Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

Posts

A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

#1

A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I'm mulling over what to get with my first month's my-own-money from going back to work part-time, and am leaning toward getting a Lee Valley medium shoulder plane, not with any specific idea of what I'll do with it, but to build up the arsenal for when I stop being a carpenter and start making furniture. Well, and to treat myself for my sacrifice with a cool toy (see below). I'm an oilstone user, and my impression from reading the literature is that A2 blades are hard or very, very slow to sharpen on oilstones. Am I right?

Off topic: Going back to work after you've retired is not much fun. I'm enjoying seeing colleagues that I liked working with, and, in the moment, enjoying explaining how things work to the new folks; and like that I'm not responsible for outcomes. But, overall, I'm being reminded why I was glad to retire or, as I say, graduate. I think I'm just going to work long enough to put together the funding for our two bathroom remodels, and then segue out - three-four months, certainly not more than six (this is 2 days/week).

Re: A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

#2

Re: A2 vs. O1

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>There are technical reasons for making the choice, and you can listen to all of those you want pay attention to.

This isn't one of those.

You retired. Your time is your own. Sharpen the easier to use O1 blade until you're happy, then take the whisper thin shavings from the workpiece and brag about it here. That's one of the reasons places like this exist - for old guys to swap tales.

I bought one of those handplanes when Rob first brought them out. It's a sweet piece of work! And a good reward. Enjoy building furniture.

Re: A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

#3

Re: A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I really feel bad for you having to go to work for 2 days a week. That would be a really rough life. Not sure what I would do with all that extra time; it must add to your frustrations to have all that extra time and nothing to do. I guess I plan on builidng furniture to sell when I retire. My thoughts are that I would build a piece that I want to build and then sell it, instead of having customers tell me what to build for them. My own personal opinion is that I am a better designer than the average customer; although there are some that actually have a knowledge of design. So far as A2 or O1 I suggest that since all you would have to do is put in one more day of work buy both blades and see which one you like. After all, you have the time right?

Re: A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

#4

Good idea, Moses

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I hadn't thought about buying both - an opportunity to see which works best for my sharpening abilities.

Sorry if I'm making anyone feel bad about the two days/week - my whine was more oriented toward confirming that graduating from work was the right move.

Re: A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

#5

Re: A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

Bob Sobieck

>I still have 20 years of full time work left myself so am a bit envious over all the wood time you appear to have.

I bought a LN low angle block plane last year with A2. This year I bought a Hock blade for a wooden smoother plane I made, also A2. I use water stones but found no problem sharpeningin them. They do seem to stay sharp longer but I don't work in the shop that much. I am by no means an expert sharpener but have found I can make those whisper thin shavings that you can see through.

I have never used O1 but I would not let the A2 scare you away.

Bob in Green Bay

Re: A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

#6

Jim in Burlington Ont.

One of my most used planes

Jim in Burlington On

>I use that plane alot to fit hardwood flooring by taking a shaving or two off the tounge(bottom). It's a royal PITA to sharpen that blade because is has to be dead square. That's my reason for getting A2.

Re: A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

#7

Benefits of working part time while retired

wilbur

>I bet 1-2 days of work during retirement would be ideal. Just enough work to make some money to buy tools with, and just enough time out of the shop at work to make you really appreciate the time spent in the shop.

Re: A2 vs. O1 - Lee Valley - plus an OT whine

#8

shoulder plane with A2 or O1 - no real difference

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>IMO this is one of those planes do don't really need but when you need to take just a tiny, wenzy bit extra off a shoulder, or, in my case last night, the edge of a wide dado, they are magic.

These planes get used so little, typically to take two or three shavings, that ease of shapening vs edge retention is IMO a non-issue. Whichever blade you choose (A2 or O2), it will arrive from Rob almost ready to use (the back will be flat and the bevel properly formed)- you just need to hone a micro-bevel and you're away.

It'll probably be months before it needs resharpening.