzy feeling. Gives you confidence in the seller as well as the item.

Hope this helps.

Wiley

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

#9

The penny drops ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I have sold a little on eBay over the years, not enough to be especially knowledgeable, but enough to recognise the basic requirements. These centre around the information on offer - clarity of pictures, illustration of important detail, and a clear description of relevant historical facts and nomenclature.

However, reading Todd's reply has made another point clear to me. I was sort of aware of this from a few years of Todd's postings on the topic, but now the penny drops.

There are amateurs and there are professinals. I am an amateur and Todd is a professional.

Amateurs approach selling on eBay differently from professionals. They have an emotional investment. They get emotional. Whether the tools they are selling are surplus or one's they have outgrown or one's bought from the fleamarket to sell on .. they look at the tool as an individual item and a item of specific value. They have a price in mind and they already feel short-changed at the thought that this price may not be realized. So they start the bidding high.

To the professional (and I do not necessarily mean someone who makes a living out of this), the tool is just an object, a commodity for re-sale. The goal is to make a profit ... any profit (of course, the higher the better). Some tools are expected to realize a high price .. but do not, while others go higher than anticipated and are an unexpected bonus. If you are selling in volume or regularly, the wins and the loses will likely balance out each other.

I think the essence of selling like a pro is to look at a tool with some dispassion. Think of it as a used car or a refrigerator or a hi-fi amplifier ... not as a member of the family or as a Collector. Decribe it as clearly as can be. This is the advertising. Then there is The Sell .. start at a price that will attract Buyers, not at a price that will guard your perceived investment. Let the chips fall where they may ...

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

#10

Re: The penny drops ...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Derek, I think it's also important to not require that every item one tries to sell makes a profit, just that overall a profit is made. It's up to the seller to determine what overall means to him/her and price accordingly. I was really surprised 3 or 4 years ago when I was selling that so many buyers wrote to tell me they loved my low prices. Never could bring myself to disabuse them of the notion that I was setting prices on a tool by tool basis.

Pam

Re: OT 'bay selling strategy?

#11

Interesting.

Todd Hughes

>When I buy a tool it is either for me to keep or for me to sell. Not really any overlap A tool that is "mine" never gets sold and few that I buy to get sold I keep. I'm not attached to what I sell, if I was I would be keeping it from the beginng and not selling it. To be honest I got so much stuff there isn't to much that I want for myself, that and I am running out of room ...but I still keep some things of course. Also I enjoy looking for stuff more then keeping it...I often tell people that selling stuff is like catch and release trout fishing.

...To do good selling stuff you have to know what you are selling and what to pay for it.Period. Yeah you might get lucky a few times but to be consistant you have to know.Very dangerous to think " well I lost money on that but I will make it up on this"...Pretty soon you start having to many of "thats" and not enough of "this". I have friends that don't do well because they really don't know what they are selling and pay to much. Just because you buy it at a yardsale, small auction or flea market doesn't mean you didn't pay to much or that you can re sell it for a profit

I think in about 9 years on the ebay I only ever lost money on 2 items, not everything sold [I run about 95% that do though] and of course not everything made alot of profit. If you are going to do good you need to make a consistant good profit.

...One good thing about tools is that you can buy them cheap and if you know what you are doing sell them very well. Not to get to personal or brag now but checking my ebay records in the last 3 days ebay auctions I sold [17 items all tools] they sold for a total of $870 and which I paid $70 to buy. To be honest thought these were "Good" auctions, probably better then avarage , bought cheaper and sold higher, but nothing to far out of the norm. I usually figure for every $100 I spend for a group of items I want to make $500.Don't always of course but usualy stay around that overall. you make your money when you buy the stuff.

There is absolutly no shortage of stuff to buy and sell out there...I could easly sell 3 times what I do if I wasn't lazy and wanted to. I never have real trouble finding stuff though I do know dealers that do. This is because they don't know what to buy and pass up stuff they should buy[and maybe buy stuff they shouldn't]. I take the approach to do well you have to know what is is that you are selling and am big on buying books and doing research etc. To do well you have to know more then the people you are buying from as well as others that might be your competition in buying stuff.....Todd