Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

How do I make this box?

Posts

How do I make this box?

#1

hb

How do I make this box?

HB

>I want to make a dovetailed box, but I want a solid top on the box. (The dovetails will be at the vertical corners of the box - not top and bottom corners like a carcase)

How do I do this without the wood movement breaking the box? I don;t want to do a floating panel cause I want the top of the box to be smooth.

There's a picture of the general shape I intend to make below.

The dimensions aren't big, it'll be maybe 5 x 8 inches and 4 inches tall. Maybe in such a small size the movement won't matter much?


img

Re: How do I make this box?

#2

Re: How do I make this box?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I see only one option. Provided that the grain of the top runs left to right, the grain should run top to bottom on the box sides, and left to right on the front and back of the box. But then you can't dovetail the sides and front/back together.

No matter what, one dimension has to be allowed to float, with solid wood there's no escaping that fact...

You could dovetail all corners if the front and back of the box are made of veneer on a stable substrate, but then the substrate will show at the joints, as viewed from the sides.

DC

Re: How do I make this box?

#3

Re: Some options

Dave Mount

>Couple thoughts--

One of the first things I ever made when I started woodworking was a walnut box about the size you are thinking about. I joined the corners with box joints and just glued the top and bottom on. At the time, I didn't really know enough to be concerned about the wood movement issue in this construction. Not too much later, I learned about the design flaw I had created and then just gritted my teeth waiting for the box to self destruct. Well, that was coming up on 20 years ago, and that box is still sitting in the kitchen with SWMBO's recipes in it, and there have been no problems whatsoever. We live in northern MN so our indoor humidity swings dramatically summer to winter, and the finish is only a little Danish oil, so it isn't like the finish is isolating the wood from moisture swings. By reporting this I'm not recommending the practice, but I am saying that sometimes we may underestimate what we can get away with if we have to.

Another option is to attach the top with brads instead of glue. Don't know whether that approach will square with your aesthetics, although traditionally, that's probably how a utilitarian box would have been made.

There is another way to float the top and have it be smooth. In this approach you put a groove near the top of the sides as per usual. The difference is in how you mate the top to the sides. I'm not sure how to describe in words how the top needs to be cut. Picture a groove cut in the perimeter of the top, a little deeper than the sides are thick. This produces two tongues in the edges of the top, top and bottom. The bottom tongue is then cut back so it fits in the groove in the sides, with some extra room for expansion. The upper tongue is left long, so it covers the tops of the sides giving you the look you want. Does that make sense?

I'll try a crude drawing in Paint and put it below. I'm not showing the gaps you should leave to allow for movement. Sorry I'm not a CAD guy.

Good luck,

Dave


img

Re: How do I make this box?

#4

Re: Click on pic in previous msg to see detail

Dave Mount

>

Re: How do I make this box?

#5

Index card boxes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, the rain's here

>Commercial wooden index card boxes used to be built from solid oak about 1/4" thick just as Dave describes building his box. I've seen some that are probably 50 years old, with no visible signs of cracking.

Re: How do I make this box?

#6

hb

Re: Some options

HB

>Thanks Dave. I get what you're saying. It's sort of like a panel floating in there except it;'s not a raised panel, it's got an overhang to cover the sides.

Thanks.

HB

Re: How do I make this box?

#7

hb

Re: How do I make this box?

HB

>DC, I'm where you are in thnking that one dimension has to float, except for the fact that right there in that picture I posted is a box that was built incorrectly 150 years ago and shows no problems.....

Sometimes I think I do too much book reading and not enough learning from mistakes...

Thanks for the info.

HB

Re: How do I make this box?

#8

A couple of things...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>This is a fairly common construction technique, the bottom is probably held in a groove around the lower inside edge, or it could be just fit in, pegged (or is that doweled or pinned?) in place.

The dovetails keep the boards straight and square and any movement is the same as there is no cross grain issue.

The tops, some times rebated around the edge, sometimes just a butt joint, glued and nailed in place. At the time a common practice. However if you will notice the wood is probably quarter sawn for minimum shrinkage. One problem now is getting wood that wide that is quarter sawn. The size of this box it should be no problem.

Mix a little glycerine in the hide glue (and of course you wouldn't use anything else, right?) to make it flexible and it can adjust a bit to small amounts of movement.

We just don't have access to that type of original growth wood that this old stuff is made from.

Stephen

Re: How do I make this box?

#9

Book learning

Bruce, a MN galoot

>HB, Just consider books to be a compendium of all the work-arounds that people have figured out to deal with the mistakes they made. Reading just means you don't have to make the mistakes yourself.

Bruce

Re: How do I make this box?

#10

fake it

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>You said you want a solid top, but veneering over some thin plywood and taking care of the edges with solid wood can LOOK solid and be stable. This is how Krenov has incorporated stability into some of his cabinets. Yes, it is work.

Depending on size and species though, you could just act like wood does not move and glue in some solid stuff. Some rules can be broken, as Dave's small walnut box proves.

Re: How do I make this box?

#11

Re: How do I make this box?

Marv

>I have made small boxes by merely mitering all edges at a 45 degree angle and gluing it all together. You end up with a sealed box. Then you saw the lid off. You can use small brads if you like and then set the brads and fill them, but problem there is, you can see them no matter what you do to fill them.

Best way is to jig it up and clamp four sides then glue the top and bottom on and just put a weight on the top to hold it down while the glue dries. Before you saw off the lid, lightly sand all the sharp corners. Makes a nice looking box and you don't see any joints. If the box isn't being subjected to rough treatment, a good glue will last forever.

I have a box I made to serve as a horseshoe tote using that method. It held 4 tournament size horse shoes plus some tools. I used it for years and it's still as good as when I made it.

Marv

Re: How do I make this box?

#12

And

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I've made some similar boxes, and put "feathers" of various thicknesses in the corners. Done right, it adds some strength.

Re: How do I make this box?

#13

Feathers??

Marv

>

Re: How do I make this box?

#14

Eagle works best, red-tail hawk OK; turkey no good

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>British term, I think, which is probably where I saw it first.

A sawcut across the miter, with a piece of veneer glued into the sawcut. I've usually done thicker pieces, 1/8" or so, but the principle is the same - and I'm not sure what you call them when they're thicker.

Ideally, I guess, the saw cuts are alternately angled, like dovetail cuts without cutting out the base of the dovetail, thus adding some mechanical strength.

If my explanation is unclear, I can attempt a drawing.

Re: How do I make this box?

#15

Re: Eagle works best, red-tail hawk OK; turkey no

Marv

>Hi Bill,

Thanks, that's what I thought you meant. There's another term for what you describe but I can't think of it at the moment...Stephen??

The horseshoe tote I made was made of 7/16" think kiln dried douglas fir quartersawn. With that thickness there's a lot of surface to glue at 45 degree miter. And I used a few finishing nails and set the heads and filled. I can still see the filled spots but hey, it's only a horseshoe box. For a box like HB is making with thinner sides he could reinforce on the inside corners if needed, depending on it's use.

Marv

Re: How do I make this box?

#16

Veneer keys, I think, in US (I call them feathers)

Andrew F in Australia

>

Re: How do I make this box?

#17

Splines?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: How do I make this box?

#18

Re: Eagle works best, red-tail hawk OK; turkey no

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>That is usually called a slip feather and it is used to reinforce miter joints, this joint is exposed.

A spline is concealed in the miter joint and is only visible on the ends not the miter.

Some people call the slip feather a spline and they are not wrong.

Stephen

Re: How do I make this box?

#19

Re: How do I make this box?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>A 5" wide board in reality will not move much at all. And then it has to move enough in one spot for the grain to break apart before it will fail. Wood has some stretch to it. So if you built this box and just glued the top on probably 99 out of 100 would not fail. Small boxes are a little different from large boxes. A better way to do it would be to cut a groove in the sides and then a tongue in the top set down and back far enough that the top would overlap the sides. Probably overthinking it.

Re: How do I make this box?

#20

Re: How do I make this box?

Marv

>Hi HB

If you decide to try the miter joint method, be aware that it can be very unforgiving. The angles have to be spot on and everything has to be dead square. If the 45 degree angle is off by only one degree for example, it gets compounded when you fit two pieces together. At first glance it seems that it should be an easy thing to do but it's actually quite difficult.

After thinking about it more, I'm not sure that this is the best method for you to use. Other methods suggested here are more forgiving and don't require precision cuts. On the other hand if you are equiped to make precision cuts, you will end up with a very nice looking box with no end grain showing.

Marv

Re: How do I make this box?

#21

Re: How do I make this box?

ThomD

>If the panel is small and it is just glued down, it will likely last forever. Depends somewhat on local weather conditions. My dad who is a classical scholar, and my mother same thing, both have lots of little index file boxes made that way without any attempt to float anything.

Re: How do I make this box?

#22

Re: Splines? Yes, that sounds right..

Marv

>Hi Pam,

I'm not sure that's what I couldn't remember, but it's a good word to describe that kind of joint.

The word "spline" comes from the word "splice"?...or "spine"?

Feather just doesn't seem to apply, at least for those of us who can't relate to the 17th century. I do enjoy reading some of the books written during those times.

Marv

Re: How do I make this box?

#23

20th century, actually

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think I first saw the word in one of the British woodworking books - can't recall which author, but one of the standard names. Of course, English nomenclature being rather tradition-bound, 17th century might not be far off from the American perspective, Marv.

I suspect the origin of the word was in the small, thin bits of stock glued into the grooves when the grooves were cut with a handsaw (cutting 1/8" cross-miter grooves would have been trickier back before t*bl*s*ws, and I find it a useful word to distinguish this technique from true splines, which I see as installed along the length of the miter and out of side, except on the ends.

Bill, no way knowledgeable about this stuff, just reporting what he's made work from time to time

Re: How do I make this box?

#24

Re: How do I make this box? *LINK*

Marv

>HB....

Here's a website that explains how to make "splined" joints. You might find some good ideas

Marv


Splines

Re: How do I make this box?

#25

Evolution of language

Bill Houghton, cold sunny Sebastopol, CA

>I guess "spline" has multiple meanings nowadays.