Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

Posts

Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#1

Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>All blades returned safely from heat treating. Batch passed the hardness test. Here is the batch *class photo* after initial quality check. There are a few custom blades and some screwdrivers I am playing with. Next comes the sort, final grinding, honing, packing, and shipping. Blade shop will be busy this weekend.


img

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#2

Sorted

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>Here are the Hamler Miller sets sorted along with my test plane. All are fitted and tested after honing. There are ten complete sets here. They are: 3/16, 1/4, 5/16, 3/8, 1/2, 5/8, and 1.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#3

Re: Sorted

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>Cat walked across the keyboard before picture posting.


img

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#4

Jim in Burlington Ont.

What's the number

Jim in Burlington On

>Hi Jim,

What kind of rockwell number do you usually try to achieve. Thanks Jim

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#5

Trade secret

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>My heat treating specifications are the result of many hours of trial and error shop testing. Hardness is a compromise of many different factors. Too hard and the metal is brittle and will crumble, too soft and it will bend. Too hard and they are too hard to sharpen, too soft and they require too frequent sharpenings. Each type of steel has different characteristics and requires different hardening specs. Sorry to say that my hardness specs are trade secrets. The blades are harder than original Stanley blades but softer than Japanese chisels. I have not done extensive testing, but I think they are very close to Hock, LV and LN. That is logical because the blades are all used for similar purposes. That puts mine somewhere in the RC range of 55--64.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#6

Oh Please!

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>These posts are beginning to look a lot like advertising.

Anyone that owns one of these blades can take it to any machine shop or heat treater and in a minute obtain a hardness. And with very little additional effort determine the alloy, which is likely O-1, in which case just duplicate what numerous others have already determined to be the best hardness. Anything that needs to be known about heat treating steel can be learned from the technical service department of the steel supplier or from a sophisticated heat treater, of which there are hundreds for a simple steel like O-1.

I'll bet that what ever the steel, the hardness will be within 2 points of 60.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#7

Sorry for the offense

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>Anything I do in the shop is not magic and all of it can certainly be reverse engineered. My intent was not to offend and I am sorry that I did.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#8

Re: Sorry for the offense

Marv

>Hi Jim,

Thanks for sharing....I'm not offended. Now if you had posted a picture and said something about my first wife....wellllll :-)

Marv

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#9

I don't feel offended.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Jim

I don't see what the fuss is about hobbiests offering their limited wares for sale. And especially is the items are of interest to many, and are coming from a regular contributor.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#10

Re: Oh Please!

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>I have had Jim make a custom cutter for me and he is a fine craftsman. I solicited the cutter because I couldn't get it anywhere else save a used up pos from ebay. I'm sure that cutters fitting Millers Patent planes are easily found and procured ...NOT. Jim provides a great service for the admittedly limited market for hand too cutters. The major manufacturers aren't building these parts. Jim will. The next question is how do tool users find out about the service Jim can give? Here in these threads. In the strictest sense the posts could be considered advertising but the trade off is well worth it. The moderators would step in if the line is crossed. Just my humble opinion.JR

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#11

Re: Oh Please!

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I don't see Jim's postings as advertising, more of "look what I've created lately". In the vein of advertzing tho, I will give Jims planes a solid plug as very well made, and excellent users.

T.O.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#12

Miller Patent Ploughs--Overview

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>When the availability of Paul Hamler's plough kits was advertised (by Ellis), it was pretty much a non-starter without a blade source. So Jim not only stepped up to make blade sets, he also posted a great tutorial on what's involved in getting the kit together. I found his tutorial to be essential, and not available elsewhere (like the blades!).

Jim ain't getting rich off the blades, and so in my view, his postings of availability are pretty much a service to those who bought the kits.

I've used a couple of blades from out of the Hamler plough blade set Jim sent me. They're hard and durable--I don't believe the Rc is less than 60.

Wiley

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#13

Please relax

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I'm sorry I have to say something here. Maybe some would feel that it's not my place to say anything here since I don't contribute as much as others. But I've been visiting this forum for some time and have read many of Jim's posts. Not ONCE have I felt that Jim's post were "advertising in disguise".

His reply to that question was honest. What more could you ask? He took the time to develop the regime that gives him the desired hardness. He is under no obligation to share that "trade secret".

And I believe that the Hand Tool forum moderator would say something if he thought otherwise.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#14

Re: Oh Please!

ThomD

>"Anyone that owns one of these blades can take it to any machine shop or heat treater and in a minute obtain a hardness."

Hardness isn't the whole story. It can be in a machine shop where cutters are a few bucks each and their wear creates about as much concern as the need to put more toothpaste on your brush, but it doesn't seem to be the be all and end all in the higher end hand cutting tools.

FWW did a review a few years back that while seriously flawed did show how compresed Rockwell C values have become while the performance qualities of various edges remain pretty separated. It is true that a fair amount of craft knowledge is devoted either to getting good quality results that would be automatic in a "lab", but out of an open flame and a bucket of water. A good deal more goes to getting non-relevant to woodworkers performance advantages or results. There are still higher orders of performance out there. There are smiths who keep learning more with each edge. One reason not to tell your secrets is because they probably won't help someone else anyway. As Hogan said of golf, "the screts are in the earth" meaning go dig yourself a few million holes with a wedge, a person might learn something.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#15

Re: Oh Please!

ThomD

>"I don't see Jim's postings as advertising,"

Hmm. I think those ones where he signs up about forty guys to get something are about as subtle as a Marine recruiter... But he is our marine recruiter!!

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#16

And...

Tony - Memphis

>Heat treating is really more of an art, not so much a science. I was in the race car parts biz for many years. Almost every part we sold was heat treated. It is very diificult to establish and maintain proper procedures. Especially on complicated parts. Even checking hardness is an art. Not as simple as some people assume. Our worst fears were realized a few times when our cams broke in very expensive NASCAR engines! Ouch. (Chevys were the worst - small journal diameters and a long distance between the back two journals). Anyway, it ain't quite so simple!

Tony (who plays a mechanical engineer during the day)

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#17

Pssst ..... Secrets Revealed !

Todd Hughes

>Heat to an orange color where a magnet won't stick, quench in some hot vegatable or motor oil edge downward. Don't switch back and forth but up and down. Take out let cool and put in oven at around 325 deg. for 1/2 hour / 45 min....OH ! Don't forget to label the container with the oil "Super Secret Quenching Formalor", and stand on one leg and mutter some mumbo jumbo when quenching in it just in case someone is watching !

....If you can get out of bed in the morning you can do it....

OK, OK ....You can torture me but I'm not giving up my secret Zippy the Pin Head Fan Club hand shake !.... Todd

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#18

Re: Pssst ..... Secrets Revealed !

ThomD

>Just take the magnet part of that. Some material need to be heated above the de-mag temp, O1 for instance, the mag is still useful, but not sufficient. Some material need to be held at "that" temp for a period of time before the quench, which is easy enough to do in an oven, but not in an open flame, so you need to know the technique for that. Some materials need to be instantly placed in the quench, others you can be casual about. Sometimes you need to heat the quench to a specific temperature to get it to cool the metal fast enough (??). Just about everything you do while forging can affect he final result when you turn to heat treating. One could go on for pages.

Todd is correct that you can do as he has suggested, and end up with a good result every time. In fact I sometimes wonder why everyone doesn't just try a small project like a screw drive, right now... I'll wait till you get back...

But that is like a beginer finishing his first wood project with Watco oil, and getting a really nice result. Doesn't mean the guy doing museum level retoration doesn't know a few more tricks.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#19

Yea, blame it on the cat...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Just kiddin...

If they turn out like mine did, there are going to be a lot of happy Hamler campers out there!

I know 80 planes were for sale. How many sets of blades have you made for them?

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#20

Secrets

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have to agree with your sentiments, Thom. I have a chisel made in Sheffield many years ago. It sharpens like a dream. On an oilstone, it grabs the stone and melts away like it was soft steel, yet it takes a very fine edge and is durable. I'm sure someone could identify the steel and the hardness, but I wonder if they could duplicate the performance.

I once revealed a secret on this forum that I thought I would never give up. Within an hour two regulars on this forum, quoting others, had responded to let me know how misinformed I was. It could be that some reader picked up on my "secret", but I doubt that also.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#21

Only a dozen

jim reed @ tallahassee

>sets have shipped so far. Three more are scheduled to go out. That leaves over sixty planes toothless.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#22

Re: Secrets

ThomD

>"but I wonder if they could duplicate the performance."

Not based on what is out there these days. I have some cast steel tools that are just like that too. I don't know what the secret is. It's somewhat the same performance one get from better Japanese tools, except they tend to be at a higher level of edge holding and edge fineness, at the cost of some significantly higher requirements in sharpening skill. Not always a good thing for every style of work. I would still like to know how they squared the circle.

A knife maker whose work I admire, though it really isn't to my personal tastes, is Ed Fowler. He is easy to like since he has written a lot of stuff. He has been gradually improving the edge holding performance in cutting tests, of his knives. He has raised the edge wear resistance about 3 fold, the same material nominally but a lot of work into heat treating. One interesting thing about his knives is that they do what the average ABS knife does, and they are designed to be completely resharpened on a single norton india stone, with a few strokes. It's a mater of finding a blend of desired characteristics and then over a lifetime of work expanding performance within them.

Re: Stanley Miller (Hamler) blade sets

#23

Ellis Walentine

I'm waiting with bated breath for mine...

Ellis Walentine

>