WE MOVED...
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Hollows & Rounds

Posts

Hollows & Rounds

#1

Hollows & Rounds

Kevin Adams

>Hi all--

I was thinking about trying out some H&R's for an upcoming project and am looking around at different options. It looks like anything from picking up some used ones (hoping they work) all the way up to C&W's masterpieces (and what I understand now is at least a one year wait). I also spotted these Chinese-style planes at Japan Woodworker and was curious if anyone had experience:

http://japanwoodworker.com/product.asp?s=JapanWoodworker&pf_id=98%2E120%2E1025&dept_id=13602

I know quite a few folks have been pleased with their Mujingfang planes, so I'm wondering if trying a couple might be in order here? I might contact JW to see what their honest assessment is. I don't own any Mujingfangs now, but I do have several planes by Terry Gordon (which I am very fond of), so I have also emailed Terry to see if he might be able to make some.

Thanks for any advice you can offer.

Kevin

Re: Hollows & Rounds

#2

Re: Hollows & Rounds *LINK*

barryvabeach

>Kevin, After making one pair on my own from the Todd Herli video, I bought an old half set of English H & R's. Looking back it was not a brilliant move in the use v dollars. If you buy a half set, assume you will spend a lot of time tuning up each plane so that the iron exactly matches the sole. Think back to when you first started using a bench plane and tried to adjust the lateral lever to get the blade to project evenly - except, there is no adjuster - so I spent a lot of time sharpening and adjusting the arc of the blade to match the profile. In the end though, I don't know that I have ever used the 3 or 4 biggest planes and so that was a waste of money in buying them and time in tuning them . IIRC a half set is 9 rounds and 9 hollows, my suggestion is that you pick up a few pairs of old hollows and rounds and them fill in as you need to. With the work I do, the 3 - 4 smallest sizes see the most action. Since there is no one measuring system, it is hard to give you numbers


sizing hollows

Re: Hollows & Rounds

#3

Re: Hollows & Rounds

John Hoffman

>Yes, I would like the same question answered. I would like to try the molding Adam made for the standing desk using hollow and rounds but would like advice on where to get them other than the obvious C&W.

Thanks

Re: Hollows & Rounds

#5

Re: Hollows & Rounds

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have used hollows and rounds for many years. If you have a plow and a moving fillester (rabbet with a fence) and a set of h & r you can make almost anything, and I do some business in matching old moldings. For a short run it is much cheaper than grinding a cutter and setting up a molder.

I have an assortment of old planes. They can require several hours of work to get them working nicely, but once they are in good shape there isn't much maintenance. I have planes bedded at 45 50 55 and 60. I prefer the lower angles for both hardwood and softwood. I have made some molding planes for special purposes, but generally there are plenty of odd h & r around. It would be nicer to have a matched set.

I think the planes at Japan woodworker are a bit smaller than our western standards, but I'm sure they would work. If you bought a pair of 3/8 planes, you could make a cove, an ovolo, an ogee, etc, probably six or eight different moldings if you are creative. I think this would be a good introduction to this type of work.

Re: Hollows & Rounds

#6

the JW planes revealed, and an editorial

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>My experience with hollows and rounds made me appreciate a router and router table and/or the brute force approach of wasting out what you can and scraping the rest. This latter approach turns out to be faster than I imagined before trying it.

I tried the used route. Good luck finding what you need when you need it. I don't want to ever see another pit(s) in old iron that needs to be ground out...slowly. And then once the plane is restored one discovers, duh, it is still a plane with all its potential tear out issues, which are more problematic than with a finely tuned bench plane. So my advice would be to consider making moldings with these things after you become confident and proficient planing flat surfaces. There may be one advantage with the molding; potentially you can choose easy to plane lumber for moldings where for tops and the like one may be choosing lumber for looks and not easiness to plane.

The Japan Woodworker planes are tiny little affairs with cheesy thin irons. I use the one I bought for taking sharp edges off pieces of very straight grained easy to work lumber. The wood in them is pretty and they might be a nice addition to a toy tool chest.

Re: Hollows & Rounds

#7

Re: Hollows & Rounds

MikeW

>Kevin,

Consider calling people like Lee Richmond at The Best Things. Aside from having half-sets, he may well have pairs and or singles you can buy and see if using H&Rs is for you.

Buying from a dealer, while typically more expensive than eBay is far less a risk. You'll also be able to ask questions from a dealer like Lee and get intelligent answers.

I bought my first half-set from Murland years ago for a reasonable cost--the prices on the Murland web site include shipping to the US. I had mixed pairs before that and each was relatively easy to put into usable shape. I agree with whoever posted about the smaller sizes. I doubt I used above the #8 on any kind of regular basis and usually smaller.

Wiley mentioned Andrew at Inchmartine in the plow thread. Andrew is a great guy as well for picking up vintage tools.

Though I haven't seen it yet (don't know if it is yet available) also consider Don McConnell's DVD on using them. If not yet available, it will be soon enough via LN.

Take care, Mike

Re: Hollows & Rounds

#8

Re: Hollows & Rounds

ThomD

>I have one pair of the Mugwhatever hollows and rounds. They seem like good quality to me, I had no problem using them. It was one of the things that made want to get a real set of H&R.

The fact they have thin blades is irrelevant, might as well complain that trad H&Rs have discontinuous ones. As Krenov pointed out many moons ago, thin blades are not necesarilly less effective, or stiff in use than thicker ones, though I prefer thick ones. One thing to keep in mind is that with wacked shapes the thicker blade edges are still going to be tricky to sharpen and having them a little thinner just means less work. These are not planes intended to take a half-thou shaving, so the tactics can be varied.

However, these planes do not have the same shapes as the western H&R, I'm not sure they fit our architectural needs for moldings. The shapes on mine seem a little deeper than some. The place I got mine they sold only a pair not the full sets. The pair they sold were not male female counterparts, though perhaps those exist is sets. The size of the planes does vary with the size of the radius, which is not appealing for those doing straight architectural cuts, though it might make sense in some forms of curvy furniture. The convex planes don't have a stop, so when you get to the full shape they keep on cutting, which would be incomvenient for running moldins.

Re: Hollows & Rounds

#9

Thanks Everyone

Kevin Adams

>I appreciate all the responses. I thought about going the used route like from a Lee Richmond or Tony in the UK (both of where I have purchased before). I may end up doing that still or just try a couple of the smaller JW ones. If anyone is interested, I also heard back from Terry Gordon Downunder and he thinks he may be able to start offering some in '08. He's going to try anyway. At this point, I believe he is thinking about sizes 1/2", 3/4", 1" and 1-1/4". I would presume the same thick irons that he uses for his other planes and higher angles (but I don't know that for sure).

Thanks again and hope everyone has a Happy Holiday and New Year ahead!

Kevin

Re: Hollows & Rounds

#10

Some late tips

jim reed @ tallahassee

>My experience with H&R planes is that you want a set and that set should be york pitched for hardwoods AND from the same maker. The most handy planes are the #2-6 hollows and the #4-10 rounds. Others are less used and I think that is why you see the larger ones in the wild and in good shape. No need for stops on H&R planes because they quit cutting when the proper profile is achieved. It is quite satisfying using a good set of these planes to make a complex moulding. Also amazingly quick. Good luck in your quest.