Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

Posts

Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#1

Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

Don in Northern Arizona

>I got one of those cute little Mujingfang planes today and judging from the box either Mujingfang or China has finally been assimilated by the Borg. Or maybe it's the other way around? Resistance is futile, etc., etc.

Don

"If you prick me, do I leak."

--Lieutenant Commander Data


img

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#2

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

Tom Colligan

>Don, which Borg? Thx.,

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#3

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

Don in Northern Arizona

>Tom,

Nope they're not selling them at Home Depot, Lowes, or Menards. I was just making a bad Star Trek joke based on the company label that appears on the box that the plane came in which is visible in the picture. I bought the plane at Japanwoodworker.com for $24.

Don

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#4

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Oh, you mean Bjorn!

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#5

Chris Scholz

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?--

Chris Scholz

>I hear these Chinese planes are great performers. They are all the same basic design (think of them as oversize spokeshaves), but with significant regional differences. They've been used for literally thousands of years (according to tradition they have been invented by Mr. Lu Ban around 500 BC). Have been used to produce some of the most amazing furniture that has ever been seen on this planet using gnarly old wood that we tend not to touch with a ten foot pole (did I get a bit carried away here?).

There are probably more of these planes in daily use today than the cumulative number of Stanley/Bailey planes ever built, and yet, they are rather obscure sights in our woodworking literature, not to mention toolboxes.

Grossly undervalued by any measure (like pretty much all historic Chinese woodworking tools) You can pick them up for pennies in China today. Wait until the collectors get wind of that!

As far as I know "Mujingfang" is a recent brand name that is specifically marketed to Western woodworkers. It is my understanding that in most circumstances the Chinese woodworker would buy a blade and at best a roughed-out block of wood (of course most woodworkers would have a block of wood laying around anyways) and build his/her own tools. There might have been some specialized tool shops during the proto-industrial era catering to entities like the Imperial Works (pure speculation from my side, pretty much everything related to Chinese woodworking tools rather murky, and that's an understatement).

Enjoy the plane and show us some shavings!

Chris

Galoot-Tools.com

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#6

Mujingfang Mini Smoother --- a mini review

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Don

That looks like the "mini smoother". It is a fantastic little plane. Nearly identical (but a fraction of the cost) of the HNT Gordon "palm smoother". 1/8" O1 or HSS (could be either, likely to be the latter) blade bedded at 60 degrees. Finish is about 90% of the HNT Gordon.

It is about the same size as the average block plane (that is a 4" square in the image below). It can be used like a block plane for cleaning up small areas, trimming or chamfering face grain, and removing tearout on small sections of gnarly wood. I hone the bevel at 30 degrees. As per the HNT Gordon planes, the blade can be reversed and it used as a scraper plane. I have not found a wood that this plane cannot tame.



Mine is built of Ebony and has a tight, brass edged mouth.

Setting the blade is the same as per all woodies, but I do find mine to be a little more sensitive to the amount of malleting it receives - it is easy to overdo it. It is possible to set it with finger pressure alone, then firm the wedge with a very light tap.

At its price (about $25 AUD locally) it is just an absolute bargain. Everyone should own one!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#7

Re: Mujingfang Mini Smoother --- a mini review

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>You probably want to check with Terry before claiming the two lines/planes are nearly identical.

Pam

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#8

Re: Mujingfang Mini Smoother --- a mini review

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Pam

I have used the Mujingfang and HNT Gordon minis side-by-side. They feel the same, look the same, taste ... :) The blades are the same size and thickness, the bodies are the same size and shape. The HNT Gordon is better finished, but the difference is not much.

Here is the HNT Gordon Palm Smoother in Ironwood ...



Cost no object? I would have the HNT Gordon. But at $165 verses the $25 for the Muji ......

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#9

Re: Mujingfang Mini Smoother --- a mini review

Don in Northern Arizona

>Derek,

I am pretty sure it is the mini-smoother you refer to, but Japan Woodworker says it is rosewood, and so it appears to be. Thanks for the info on setting the blade. I had pretty much come to the same conclusion on my own as it was easy to set it too rank with a mallet only.

I did have to do a little work on the sides of the mouth with a file to clean it up a bit, but other than that the finish is quite acceptable.

It does make a great little scraper. I used it to quickly clean up our kitchen cutting board top. I found that I could lean on the blade a little as I scraped to adjust my cut.

Don


img

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#10

Derek, Muji left Australia on my cutting board ;-)

Don in Northern Arizona

>Derek,

There was one low spot on the cutting board that sole of the Mujingfang plane was actually too big to get into. It looks quite a bit like Australia, eh? Tasmania is attached so it must be a picture from back when the oceans were higher or shortly after the breakup of Pangea when things were more attached. I kid you not, this was not Photoshopped.

Cheers,

Don


img

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#11

Another tip for setting up a woodie

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Don

Mujingfang generally offer either Ebony or Rosewood. You got the one and I got the other.

You may want to try the follow idea for setting up this plane. The mini smoother ideally should be set for a very fine shaving. Terry Gordon has recommended using a flat hardwood "setting block" upon which the plane is rested as the blade is inserted, etc. For about the past year now I have been using a setting block that consists of a sheet of glass. While this may at first sound as if it could damage the blade's edge, it does not do so - possibly because the surface is so smooth. The hardness limits the blade's projection, and the result is a very fine shaving. You can always deepen it with a tap from a mallet.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#12

Re: Mujingfang Mini Smoother --- a mini review

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Hmmm, the profile is different, length is different, and the HNT doesn't have that ugly hole in the blade. While I agree that at the price one should at least try the Mujinfang first, the option wasn't available when I got into the HNTs; and I've decided to stop buying tools I don't need. :)

Anyhow, a call to Terry still wouldn't be out of line. I objected to Lyn's similar statement a few years ago when he was writing the high angle planes article; and both he and Terry thanked me. I don't know what Terry said to him.

Pam

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#13

Planes with holes in the blade

wilbur

>How about this one? :@)


img

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#14

Why is the hole there? Forging technique?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#15

Re: Why is the hole there? Forging technique?-----

wilbur

>The story with these planes is that the soft metal part of the blade is obtained from old steel bridges, and the hole is from the bolt holes, so that the hole was there before it was forged into a Japanese plane blade.

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#16

Re: Why is the hole there? Forging technique?-----

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Amusing. I suspect there are too many Mujinfangs made with holes to make that likely today, but perhaps that's how someone got the idea. The holes are too neat, seems it would be a lot of work to neaten a bolt hole. Also seems it would introduce some build complications. Bet it sure saves some metal cost.

Pam

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#17

Re: Why is the hole there? Forging technique?-----

Paul in NJ

>I imagine the hole is for hanging multiple blades on some sort of rack or fixture for heat treatment in a production environment.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#18

Some more pictures to illustrate

wilbur

>Here are some more pictures to show where that hole comes from. They come from an eBay listing. This particular Japanese plane is for sale on eBay, but I thought that linking to the actual auction probably would be frowned upon.

Here is the steel from the old bridge, with bolt holes in place.

Holey Japanese Plane

Here is a cut off section of that steel, ready to be made into a Japanese plane blade. A piece of harder steel will be laminated to this softer steel.

Holey Japanese Plane

Here's the cut off, next to the finished product.

Holey Japanese Plane

This steel is supposed to be on the soft side, so that filing the hole smooth shouldn't be too much of a problem.

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#19

Re: Why is the hole there? Forging technique?-----

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>So maybe the presence of a hole is testimony to machine made blades?

Pam

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#20

Chris Scholz

Re: Why is the hole there? Forging technique?-----

Chris Scholz

>I'd say that's a fair assumption.

As far as I know most blades (even many 'hand made' ones) are made using some sort of self-powered mechanical implement such as a spring hammer.

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#21

Re: Why is the hole there? Forging technique?-----

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes, sure. But I think there's a lot of difference between a blacksmith using a powered hammer and such a hammer included in a production line without human supervision; and I don't relish the day I have to admit otherwise. :)

Pam

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#22

Re: Why is the hole there? Forging technique?-----

Dave Burnard

>I was given a small stash of these bridge plates, one aspect of their use is working around the holes, or occasionally working one into the design of the blade. If you look in the smiths scrap pile you see that almost always the holes are worked around. Tsunesaburo has sort of popularized the practice with his "plane with hole" blade.

If the hole looks punched or drilled, like on those Mujinf... it's there for a different reason. Often for hanging the blade during heat treatment, or jigging during grinding, but since it's so big it might be decorative as well...

Re: Mujingfang planes...assimilated by the Borg?

#23

Re: Why is the hole there? Forging technique?-----

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Seems that it wouldn't take much to work around a hole by forge welding more material in the hole area. I suppose the inner diameter of the hole would have to be cleaned/prepped. Is that a big deal?

Pam