Re: Some options
Dave Mount
>Couple thoughts--
One of the first things I ever made when I started woodworking was a walnut box about the size you are thinking about. I joined the corners with box joints and just glued the top and bottom on. At the time, I didn't really know enough to be concerned about the wood movement issue in this construction. Not too much later, I learned about the design flaw I had created and then just gritted my teeth waiting for the box to self destruct. Well, that was coming up on 20 years ago, and that box is still sitting in the kitchen with SWMBO's recipes in it, and there have been no problems whatsoever. We live in northern MN so our indoor humidity swings dramatically summer to winter, and the finish is only a little Danish oil, so it isn't like the finish is isolating the wood from moisture swings. By reporting this I'm not recommending the practice, but I am saying that sometimes we may underestimate what we can get away with if we have to.
Another option is to attach the top with brads instead of glue. Don't know whether that approach will square with your aesthetics, although traditionally, that's probably how a utilitarian box would have been made.
There is another way to float the top and have it be smooth. In this approach you put a groove near the top of the sides as per usual. The difference is in how you mate the top to the sides. I'm not sure how to describe in words how the top needs to be cut. Picture a groove cut in the perimeter of the top, a little deeper than the sides are thick. This produces two tongues in the edges of the top, top and bottom. The bottom tongue is then cut back so it fits in the groove in the sides, with some extra room for expansion. The upper tongue is left long, so it covers the tops of the sides giving you the look you want. Does that make sense?
I'll try a crude drawing in Paint and put it below. I'm not showing the gaps you should leave to allow for movement. Sorry I'm not a CAD guy.
Good luck,
Dave
