O1 or A2 ?!?
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>If� in you were going to take advantage of LV's edge trimming plane sale that expires tomorrow witch blade would you choose?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
O1 or A2 ?!?
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>If� in you were going to take advantage of LV's edge trimming plane sale that expires tomorrow witch blade would you choose?
Re: O1 or A2 ?!? *LINK*
barryvabeach
>Scott, I would go with A2 - the studies I have seen suggest A-2 lasts longer between sharpening - and I would rather spend less time sharpening
Brent's Sharpening page
Re: O1 or A2 ?!?
Gary Karner
>I ordered them in A2, I have A2 blades for my BU Jack and I'm sold.
Re: O1 or A2 ?!?
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>Second the A2.
I bought mine with the O1 blade, works wonderfully but needs to be honed more often than I like (most of my planes use A2). So I bought the A2 blade, but haven't got the chance to try it and compare with the original O1 blade. Whenever I get the chance I'll do a "scientific" comparison...
DC
A2
Jim in Burlington On
>What Dennis said plus those little irons are a PITA to sharpen so the less the better for me.
see recent Lee Valley catalog
Bill Tindal, E.TN
>There is an article on this very topic in recent Lee Valley catalog. Summary-O1 easier to sharpen but less abrasion resistant so it dulls quicker. Therefore, the answer depends on how you sharpen. With diamond they all cut quick but with a slow cutting technique the O-1 would be more practical because one would never get the A2 sharp.
Re: see recent Lee Valley catalog
Frank D. in Montreal
>Hi Bill,
Just a slight disagreement with your last statement, I think. I prefer A2 steel, and I can get it as sharp as 01 with water stones (or with oil stones, which I use less often though) with little effort. Would water stones be a slow-cutting technique? I don't examine edges with a microscope, but I do measure shavings on occasion, and my limit for both steels seems to be around .0003" thick, so I presume they're both the same sharpness.
Re: O1 or A2 ?!?
Rob Lee
>Hi Scott -
I'll add to the confusion... I prefer O1 (and like to sharpen)...
But there is an additional reason I prefer O1 in a plane like an edge plane - it can be sharpened at lower bevel angles (and hold it's edge) than A2...
Yes, there is a wear trade-off, but in a plane where the lowest possible effective cut angle is desirable, O1 should let you get to an angle at least 5 degrees less than A2...
Not much of a reason - but a reason nonetheless. Go with what you like!
Cheers -
Rob
"fast" cutting
Bill Tindal, E.TN
>I would regard water stones as fast cutting because they are designed to shed the dull grit and therefore almost continuously expose the metal to a fresh, sharp cutting edge. At least in my hands old fashioned oil stones in their various varieties are way slow because one is always cutting with a dulled abrasive particle. I suspect many would loose patience sharpening A2 with oil stones. I loose patience sharpening a cheap pocket knife with oil stones.
So Rob...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>You stated "but in a plane where the lowest possible effective cut angle is desirable"
Are these that type of plane? It seems to me that a lower cutting angle would be usefull on end grain applications, but that's about it. Care to elaborate?
And yes, you have done a fine job of adding to my confusion;^)
Re: O1 or A2 ?!?
Jamey Amrine in Ann Arbor
>I prefer O1. I have both for my LV bevel-up planes, and the O1 gets sharper. I used to use waterstones and now use oilstones. My A2 irons are packed and I haven't figured out what to do with them.
Thanks for all your input!
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>