We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Been away for a while, dealing with life. Having moved away from my shop, I'm now setting up a small hand-tool-only workspace in a building that rents studio space to a variety of artists and artisans. I've a question about frame saws (my first two projects are to be a frame saw and bow saw). Has anyone ever seen or heard of a frame saw with a fence? I'm thinking an adjustable fence, parallel to the saw blade - seems it would make resawing more accurate and easier. Or would it just bind? Whaddya think?
-Peter
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw question
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw questio
Adam Cherubini
>yeah- I don't think a fence will help. On a power saw, the blade has a good bit of inertia. And you can also steer a power saw by forcing it, is that right?
With a hand saw, you aren't going to get inertia so the blade will just pull away from the fence. And you can't force the blade left or right or twist it back to the line.
Resawing by hand is not that technically difficult. Depending on the saw, it can be strenuous. Just learn to saw the corners out then saw every board with every saw the exact same way and you'll be okay.
Adam
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw question
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw questio
Peter Berglund
>Thanks Adam. I've seen the pictures of starting on the corners. When you say "Depending on the saw", do you mean it would be less strenuous with a low tpi? Strenuous, I'm going to have to learn to deal with. More fun than the gym.
-Peter
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw question
>Well tpi is one factor. A better way to say it would be how aggressive the saw is. And obviously the stock will inevitably decide how strenuous the job is. And also there are different types of strenuous. A slow cutting saw that takes forever to finish a cut is strenuous in a different sort of way.
adam
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw question
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw questio
ThomD
>Before I got a bandsaw, I made a hrizontal frame saw using the most agressive German bowsaw blade I could find. They are designed for resawing wood. They are also really cheap, less than 10 bucks. Stay away from the ones with Japanese teeth, they are rough crosscut formated teeth, at least the ones I have found. Putsch is a good name in blades.
Ive spent up to 500 bucks for a rip saw, but long before you reach that point, or even the cost of a new bowsaw and a bunch of blades, you could probably snag something off of craigslist.
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw question
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw questio
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>The fence will probably not work as others have mentioned. If you are resawing wide boards your saw needs to have few teeth with big gullets to be able to discharge the saw dust.
The thicker the board the fewer tpi. On thin boards clearing the gullets on finer toothed blades is easier, but will present problems on thicker boards, no where for the saw dust to go.
Stephen
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw question
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw questio
Marv
>Peter,
It might work ok when sawing narrow pieces but the wider or thicker the piece to be cut off and the farther from the blade the fence is, the more tendency for binding. The fence should be as lightweight as possible and produce minimum friction, maybe use a 1/4" dia. steel rod, tubing would be even better, less weight. Maybe use Chrome-moly. It's extremely tough and light weight. Chrome-moly is used for race car frames and motorcycle frames and can be worked pretty much like cold-roll steel. With chrome-moly, thinner wall, larger diameter might the way to go....say .031 wall thickness x 3/8 O.D.
It's an interesting idea and I think you should pursue it.
Unless your fence can produce a perfectly square and straight finished cut, seems that it's simpler to just saw to a line.
How thick of material do you intend to resaw?
What do you feel is the advantage of using a frame saw compared to using a rip handsaw? Is it the interchangeability and replacement of the blades? Is it because the blades perform similar to a bandsaw?
Marv
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw question
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw questio
Peter Berglund
>because a frame saw is cool, that's why! Plus, I like making tools. But I do have an old ripsaw, and sharpening it will be my -actual- first project. I also think (without having any experience with frame saws) that it might be easier to saw to the line because the blade is under tension.
-Peter
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw question
Re: Returning after hiatus, with frame saw questio
Adam Cherubini
>"I also think that it might be easier to saw to the line because the blade is under tension"
I don't think so. Tension is not a design enhancement. Its what you must do if your country didn't develop rolling mills to produce sheet steel inexpensively. The frame does let you "get away with" a thinner blade. In theory, this should make the saw cut faster. But anglo america pit sawyers gave up framed pit saws in favor of thicker unframed saws early in the 18th c. So that tells you something. No the frame is not going to help you track. The frame's chief advantage as far as I'm concerned is that you can push a really long saw by yourself and horizontally. In the 18th c, the frame was probably there because the saw was iron or so brittle it would crack if it bent sideways or so soft it would kink.
One more thing: I don't see any technical difference between resawing 12-20" lumber, and a pitsaw operation. Why anybody thinks they can do this quickly and easily without a friend and an 8' saw escapes me. This sort of work has been done and we need only look to see what the solution to this problem was. Pretty sure Roubo talked about sending out boards for resawing (to the saw pit) unless they were small and then he would get his "valets" to do it in house. I don't think a lot of this sort of work was done in house precisely because it is so time consuming and laborious. It may be one of the reasons veneer was such a big deal. We know the French had machines to cut veneer in the 18th c.
Adam
P.S. If you are interested in 18th c furniture, sawing is what it is all about.