A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Recently, Thomas Lie-Nielsen released a �hotdog� handle for the LN LA Jack. This looks to be a version of the handle that is in production for their #9, the mitre plane, and itself based on the original Stanley #9, which is long since out of production.
Although the round depressions in the side of the Veritas (Lee Valley) LAJ are designed as handholds, these are fatiguing if used over a long planing session. I had been toying with the idea of making a hotdog handle for the LA Jack for some time, and the timing was now right to get it done (well, what do you do when waiting for glue to dry?).
The only complication I could see would be that the LN has an advantage in that the hotdog�s mortice would fit over a symmetrical curved side, which is easier to make compared to the LV�s asymmetrical side. Then again, this could be an advantage if one went for a friction fit (the LN is held on with a screw).
Step one is to turn the basic hotdog shape on a lathe. I have a little Jet Mini that is perfect for these jobs. If you don�t have a lathe, pop around for a beer and a chat, and we�ll turn one out in no time (it is a 5 minute job). Oh what�s that, I�m in Perth, Australia �
The hotdog I turned came from a bit of Jarrah (sort of matches the Bubinga knob, and I already had a replacement Jarrah tote .. don�t ask). The final dimensions were 5� long and 1 �� diameter at the center.
Step two was to cut the mortice to slide the hotdog onto the side of the plane. Now I am sure that I did this the hard way, that there must be more efficient methods � if so, I apologize. Step two began with marking out and sawing the outline of the mortice. I used a Japanese saw here as the action is gentler and cleaner than a Western saw (I would kill for a patternmaker�s vise!).
Step three is to chisel out the waste. This is where the fun begins! I used two mortice chisels, one was 1/8� wide (easier to dig out waste with this) and the other � the correct sizing for the slot � was 5/16� wide.
This process was basically done by eye� chisel a little, test fit, chisel some more. Here is a test fit.
Finally the fit was close enough�
� and the LAJ with hotdog was tested out on the shooting board.
How does it feel? Just perfect. Very comfortable indeed. A permanent addition.
Regards from Perth
Derek
December 2007
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#2Small correction
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Small correction to article (why can't we edit posts?) ...
The second chisel should read 3/16" wide (not 5/16").
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#3Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX
>Like most good ideas, a simple one as well. Very well done.
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#4Looks nice, but I don't get it...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA
>You say it's a friction fit. Could you please explain?
I figure it would come off during planing. Also being wood against metal I don't think the friction would last very long i.e. it would wear out the wood.
Scott, confused and waiting for rain.
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#5O.K., I'll pop by
Neal in San Jose
>The GF and I leave Wednesday (Thursday to you) for a two week cruise all around OZ. Unfortunately, I don't think I'll be close enough to Perth to stop by. Nice looking hotdog. I'm sorry I won't be able to see it in person. Close, but no hotdog.
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#6Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)
>Hi Derek,
Nice work, it makes a lot of sense to have this
type of handle on a plane when shooting. When using
metal-bodied planes for shooting, and doing a considerable amount, I find myself grabbing a small cloth for lack of a better idea.
I had a question though.
Did you use the Sawstop to cut the Hot Dog to length :)
Norman
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#7Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Did you use the Sawstop to cut the Hot Dog to length :)
Norman, I tried ... then tried again ... and again ... damn saw kept stopping!
You are such a smarty pants! :)
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#8Re: Looks nice, but I don't get it...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Scott
A friction fit means it slides on and is held by the tightness of the fit. It is quite secure (I can lift the plane holding onto the hotdog). In addition, the raised rear curve on the side wall of the LAJ provides a little something to push against.
I will see how it goes over the next month. It may work loose, and then I will need to add a set screw from the underside. So far so good.
I'll say this, with the hotdog there is no temptation for a #9.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#9Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
Paul Kierstead
>That is pretty cool, Derek. Nice looking and functional.
Relatives (or near enough) are always wanting a birthday/christmas list for me. One of the items I said I would really like a hot dog for my #9 (the original knob really didn't work well for me), and pointed my g/f mother to a wood store that sold LN stuff. Now she is a very well coiffed, sophisticated looking lady who extreme is *extremely* urban and looks very much out of place in a place selling woodworking tools. So she goes in and asks for a hot dog. Now this is in an area of the states where people are still more ... plain spoken. They had a good laugh and told her she was in the wrong store and that they sold hot dogs in the cart in the parking lot or at the grocery store up the street. They were kind and good natured about it, and she was somewhat amused (plus has a story), but I don't think she believes me any more when I tell her what to buy .... now I gotta give web links to the list.
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#10WHAT!
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>"I'll say this, with the hotdog there is no temptation for a #9."
Derek, your a sick puppy! :^)
Thanks for the clarification.
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#11g/f mother?
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>Paul, what's a g/f mother?
Derek, very cool, maybe I'll make one and keep that LAJ, maybe; although I kind of like the HNT Gordon try plane wings a lot.
Pam
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#12Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
Philip F Duffy
>Oh sure, "pop around to Perth"! Gosh, there was a time when I would do that with a ship but these days I seem to be lacking one of those big flatops! Merry Holidays to all in Perth! Phil
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#13Re: g/f mother?
Paul Kierstead
>girl friends mother. I fall into slang if I don't watch myself.
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#14Easy to telll who hangs around chat rooms. :)
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>
Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
#15Re: A Hotdog for a LV LAJ
Kerry in Alberta, Canada
>Derek - that looks terrific. When I use my LAJ for shooting, I find I have a tendency to 'roll' the plane in towards the blade. This looks like it might help counteract that. Thanks for showing this.
Kerry



