Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

backsaw with combo teeth?

Posts

backsaw with combo teeth?

#1

backsaw with combo teeth?

Marv

>How would one describe handsaw teeth that are filed as combination teeth? The only method I'm familiar with is to add a little fleam or bevel to teeth that are filed as rip. Are there other ways of doing it?

Thanks,

Marv

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#2

Re: back-saw with combo teeth?

Bart Leetch

>Why would you want to do this to a saw? A rip saw is filed the way it is because you want a narrow kerf for doing things like dovetails. A cross cut tooth is filed & set to cut tenons & across the grain being able to clear the chips out of the saw kerf. These saws are used for to very different things. Although some people use a cross cut style saw to cut dovetails.

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#3

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

MikeW

>"How would one describe handsaw teeth that are filed as combination teeth? The only method I'm familiar with is to add a little fleam or bevel to teeth that are filed as rip. Are there other ways of doing it? "

Hi Marv,

It depends. Saw teeth are in practice somewhere between a "pure" rip (zero rake and fleam) and a cross cut with a lot of rake and fleam.

When I file a handsaw for someone who wishes to do some ripping and cross cutting, I term it a strong cross cut. That is, perhaps 10 degrees of rake and 12-15 degrees of fleam. But that too depends on the woods they tell me they are using.

But there are lots of variations of teeth shapes for various purposes. One can change the back shape of the tooth, file peg teeth, and the list goes on.

There are old patented filings. Of them, maybe 10 or less that pertain to handsaws really account for much real sawing difference. But they are not "termed" anything. A few make a real difference, including one which is great for cross cutting and ripping...but it's a time consuming filing job.

I suspect the above rambling doesn't really answer your question and so apologize...

Take care, Mike

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#4

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

Marv

>Thank you Mike..!

Always good to have someone with alot of knowledge about a certain subject confirm or clarify one's doubts about something.

I normally don't vary much from basic rules that I follow when sharpening rip or crosscut saws. But I have a good customer who has asked me to file his backsaw with a combo profile. I'm thinking that the easiest method is to merely file the teeth with an 8 degree rake and with an 8 degree fleam. That way both rip and crosscutting would be the least compromised. Compromising is a given anytime we attempt to make the same teeth do both jobs.

Thanks again for your response.....Marv

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#5

Re: back-saw with combo teeth?

Marv

>Hi Bart....

Thanks for your question. A valid one at that. And what you say about rip versus crosscut is exactly right.

Drop down and read what Mike said. He says it better than I can.

Marv

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#6

Re: backsaw with combo teeth? *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Marv,

Three examples of teeth that are modified, or fall somewhere between pure rip and pure cutoff (90 degree crosscut).....

1. Japanese impulse-hardened combination tooth; Japan Woodworker Cat. No. 19.303.

Generally, I like the real-deal Japanese saws, but this is an unusual and effective backsaw, in my opinion. I've had mine a long time, so don't know if the tooth has changed in the meantime. And also don't know if the same tooth profile would work on a western saw. This is a 19tpi saw, and it's hard to see precisely what is happening with the tooth. But under a magnifier, it appears that the tooth is basically a rip tooth--no fleam. But (remember, Mike W. mentioned 'top treatment'), each tooth has a facet on the top back, which puts a sloping shoulder on the top of the tooth, if viewed from the front. So the tooth presents to the work as a rip tooth, but has this point at the top, which must be what gives it a decent crosscut action. This saw will rip and crosscut well. Mine is about zero rake.

Question: Can anyone else confirm my observations about this particular saw's tooth configuration? I think the above is correct, but it's hard to make out exactly with small teeth at 19tpi.

2. Previous post by Don McConnell (see link at bottom)

Don McConnell made a remarkable post about a month ago, where he was summarizing the filing recommendations of a turn-of-the-last-century saw doctor named Charles Johnson. See link to Don's post below. What this summation of filing methods brings out is that, in the old days, there was a continuum of filing options between pure rip and pure cutoff. Short and long miters were in-between options. The differences lay in the interaction between fleam angle and rake angle.

3. Disston's Lumberman's Handbook of 1907. Here is a link, courtesy of the Disstonian Institute:

http://www.disstonianinstitute.com/sawfiling1.html

In this remarkable article, Disston discusses fleam and other filing modifications, to be used for different purposes in differing woods. He makes reference to putting a smaller fleam angle on the back of the tooth (than on the leading edge), so as to create a flatter top profile (front view) to be used in hard woods. So this is not so much a combination tooth as a modification to deal with harder or softer woods. Incidentally, this material is only to be found in the 1907 Disston Lumbermans Handbook, and the purchaser of the later version offered by Astragal Press will be disappointed a bit--thanks to Disstonian Institute for publishing this version.

Hope there's something of use in here.....

Wiley


Don McConnell's post on Charles Johnson's methods

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#7

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

Marv

>Thank you Wiley....

Lots of good information you presented. I don't know, I'm kind of a simple minded kinda guy and tend to stick to what works, especially when I'm sharpening saws for other people. But I don't mind experimenting when filing my own saws. The feedback I get from my customers pretty much dictates what I'm doing that is right. Reading about all the variations when it comes to filing a handsaw can end up in a foggy kind of state of mind. When my customers compare my filing to people like Tom Law and others, I think I'll stick to what I'm doing. But back to the subject at hand....filing a combo profile. I actually don't see the logic in doing it when it's so easy to grab the other saw. Anyone doing tenons and such probably will have both a rip and a CC. On the other hand I like to please my customers as much as I can. If it wasn't for them I wouldn't be having all this fun.

Thank you for taking the time to respond so extensively.

Marv

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#8

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

Marv

>Hi Wiley,

Just a few comments on your 19tpi saw. Once you get to that number of teeth per inch (20PPI), whether they are filed rip or crosscut probably in most situations won't make much difference as long as they are sharp. They'll cut wood with the grain and across the grain with little noticable difference. The thickness of the blade also plays a part. A blade like that is approaching a knife edge with nicks in it. Am I right in saying the Japanese harden those teeth to keep them sharp, not intending to ever sharpen them again? I must confess I have not used one of those saws, so I'm merely applying some logical thinking here.

Thanks again for your info.

Marv

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#9

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Marv,

Thank you for the perceptive comments on that saw. It's basically a plywood saw I think, but thought that tooth might possibly have some interest. However, as you say, 19tpi and thin blade is a whole different thing, so probably would not have any applicability to western saws. And yes, the induction-hardened blades are not re-sharpenable--you throw em out when they start breaking down. I mentioned it because it's the only saw I ever saw that would rip and crosscut pretty well.

I've admired your work before, I think on ebay!

Wiley

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#10

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

Marv

>Hi Wiley,

Thanks for the compliment on my work.

Yes, I sell reconditioned saws on eBay. You can look for one I have scheduled to start tomorrow at 3:00pm west coast. You might like the wheat carving. It's a "nicely" pitted Disston 12" 14PPI No.4 tenon. filed rip with a 4 degree rake, zero fleam. I use the word "nicely" loosely and with tongue in cheek. I'm sure I'm among the majority regarding pitting in general but I try to work around and with them mainly because I'm trying to sell my saws. If I didn't I wouldn't be reconditioning very many older saws. Believe it or not they can be made to be quite useable again in spite of the pitting except in extreme cases. Sometimes a tooth will have pitting directly on it. With those teeth I just don't set them. With smaller teeth it doesn't seem to be noticable.

BTW....I just finished filing a combo profile 14" 12PPI backsaw. I filed it with an 8 degree rake with a 10 degree fleam. It does a good job of ripping Mahagony but isn't as smooth crosscutting. It cross cuts ok if very little downward pressure is exerted but when ripping, more than normal downward pressure is required. I first tried it with a 4 degree rake and it wouldn't cross cut for sour apples. Any more than 8 degrees would take forever to make a rip cut.

Thanks again,

Marv

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#11

Re: back-saw with combo teeth?

Bart Leetch

>Hi Bart....

Thanks for your question. A valid one at that. And what you say about rip versus crosscut is exactly right.

Drop down and read what Mike said. He says it better than I can.

Marv

Thanks Marv it nice to know I at least sound like I may know what I'm talking about.

I have some saws I need sharpened I try to include a pic.


img

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#12

Re: back-saw with combo teeth?

Marv

>Hi Bart...

Are we allowed to solicit business here in this forum?

You want me to file them all with a combo profile, right? *just kidding*

Where do I find your email address? I'll email you directly

Marv

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

#13

Re: backsaw with combo teeth?

Charles

>All of your backsaws, or fine toothed saws, can be filed rip. If you're worried about a little rag on a crosscut then knife and chisel a line all the way around the workpiece which you should do anyway on joinery crosscuts.