We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I was ripping a four foot long pine board this morning and got to noticing once again how my little finger and that part of the hand below it starts to ache, no matter which saw I use. I am bearing down on the saw putting some pressure on the teeth. This seems to make the cut more agressive and speed up the whole process. This pain I'm experiencing; in my mind it means that I'm doing something wrong. Is my holding technique wrong? Is the hang of the saw wrong? Is der a docta in da haus?
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
I don't even play a saw doctor on TV, nor have I recently slept in, well, whatever hotel chain that is suppose to impart smarts...
A couple things. My opinion about forcing a saw to cut faster is to simply use a coarser saw to begin with. Pressure needs to be maintained, for sure, but long term forcing a cut is a bad idea.
Sharpening may be an issue no matter what saw you are using, including their present configurations (amount of rake).
Without a picture of the saw, it would be near impossible to determine if the handle hang has anything to do with it. It can, but so does stance, angle of saw to workpiece and height of the stuff you are cutting (and its support).
Here's a picture from someone I know in Norway...aside from the idylic setting, it shows a good stance (esp. for the terrain). She had ripped 260 lineal feet by the time the picture was taken...
Long term sawing requires good stance, work support, and a sharp well set saw for the work at hand.
Take care, Mike
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>Way back when I used to inhabit the piano practice rooms seven hours a day, I learned about repetitive motion injuries the hard way; tendonitis, CTS, and so on. I was helped by teachers, trainers, physicians, but I learned most from a pistol trainer who also taught aikido. She demonstrated how much easier one can break a full grip than a grip employing just the thumb and two middle fingers (medio and annular). In the full grip, the index and pinky work against the other two fingers and must entrain other muscles in the rest of the hand, arm, shoulder, neck and side restrictively, robbing strength and mobility.
By easing the index and little finger in a grip, the wrist gains greater freedom which actually improves straightness in the sawing stroke by interfering less in the sawing motion. One mistake, however, is to remove the pinky from the grip by straightening it in a locked manner, compensating with the hand pad and muscles just below the finger to grip the handle. This is both painful and injurious. But with a little focused practice, one can learn to leave the pinky lightly contacting the saw handle contour.
The index, in a small handle grip, can be used as a 'pointer'. If the handle has a large opening, it remain lightly wrapped with the rest of the fingers, but by merely 'thinking' of it as 'pointing', the brain will actually entrain the finger into very fine corrective and guiding movements at its base that will afford greater control and finesse in balancing the saw and guiding the cut, especially at the beginning.
I suggest practicing and thinking about this before starting on each new board and cut. Before you know it, it will become automatic.
Also, at frequent intervals whilst sawing, place you other hand's thumb between the pinky and ring finger of your sawing hand, wrap the two middle fingers (reinforcing the tendency to using the new grip) then squeeze gently, separating the two fingers. Push back lightly on the little finger with the web of the index and thumb, down and away from the annular, then release. Doing this slowly and rhythmically a few times breaks the habitual entrainment of these adjacent fingers as well as easing the tension between pinky and and hand (a piano thing).
Hope this helps.
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>I am constantly amazed, and grateful, for the level and breadth of the expertise in all corners of educated life that inhabits and contributes on this board. Just amazed!!!
Thank you, all!
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
I don't understand the problem, but it sounds as tho you are correct in assuming it is a problem.
Try this:
Make the cut again, on horses, saw held at 40-60 degrees to the board and relax your grip so that the saw is almost falling out of your hand. Just push the back of the handle.
Does the saw not cut (I'm guessing)? Is the discomfort gone? (I'm hoping)
Adam
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>Some of the older books recommend an alternative grip (not a preferred alternative, just an alternative, as I understand it) that works only once the saw is well started in the cut. You leave the saw standing in the cut, walk around to its other side and turn facing it, grip the handle with both hands, and saw that way. Hard to describe, and, naturally, I couldn't find any of the older books I own that show a picture (lack of space has forced a lot of them up into the attic, which is a hard climb at the end of the day), but if you try it, you'll probably find a kinda natural feeling grip. Myself, I find it awkward, but you might give it a shot as a change of pace and see if it helps.
I concur with others, WAY more expert than I, that a death grip doesn't help you saw and isn't good for your body. Sawing should be like riding a bicycle in a sylvan park - well, except for the part where you sweat more and the lack of bunnies and squirrels in most shops - light, relaxed movements, where your job is to guide the tool (saw; bicycle), not muscle it.
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>"Sawing should be like riding a bicycle in a sylvan park - well, except for the part where you sweat more and the lack of bunnies and squirrels in most shops - light, relaxed movements, where your job is to guide the tool (saw; bicycle), not muscle it."
I've had that same sort of little-finger-part-of-hand pain myself; specifically from riding a bicycle. Actually it was on a very long ride, I got tired and leaned heavily on the handlebar, creating pressure on the outside of my hand. My little finger was 'curled' for a week or so from 'minor nerve damage'. When I read the initial post, I wondered if there was another activity that was aggravated by sawing. So...anything else going on?
Tom
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>(So don't do that). I'm sorry, I always assume the unknown reader out there knows exactly how, why and what I do without any further explanation. This is what happens when one gets too comfortable talking with old friends. But I digress. I have a saw bench that stands approximately 20" high. I'm left-handed. (Don't think this makes a difference but I'll throw it in anyway.) I always point the forefinger. This pain occurs with just about any saw but is more pronounced while ripping. I have short little legs and arms and a long trunk. Think worn out Irish boxer that makes a great target for a long-armed, quick-footed, young, strong pugilist. I'm a little over six foot tall. I have a left knee that gives me problems and sometimes it hurts too much to use the knee for holding the board down. When I use the knee often times the back hurts. Sometimes I use my left foot to hold the board down. Neither pose seems to be better than the other. Is my saw bench too low?
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>The saw bench height can be raised temporarily by clamping a 1", 2", or multiple pieces to the top. Might help the back issue. Maybe not unless the strain is noticed right away when bending over the saw bench.
I suspect the pain will be present no matter, but try allowing the saw to do the work after a period of no sawing. The portion of the palm extending from the little finger does receive more pressure if forcing the cut.
The two-handing sawing technique of simply placing the web between the forefinger and thumb at the top of the handle might also bring relief by load sharing.
Also, consider drilling some holes in your saw bench to allow holding the stuff with holdfasts. That would keep the knee out of the equation. You can try the effect by simply using clamps to hold the stuff to the top of the saw bench.
As well, to stand more erect you can utilize the top of your bench to saw from. Afix the stuff to the top with the line a bit out from the bench after first beginning a kerf on the saw bench. The saw is positioned with the handle up, teeth away from you. One hand uses the hand hold, the other through the hand hold. As you saw you walk beside the board.
Take care, Mike
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>and boy are my arms tired. After thinking about my own problem some more, it seems to me that the trouble has to be in my grip. I get the same pain when I clamp the board to my bench. I do have a holdfast on my saw bench and use it often. I believe my grip tightens the longer I saw and this leads to the pain. This whole issue has me thinking about how little I know about technique for anything. Problems I had (and still have) with planing were more because of technique; holding the dang thing. I'll be experimenting tomorrow after Sunday School. I'll let you know about all the good observations y'all've made. (here in the South we can make words with double contractions.)
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>then I made replacement handles for all my saws with a bigger hand hole and that helps.
Like Mike said use holdfasts to hold the boards while sawing.
And most importantly make sure the rest of your body lines up with the work. In order to reduce the effects on your arms, back, knees hands keep eventhing in alignment.
My wrist is straight and my arm moves back and forth with my elbow next to my side. I take as long a stroke as my saw will allow, all the teeth are sharp so why not use them? I have a fairly loose grip on the saw handle and at the end of the cut slow down and loosen the grip a little more to finish up without loosing a chip.
The overhand grip is a good change when you get tired and ripping a 16 foot board can tire you out. I place my thumbs through the hand hole and grasp the top of the saw handle, works especially well for ripping but also in crosscutting.
Make sure your teeth are appropriate for the thickness of the material you are ripping, fewer teeth with increase in thickness. The weight of the saw and a little pressure is all that is necessary.
It shouldn't be an effort.
Stephen
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>I remember watch my Dad using a hand saw & thinking there is a rhythm
to it the same as driving nails both require a relaxed grip on the handle & don't use extra pressure & try hurrying it along let the tool do the work & you just guide it.
My Dad told me at 4 year of age I was watching my Mom using a hand saw & told here you don't saw very well Mommy.
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>I had a teacher at North Bennet who used to extol the virtues of Yoga for all the reasons you mention... back, knees, etc. In his words,
"Woodworking is usually like this." And he'd hunch forward, curling his shoulders in, head down, arms bent and tangled up.
"And Yoga is like this." Back straightened, arms up to the sky, head back, and looking like a 4 year old stretching in the morning after getting out of bed.
Repetitive injuries aside, woodworking will make you sweat, but it's not the greatest recuperative exercise. I hate recommending Yoga and other hippie stuff to people, because it's can be perceived as new age hippie vegetarian-missionary nonsense for crunchy granola space cases. But in this case, if you're already hunched over and sore, more exercise that involves being hunched over and sore probably doesn't help. I find, for myself, that when one thing is sore, I twist and tweak in unnatural ways to compensate, just to get one thing done, and by the end, I have more things that are sore and out of place.
Personally, I didn't follow the Yoga suggestion myself, but I can say that when I get to that point, where things are sore, and I'm trying to compensate in bizarre and ultimately stressful and unhelpful ways, that a walk outside and looking up at the trees can do wonders to ease the stresses, help cure the sores, unwind the mind, and help my woodworking look better. I don't know if that helps or hinders, but I figured it might be worth passing on, in case it helps.
Re: Saw Technique; Is there a doctor in the house?
>I don't do yoga myself, but I do spend 20 minutes each morning*doing a series of stretches that are keeping my increasingly cranky body functional. Seems like "yoga" is basically just a particular set of stretches, with a particular emphasis on focusing the mind while doing it.
Only the very young can do strenuous or physically demanding things without warming up to them first.