Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Sawing wide lumber question

Posts

Sawing wide lumber question

#1

Sawing wide lumber question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I had some large logs rift cut into cants(planks) with the intention of resawing them into potentially book-matched lumber for doors and the like as needed. Let me try to precisely state the need.....

Occasionally I would like to resaw a board from a cant(plank) that might be 16" wide and 2 to 4' long by xx" thick. The objective is to get it sawed in the most practical way consistent with the fact that this is an occasional need. If it was 12" I would do it on a band saw but not a piece this big. I have done similar sawing with a hand saw rip tooth but it was very slow going because the saw was short relative to the task. A chain saw it too crude a cut, at least in my hands.

Would building some sort of frame saw be the thing to do? I have never seen one so I don't know how to make one. Would a piece of bandsaw blade such as out of a bandsaw mill work if this was the way to go. I don't want making the saw more effort than making the lumber. The saw, whatever it might be, is a means to an end.

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#2

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Probably not the answer you're looking for, but if it were me I would ask someone who has a bandsaw mill.

DC

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#3

Veneer Saw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>The traditional tool for this work is usually called a veneer saw. It is a blade perhaps 1 1/2" wide and 3 or 4 feet long stretched in a wooden frame. The lengthwise pieces are tenoned into the end pieces which have usually turned handles extending out to the sides. There are about 3 teeth per inch. The saw is held horizontally and the wood is fixed vertically in a vise. It is generally a two man operation, but can be done alone.

I generally use mine for stuff that is 6 to 12 inches wide, but once did 14 inches. I figure about 5 strokes per square inch of material. For a piece 12X24 thats maybe 1400 strokes. You can use bandsaw blades, but it might be nice to be able to modify the teeth.

There are nice illustrations of veneer saws in Roubo, Diderot, Mercer and Hummel. There are also some nice machines that do this work.

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#4

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

MikeW

>Hi Bill,

I would say Warren's estimate is close enough. Depending on the wood being sawn, 3 to 7 or 8 strokes per inch of width to advance 1" in depth is a good bet *after* the blade is buried in the cut.

2-3 tpi (3-4 ppi) bandsaw blades work well. I've used worn 1/2" WoodSlicer blades I've touched up sharpening-wise. iirc, the WS blades are 20 thou. Thin blades are better than thick for obvious reasons, but in drier woods.

You can also build a frame saw with the cant supported and saw straddling the cant (sitting on it works if it isn't quite so large). Main issue with this method is it is difficult to check the opposite side for remaining on line. But on thinner material the vertical can be eyed using the saw fairly well.

Also, if the wood is yet wet, that creates some issues with the blades getting gummy (friction = effort) as well as needing more set, which also means a thicker blade (which = more effort). For the gummy aspect, I've used a squirt bottle filled with Kerosene (which is what we always lubed saws with when I was growing up). These days I use mineral spirits. Doesn't work as well, but works fine.

Take care, Mike

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#5

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

Marv

>Hi Bill,

Adding a little to Mikes suggestions....Back in the old days when carpenters and DIY selfers needed to rip a large beam they would mark both top and bottom for the cut line. They would saw a short distance, then flip the beam over and do the same on the other side and kept doing that until the cut was complete. This insured that the cut would be relatively accurate.

Marv

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#6

I need a picture

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have a rough idea of the saw but some details would aid construction. I have no chance of seeing one of the books referenced.

It took about 10,000 strokes to cleave a 18" by 2' piece of birch with a carpenters rip saw, so the rates given look attractive. All sawing will be in very dry wood.

If there was a band mill handy that would be the choice.

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#7

Here's one

Frank D. in Montreal

>...from Roubo. There are some good pics on the Web of modern equivalents...I'll let someone else post a link because I don't remember exactly where I saw them.


img

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#8

Yikes...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>No need to go to the gym with that kind of workout :-)

DC

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#9

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I don't know if it would work, would be dependent on the wood and thickness; but I'd certainly try riving before I broke down and sawed.

Pam

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#10

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

paul womack

>I don't know if it would work, would be dependent on the wood and thickness; but I'd certainly try riving before I broke down and sawed.


I can't see riving a piece that wide making book matched flitches, unless the grain were so uniform as to be too dull for book matching to be of interest.

BugBear

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#11

Re: I need a picture

paul womack

>frame saw

in use

BugBear

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#12

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>If you are resawing cants then you should be able to use a large frame bow saw with a wide rip blade.

Stephen

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#13

Another question, maybe for Mr. Lee

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Does Lee Valley sell the hats and bloomers required for this saw?

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#15

Style

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I thought those fellows had a lot of style. They look more like they are dancing than slaving away. Is that the way it was in 18th century Paris? Maybe the illustrator took some liberties.

There was once a young fellow at our local millworks who operated a tablesaw all day long. He worked very fast and also very long hours without seeming to get tired. I liked to watch him because he was so fluid and graceful it was like dancing.

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#16

Thank you Paul.

VLParisian

>The old to-do list just grew again...

Making a living keeps gettingin the way of life.

Victor

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#17

Re: Another question, maybe for Mr. Lee

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I remember in a FWW article of a whole bunch of years ago, Frank Klausz and his brother used one to resaw a plank. It struck me as an awful lot of work.

Wouldn't a wood mizer or other band saw mill (with a really skilled operator) make pretty short work of your board?

Bruce

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

#18

Re: Sawing wide lumber question

Marv

>Hi Bill,

I've never tried it but I betcha if you had a big-O 4 or 5 ft. one man crosscut saw, it would rip just fine. Would have to be really sharp though.

Marv