WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

Posts

Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#1

Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I just got a postcard from the Fine Tool Journal announcing the 31st Tool Sale and International Antique Tool Auction being held at the Sheraton Four Points (717 561-2800) in Harrisburg PA on October 26th and 27th 2007.

I've never attended this gathering and was wondering if it was worth it. I'm not in the market for a $5000 hand plane. I just want to browse and see if there is anything in my price range. Can you buy a nice user Bedrock there?

Do manufacturers of new hand planes show up here and sell their wares? Or is it just all collectibles?

I guess I'm expecting a hand tool show, rather than an auction.

Who has attended this show and what were your impressions?

Thanks,

Dominic

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#2

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

Joel

>it's tons of fun. THe dealer show the day before the auction will have tons of antiques usually in nice shape. This is a top dollar, top condition show. But I have gotten some great deals. IF you are looking for the 4$ #1 then it isn't the show for you.

The night before the dealer show there is room trading which is fun both because I routinely get some good stuff and because for the entire 2 days I get to see stuff I wouldn't normally see.

The auction can be tedious but if you pay attention you can both fondle really cool stuff and occasionally get a great deal. I got a lot of stuff in the auction over the years just by figuring out what I am willing to pay and taking a chance.

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#3

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

wilbur

>Hi Dominic,

I haven't been to this particular auction before, but the ones I've been to were worthwhile even though I didn't buy anything.

First of all, the auctions I've been to had a bunch of people selling hand tools out front, which is a good place to go bargain hunting, although I don't know if this auction will have a similar setup.

Secondly, think of it as a chance to go to a hand tool museum. You'll be able to look and handle a lot of vintage tools. Much more satisfying than looking at pictures on eBay.

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#4

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

Rob Lee

>Hi Dom -

Nope... nothin' to see there....

Don't take any money...

Don't even go....

And...

Don't bid against me.....! ;)

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#5

Hi Joel

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Joel,

Thanks for the input!

You wrote:

"The dealer show the day before the auction will have tons of antiques usually in nice shape."

Now THAT sounds exactly like what I was looking for! The advertisement states that the auction is being held on Oct 26th and 27th. When would the dealer show be? I'm trying to determine the best day to be there. My initial plan was to be there early on Saturday the 27th.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#6

Hi Rob

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Rob,

I promise to TRY not to bid against you. :>)

But I have a funny feeling that you're a bit more discriminating when it comes to the tools you'd be bidding on!

Seriously, I'm terrible at auctions. So I usually avoid them. Maybe it's my nature. But the times I've bid, I usually went over my limit and REALLY regretted it. I prefer to walk up to a table and just BUY something for the advertised price (with maybe just a bit of haggling). :>)

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#7

You bring up a good point!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Wilbur,


"Secondly, think of it as a chance to go to a hand tool museum. You'll be able to look and handle a lot of vintage tools. Much more satisfying than looking at pictures on eBay."

You know, that is a real good point. I could think of it as a "education" trip. Like to a museum. :>) To be honest I wouldn't mind seeing some of those rare planes up close.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#8

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hey Rob,

Do they have Offer Sheets for Restricted Free Agent Tools?

:-)

Don't bid against Burkie, He's in a BAD mood, eh!

Enjoy adding to the collection......I think you need to build a Tool Museum in Ottawa...

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Drive Safely

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#9

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

Ernie Miller

>I would like to see a traveling show we have a great place here in Topeka The Great Overland Station and old remodeled UP station that could show a simi load of tools for a couple weeks to a month. I would think Rob cout put together a show and let it tour across Canada and then back across the continant thru the USA and back home it would make allot of people happy and might even be used as a way of driving there sales to the next level.

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#10

Re: Hi Joel

Joel

>Friday is the dealer show and the showing of the auction items, Saturday is the auction. A lot of people get there thursday afternoon for room trading and a lot leave Saturday morning if they don't plan to bid in the auction. My usual plan was ( I'm not going this year - small kid needs me) go either thursday of really early Friday stay until the items I want to bid on saturday come up, or when I get bored.

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#11

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

Tony Zaffuto

>Definetly worth the trip! Dealer show starts at 1:00 PM Friday (IIRC), with hand woodworking tools of all types! I've been going to the Spring and Fall shows for a few years and find the Fall show a bit bigger.

Re: Harrisburg Antique Tool Auction: Worth it?

#12

Plenty to see w/o staying for the auction

Michael Stadulis, in Gloucester County, NJ

>There are very many dealer tables to make you happy ......but you can always inspect the auction items so you won't miss anything, If you just want some old tools, you'll find them here, but don't worry that it's all auction. It is not. -Mike

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.