Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

Posts

More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

#1

More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I will quote from a response by Mr. Lee to a post last week.....

"But there is an additional reason I prefer O1 in a plane like an edge plane - it can be sharpened at lower bevel angles (and hold it's edge) than A2." ( I am confident this statement can be backed up with sound engineering data)

When it comes to chisels I don't think abrasion dulling is a significant factor. The toughness of the edge is what is important (which is why we advocated 3V for chisels). For ease of penetration by hand or mallet, the lowest bevel angle that will support the edge will be best.

Does it not follow that LN screwed up when they chose A2 for their chisel metal?

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

#2

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

John in New Mexico

>"Does it not follow that LN screwed up when they chose A2 for their chisel metal?"

Perhaps to an ultra-purist in such things (not implying anything). But they remain quality chisels like many others on the market. I suspect that the price of them has more to do with the name and the construction than the metal itself, so I wouldn't think it makes much difference what they make them out of. I've got both O1 and A2 plane blades, both work fine for me, and I expect chisels would be the same -- but then I'm pretty easy to please.

John

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

#3

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

MikeW

>"Does it not follow that LN screwed up when they chose A2 for their chisel metal?"

I don't think so. Not in the larger scheme of things anyway. While my preference lies with O1 for honing while working, I sharpen a general bench chisel at about their tolerance for angle anyway.

Now, for a paring chisel I think the style, length, and ability to have a lower angle without futzing (low primary and small micro secondary which doesn't hurt penetration) is a hindrance. As for length, I don't buy into the idea that swapping out for a longer handle makes a bench chisel into a paring chisel.

But for myself, I don't bash on bench chisels. I saw waste for DTs. I pare far more than I chop with the exception of mortising. So if a set of LN bench chisels landed on my doorstep, I would probably keep them--even though I am not fond of socket chisels.

Take care, Mike

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

#4

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Does it not follow that LN screwed up when they chose A2 for their chisel metal?

I can't answer that, but I recall Rob Cosman telling me that he re-ground his LN chisel down to 17 degree and the edge held well. That's for "chopping" dovetails, i.e. the part that's left after taking most of the waste with the coping saw, so it's something between paring and chopping.

I wanted to bring my sole LN chisel down to 20 degree or so to see how it holds, just never got around to it. In its original shape (30 degree bevel) the chisel holds its sharpness pretty well, but nowhere near what I get from my Japanese chisels.

DC

Who thinks most chisels are too long

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

#5

O-1 vs A2 for chisels - a bit long

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>The use of A2 was on my mind when I bought a set of Blue Spruce chisels. As with the LN, these are ground and honed at 30 degrees. The BS and the LN share another "identity", this being that they are viewed as chisels for dovetails.

While neither the BS and the LN are true "paring" chisels, both are touted as such. In the case of the BS I would call them "detail chisels". With the LN I would argue that they are bench chisels, regardless of whether thae are pared with the long Japanese-style paring handles that are available as an alternative to the original #750 design.

Like Mike, I prefer tanged chisels. They seem to have a lightness that cannot be matched by the more heavily constructed socketed chisels (with the exception of the Stanley #750 I have, and the LN which is based on these). I include my butt Witherbys as having a lighter feel than most, but still not in the same class as my tanged Bergs.

Reinforcing the paranoia over bevel angles is the design of Japanese chisels. My bench chisels and dovetail chisels, all used with a mallet, are ground and honed at 30 degrees. My parers, which are pushed, are ground and honed at 25 degrees.

Now my HCS Bergs are ground and honed at 20 degrees. The blades are thin, and they have a light and balanced feel, more so since I replaced the short original handles with long ones. In my mind these chisels are closer to your true paring chisels. They are not only in that the blades are shorter (still longer than most, but not as long as vintage parers).



In summary, those chisels that are hit tend to have bevels that are 30 degrees (and greater), while those that tend to be pushed have bevels that are lower, usually less than 25 degrees.

So why then did I buy the BS chisels for dovetail work, which in my case I use by pushing not hitting? The long and the short of it is "because they work!" Perhaps it is the shortness of the blade (of the BS) that allows for greater control. Perhaps it is that these edges get really sharp and hold it so well. Perhaps it lies in technique of use. They are beautifully balanced tools, permitting a lightness and delicacy of touch (I had Dave make a custom 3/4" for me, then sent it back as the steel was too long and too thick - 3/16" - which made the chisel too heavy. He made another in 1/8" and shorter, and this was just perfect).

I have a number of chisels (OK, I like chisels more than any other tool) and they get dedicated to specific tasks. My A2 BS chisels are only used for paring dovetails. For such a limited task they excell and the type of steel used does probably not get tested much. Then, again, many use Japanese bench chisels as their parers and the higher bevel angle does not seem to bother them either.



In my opinion the balance of a chisel and its ability to take and hold an edge has more relevance than the type of steel and the angle of the bevel. A2 may limit the lower end of the bevel angle, but at the appropriate angle it takes and hold a very fine edge and this is what counts when the other ingredients are present.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

#6

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

ThomD

>I don't think the angle on chisels is determined by the requirements of toughness in penetrative cuts. One can certainly make chisels that don't stand up to a hit and vibrate nastily. Those problems tend to have their origin well above the edge. But the edge breaking down, that seems an odd reason for determining chisel angles, just because it gets said over and over, the tools tell a different story.

Many tools whose edges are messed with quite horribly, from axes to plane blades have lower angle edges/bevels. I think the guiding principle is how the bewels set the edge aside when they are hit. A very narrow 3 degree blade can sometimes fully penetrate a joint in softwood in one cut from each side. But barring that you need to guide the chisel and determine the notch dimensions, and one does that with the bevel. It is another reason I generally prefer not to have micro bevels, though if they are present it won't ruin my party.

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

#7

Proof is in the pudding

Frank D. in Montreal

>The theory of bevel angels and steel type is interesting,

but i think the most important question is whether people actually have problems with chipping at the bevel angles they use. Most of my chisels are made with A2 and it hasn't really been a problem for me. I sharpen most of my chisels around 30 degrees. Even my Japanese paring chisels came sharpened from Japan at around 30 deg. I often shy away from theoretical discussions because IMO they don't really matter in the end. I think part of the Internet knowledge which tends to stray from practice (and which is often a target for criticism by experiences craftsmen) is because much of it is based on reading rather than experience. When I try to shave off some bubinga end grain I'm certainly happey my chisels are made os A-2.

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels

#8

Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels *LINK*

Brent

>I don't know that plane blade test results can be applied to chisels. In fact, I expect that demands on chisels are very different.

Just two examples. In the last week I cut 16 through mortises in fir with an older (Ibbotson, Shefield) chisel which has a 20 degree included angle with no edge problems. On the opposite extreme, the old English mortise chisels (pigstickers) that I have bought all came with 30+ degree included angles. I suspect these heavy chisels were used in production work in heavy timbers with large mallets with down time for sharpening much more an issue.

So, a wide range is indeed possible, depending on how hard you intend to use the chisel.

The bevel angle on saw teeth affects the performance in cross-cutting is a related way. The tip cuts first, then the tooth then pushes the chip sideways, loosening it. If the bevel is too great (the included angle too small) the saw will not work in hard woods because the tooth does not push the chip enough to break it off. See the Holly book on saws at the Toolemera site.

In mortising, the work is done by the bevel pushing the back of the chisel against the wood, breaking the chip out. Same chip-forming action as a cross-cut saw.

So, you may want a larger included angle for chisels working tough hardwoods for chip formation reasons, even if the edge can handle lower angles.

Testing chisels is much harder than testing plane blades - it is very hard to devise a repeatable, objective test. Any ideas?

Related, I have finished the first part of a study of edge sharpness versus steel type - that would apply to any edge tool. The testing shows that O1, A2, D2, and M2 (and other) steels can all be brought to the same initial sharpness.

If you are having trouble getting one of these steels sharp, you should be thinking of changing how you grind and hone.

Brent


Initial Sharpness - O1, A2, D2, M2, ...