Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Tresle Feet , Pros and Cons?

Posts

Tresle Feet , Pros and Cons?

#1

Tresle Feet , Pros and Cons?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Well, following my normal M.O. I am planning on re-doing my workbench based a little on what Chris has said, and a little on space considerations in my shop, by changing the demions of the top and the base.

The top is currently 3'x6' and I definately am going to make it 2' wide vs the 3', and either shorten it to either 5' or 4' I can't decide which, tho I think I'll go to the 5' first.

The base is fully boxed, and currently has one drawer in it and I am stongly thinking of changing over to the Trestle Leg design for no other reason than I like the looks of them. I do however have concerns that the trestle feet might not really be adequate enough to hold the bench in place during heavy planing as well as the fully boxed base does. Can anybody confirm or deny this concern?

T.O.

Re: Tresle Feet , Pros and Cons?

#2

Both Confirm and Deny

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Todd,

The trestle will increase the footprint of the bench and provide increased friction between the floor. If however you put pads under the ends then the friction is reduced but its ability to sit flat is improved.

A fully boxed base, providing the joinery is tight will reduce racking when planing.

Hope that helps.

Stephen

Re: Tresle Feet , Pros and Cons?

#3

Re: Both Confirm and Deny

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Yeah, good points Stephen, and something I haden't had thought of, that being if I leave the feet full width than setting flat on the floor is going to be a problem. With pads on the ends of the feet than more than likely I'd have to attach a brace to the floor for it to hit against. To reduce racking I can see where I'd have to have cross members between at least the tops of the trestles.

Right now the top is made of edge glued 2x4's, so it's not all that heavy. Once I come up with some final demensions of a top that I can live with I'm thinking of making a new top out of either 2x6's or 2x8's, which will than more than likely cause my holdfasts not to work so well.

You know the drill, solve one problem and create two more-happens everytime I swear.

Ahhhhhhhh more fuel for the mental fire. Thanks for the input.

T.O.

Re: Tresle Feet , Pros and Cons?

#4

Re: Both Confirm and Deny

ThomD

>I don't like wide beches, but length is a positive, I would never shorten, so I assume you have good reasons for it.

I like the look of trestles also. I really can't give a good argument for them on a workbench, I am none to sure where they come from. They probably create problems if the floor is uneven, though they sell material for evening floors, and that would be a very good idea for the foundation of a workbench.

I don't think you will find the new base skids around all that much, it is just a mater of weight. I find the tresle base, properly made, particularly with wedges, to be about as rack free as anything can be. It also excells at providing the odd post for heavy pounding, something one would not get with a box construction.

Re: Tresle Feet , Pros and Cons?

#5

force of friction

Ryan Stagg - Cincinnati

>Sorry to have to disagree, but the force of friction is independent of surface area for inelastic materials. Four pointy legs, one big boxed base, or two big trestle feet exhibit approximately the same friction given equal weight.

Now, if you coat your trestle bottoms or fully boxed base with rubber, that changes things...

Re: Tresle Feet , Pros and Cons?

#6

Re: Tresle Feet , Pros and Cons?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Todd,

I am not sure you should cut down your bench unless you don't use the entire thing,

I however have a slightly different problem. The bench is 8 feet long and the stuff I am planing is 16'5".

Stephen


img

Re: Tresle Feet , Pros and Cons?

#7

Need all the weight you can get...

John in New Mexico

>Thats what will increase the friction and give you good resistance to heavy planing. Since you're sure you'll shrink the top, I'd keep the box base and add some drawers or other storage for all that nice heavy iron you've got laying around ;). Maybe you should get more too!

As cool as trestle legs are, I like cabinet style bases for storage. I'll post a pic of mine if I ever finish it!

John