Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Posts

Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#1

Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

wilbur

>I just posted a question on the main forum with this title, but if all you hand tool regulars could look at it, I'd be grateful.

I couldn't decide if my question should go here or the main forum, so I flipped a coin.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#2

Both

Ron in Kokomo

>Even if you are a power tool guy, the joint will be improved by a pass or two with a finely tuned jointer plane. It will remove the little ridges that all power jointers leave on the edge of the board

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#3

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

"RJ" Whelan

>Wilbur,

I almost always use a powered jointer to get close and then finish up with a #7 to "perfect" the joint.

To answer your question: you're correct; a jointer plane is shorter than the infeed and outfeed on a typical machine (6" and up, anyway), but using a handplane allows one to finesse the joint by making light passes in area that are a "little high". You can't really do this (safely) with a stationary jointer.

Additionally, there are many who like to do what's called a "sprung joint"; this is where there is a slight belly to the joint line and the joint is pulled together with clamp pressure - in theory this allows the endgrain to dry out without having the ends of the glue-up separate. This type of joint is impossible to do with a stationary tool - at least I can't visualize how it would be done.

Hope this helps .... rj

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#4

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>I, too, use a power jointer. then finish with hand plane--particularly for edge work. But last week at Marc Adams, I asked a well-known instructor whether he ever does the same thing with the edge that comes off a shaper with template, and he didn't know why anyone would take the time with either shaper or jointer.

Just can't convince everyone...

Best, Ted

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#5

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I don't mean to offend anybody, but it looks to me like the answers you got on the PT side came from folks who didn't have much hand plane experience. Anybody who says it takes a long time to true an edge with a hand plane simply doesn't know how to do it. This is the one operation where I think I could go toe to toe with a machine and win.

If you could do a consumer reports comparison, the quality would be better coming from the plane, the tool would be cheaper and easier to maintain, take up less space, make less mess, be more flexible in terms of spring joints as RJ described, match planing, handling large stock etc. The power jointer is one of these most dangerous tools in the woodshop.

I think when you look at the bigger picture you see that the try plane is a superior tool. The only reason I would resort to having a power jointer is if I had unskilled italian and irish employees who couldn't read, didn't speak english, and who I didn't want to train. I'd want to make sure there were no unions or workman's comp laws so I could throw these "mules with thumbs" (for teh moment anyway) at my array of power tools and whoever lived thru it would get paid on Friday.

Why any serious, skilled or at least thoughtful woodworker would want or use a power jointer escapes me.

How's that for the other side of the story! I especially liked the part about the Irish not speaking English.

Adam

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#6

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Gaelic is a bit difficult to understand, Adam. :)

That said, since most school systems of western Europe are far superior to ours, and since they all learn English these days, I have to wonder why you specified Irish and Italian as being illiterate, untrainable, etc. Perhaps it would have been more charitable and/or politic to specify poor, poorly educated Americans? You'd probably lust after H1B's for some non-Americans.

Other than that, I agree, hand jointers and try planes are better than powered jointers.

Pam

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#7

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Sgian Dubh

>"........it looks to me like the answers you got on the PT side came from folks who didn't have much hand plane experience."

Adam, I hope you didn't include me in your words above. I'd take that as a serious insult. Slainte.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#8

Not just edges...

John in New Mexico

>Hard to argue that its quicker to flatten a board with a handplane, though there are advantages to using one for the task.

John

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#9

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

wilbur

>Adam,

As I posted in the main forum, I should have picked a better title for my question. I wasn't looking to start a hand vs. powered jointing discussion. I was looking for an explanation as to how important jointer table bed length is for a powered jointer. According to every review I've read on powered jointers, increased table bed length is seen as a plus. In addition, I do have a Rikon 10" combo jointer/planer machine, which has a 40" bed and most comments that I have read about this and similar machines, like the Inca, have been along the lines of, "The bed is too short and it makes the jointer unusable."

Which led to my question: if jointer bed length is so important for its use, how is it that you can flatten boards with a hand plane, which is much shorter than any powered jointer? After thinking about it some more, I've decided that jointer bed length can make your life easier, but it is not necessary for jointing even long boards.

As for me, I tend to turn to the powered jointer to get close to my desired surface, and finish off with hand planes. For edge jointing, I've been able to do this just with hand planes fairly easily, as you say, but for face jointing I find the powered jointer to be a real time saver. But that's just me.

I also agree your comment about Italians and Irish was unnecessary.

Wilbur

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#10

I'm flattered

Adam Cherubini

>Richard, you man hole thrower, you flatter me that I could come close to insulting you!

I read your comment and thought it was pretty much awesome. Read down a bit and you'll see what I'm referring to.

But thanks for the sideways compliment!

Slainte to you to!

(whatever the heck that means)

Adam

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#11

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>This type of joint is impossible to do with a stationary tool - at least I can't visualize how it would be done.

Oh, that's easy to do, all you need is a tailed jointer with drooping tables :-)

DC

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#12

OT Irish and Italians (and Texans)

Adam Cherubini

>Pammy,

I just picked Irish and Italians for no good reason. Like others, they came here in droves in the late 19th and early 20th centuries and really became the prime movers of our economy. They were treated generally like garbage, as others were. "If Mules had thumbs, we'd hire 'em" is a quote from the time. I think of lot of the power tools we use today were developed for these unskilled laborers at that time and that was sorta my point.

I think its funny to single out these two nationalities specifically because, at least in my experience, ethnic prejudice with respect to them is pretty much gone. That said, I have some funny stories about working in the South! In Texas there was a conspiracy to mispronounce my surname to the point that they misspelled it on my company id badge. My name is kay-roo-bee-nee. Che is KAY in Italian. Some here say chair-roo-bee-nee. That's wrong but closer. In Texas they called me "cha-boonie" and my badge read "Cherbuni".

I don't care if people, heck, even my own family, mispronounce my name. I won't knowingly mispronounce it. I just thought having my name misspelled on my badge was funny.

Adam

P.S. BTW, I loved Texas. Loved the people, food, etc. The people I met were smart and friendly, many spoke Spanish. So I found it all the stranger that my Italian name gave them so much difficulty (or amusement???).

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#13

His comment was more about history...

John in New Mexico

>than nationality. Taken in the context of the turn of the last century, I take it more as a comment disparaging the working conditions of the time and the choices an employer might have made at that time.

John

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#14

I hear ya

Adam Cherubini

>You guys work faces with your jointers don't you. I take it your success really depends on the board though. If its wide that's a different story, if its wide and heavy its a different story and when you take sanding into account.....My guess is I could get a finished board faster with hand planes IN SOME CASES. Now it does take some skill, some experience or judgement.

In my view there's a wierd circular logic at play in woodworking today. Folks get really fussy with their hand planes then later pronounce them too slow. I'm not saying that's you. I just think its something to keep in mind when the subject turns to the use of dial indicators, micrometers, and granite surface tables.

Adam

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#15

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Adam Cherubini

>Sorry. I was really just picking up on the power tool prejudice of the other side and not really directly addressing your question. I do that sometimes. Sorry.

To you I would say whatever you do you are getting flatness or straightness over some length. I think you are right that the length of a plane- 20-30" is probably long enough to provide you with a flat enough surface. Remember that wood isn't all that stiff and in many cases, it will receive the shape you restrain it to. Also, if you take a really warped board and flatten it, it will likely not remain thus.

Still I can't resist the urge to say, I think jointers are silly. They are particularly dangerous and singularly easy to replace by hand. I can't say that about a table saw or chop saw or band saw.

Here's another reason- if you have a twisted board that you think you can restrain, how do you get a square edge on it? I can restrain out the twist on my bench and get a nice square edge. I don't know how one would do that with a power jointer of any size.

Adam

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#16

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

wilbur

>I guess if I had a twisted board that took restraining to get a straight edge, I'd probably go look for another board, or plane it down so that it's no longer twisted, assuming that the resulting thinner board was still useful for my purpose.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#17

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Adam Cherubini

>Wilbur, I see this on really wide stock- 15"+ wide. On these boards, the wind is easy to restrain out (with table buttons say or carcass dovetails), but sometimes you need a straight square edge.

Otherwise, I agree and I tend to reject twisted stock too. But in that case, you don't need a power jointer to face it do you?

I don't mean to be argumentative, truly. I'd like to see this in the "food for thought" category. In my mind, it doesn't rise to the "hill I want to die on" category.

Adam

Adam

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#18

that's it exactly, John

Adam Cherubini

>

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#19

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

Paul Kierstead

>Still I can't resist the urge to say, I think jointers are silly.

Hmm ... I don't know about silly. De-skilling a process is very much part of the industrial revolution and that whole shtick of increasing production while lowering cost. Now the powered jointer requires skill, but not at the level of the handplanes. You alluded to this yourself. So clearly they are not silly, just perhaps commercially expedient, just like sheet goods are (and in many ways superseded the jointer).

All that said, I am going to be going into my shop this weekend to photograph mine for sale (not to be replaced). I haven't turned it on in 6 months and am pretty sure I can live without it. Mind you, I do this for fun, and consider hand jointing to be a enjoyable pastime.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#20

Push down while crossing the middle

Paul Kierstead

>

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#21

Re: I'm flattered

Sgian Dubh

>I suspected you wouldn't think I was inexperienced with hand tools-- I've been around them for a very long time. But somehow I just can't get very excited about the idea of flattening, squaring and getting to thickness and width something like 20 cubic feet of english oak, or some European ash by hand with scrub planes, jack planes and try or jointer planes-- that's 240 board feet to you guys over there in Americaland.

At the rates charged for initial machining with power saws, power surface planers and power thicknessers, et al, you're looking at approximately 16 hours to process that 240 board feet.

I can't see anybody with hand tools keeping up with that 15 bd. ft., per hour throughput. Fun it might be to hand prepare everything for a wee job with no commercial pressure, but it's an almost guaranteed way of going out of business fast in most, but not necessarily all contemporary commercial furniture or joinery businesses. The waste is most likely higher, but speed and efficiency tends to be king. Slainte.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#22

Jointer bed length

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I'm going to go against the grain of common opinion and say that what's important is happening in the middle of the table. As long as you keep pressure on the board just past the cutters and just before the cutters, move the board along maintaining those pressure points, you can joint an infinitely long board. Of course, it will be real hard to do this for very long boards without infeed/outfeed tables, but it's possible.

Pam

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#23

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes *LINK*

MikeW

>And on Paul's note, the link below is to an article which appeared on the Old Tools list.

I've read it a few times. Corresponded with the author--who's in process of writing a book by the same title.

Mike


Shop Class as Soulcraft

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#24

Bed length, original question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Wilbur, it seems many have not really responded directly to your original question. The long bed length on a power jointer is helpful because for stock longer than twice the infeed (or outfeed) table it is difficult to control the board without the far end flopping around. That is why several mentioned having a helper with long stuff. Having long enough tables to get a flat cut is not really the issue.

With a hand plane the board is staionary and not difficult to control. While a skilled worker can joint a board with a short plane, it is easier and faster if the plane is longer. The trade off is that the longer the plane the more unwieldy it is. The 22 to 30 inch length is the compromise resulting from these two factors.

Re: Powered jointer vs. jointing with hand planes

#25

Re: OT Irish and Italians (and Texans)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Just about everyone mangles my name, too, so that now it's a non-issue with me. I thought your name was pronounced cherub-eenee, or possibley cheu-beenee. Sorry about that, I only learned enough Italian to ask software development questions, understand the answers, and get around Rome for a couple of weeks in '91.

Of course I was just egging you on here. Glad you liked Texas. I'm sure I don't, but I love Austin. :)

Pam