Re: More discussion of O-1 vs A2- LN chisels *LINK*
Brent
>I don't know that plane blade test results can be applied to chisels. In fact, I expect that demands on chisels are very different.
Just two examples. In the last week I cut 16 through mortises in fir with an older (Ibbotson, Shefield) chisel which has a 20 degree included angle with no edge problems. On the opposite extreme, the old English mortise chisels (pigstickers) that I have bought all came with 30+ degree included angles. I suspect these heavy chisels were used in production work in heavy timbers with large mallets with down time for sharpening much more an issue.
So, a wide range is indeed possible, depending on how hard you intend to use the chisel.
The bevel angle on saw teeth affects the performance in cross-cutting is a related way. The tip cuts first, then the tooth then pushes the chip sideways, loosening it. If the bevel is too great (the included angle too small) the saw will not work in hard woods because the tooth does not push the chip enough to break it off. See the Holly book on saws at the Toolemera site.
In mortising, the work is done by the bevel pushing the back of the chisel against the wood, breaking the chip out. Same chip-forming action as a cross-cut saw.
So, you may want a larger included angle for chisels working tough hardwoods for chip formation reasons, even if the edge can handle lower angles.
Testing chisels is much harder than testing plane blades - it is very hard to devise a repeatable, objective test. Any ideas?
Related, I have finished the first part of a study of edge sharpness versus steel type - that would apply to any edge tool. The testing shows that O1, A2, D2, and M2 (and other) steels can all be brought to the same initial sharpness.
If you are having trouble getting one of these steels sharp, you should be thinking of changing how you grind and hone.
Brent
Initial Sharpness - O1, A2, D2, M2, ...