Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Patching a Transtional planes mouth

Posts

Patching a Transtional planes mouth

#1

Patching a Transtional planes mouth

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Yeah, it's me again. Like I said in my previous post, I was cleaing out my hand tool cabinet and came across some more "project" planes.

They are a Stanley #26 jointer and a #23 coffin smoother. Both are transitional planes and both look to be in fine shape over all. But I was toying with the idea of adding a patch to close up the mouth. I have some nice pieces of pear or apple that would work perfectly. Or if I'm feeling brave, hickory or Osage (they'd NEVER wear out!). However, I'm not sure if these planes even need to have their mouths "closed".

I was about to flatten the bases. And I reasoned this process would open the mouth up slightly (depending on how much I took off). From my initial inspection, the bases don't appear too far out. It will only take a small bit to flatten them up.

I guess my question is; how do you determine if the mouth is too wide?

Thanks in advance,

Dominic

Re: Patching a Transtional planes mouth

#2

First off, get it flat...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Then get the blade sharp and put it back together. Give it a try and see if your happy with the results. If your getting some tearout then patch the mouth. File it open carefully to get a nice tight mouth.

Re: Patching a Transtional planes mouth

#3

Thanks Scott!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Scott,

That's what I figured I would do. Main thing is to get it flat first.

Horror of horrors, I was figuring on using a trim router with a 1/4" mortising bit to mill out the flat for the patch! Hell, if I was REAL slick I'd use a router with bushings in conjunction with a template to cut the mouth and the patch as well! Would that be considered sacrilege? :>)

Thank you for responding to this question. I was concerned that no one was going to.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Patching a Transtional planes mouth

#4

Easy there Norm!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Back away from the template and bushing... slowly!

If you need to patch it cut, the patch first. Trace the outline on the plane. Then you can use the screaming finger eater to remove most of the waste. Use a sharp chisel to clean up to the outline. Leave the pencil intact (kinda like cutting DT). Then glue in the patch. It's pretty easy to do and get a nice tight fitting patch.

Good luck!

Re: Patching a Transtional planes mouth

#5

Re: Patching a Transtional planes mouth

James Watriss

>Well, see now, I think you're all crazy.

IMHO, transitional planes have a fatal drawback. Granted, this is my own opinion, but so be it. I think the throats are too tight to begin with. A shaving that curls well will jam up the throat halfway to the top of the plane, and it won't exit cleanly.

Sharpen it up, try it out. If it jams up, this is what I had to do to get mine running properly...

Hog out a huge gap in front of the blade, 3/4 to 1" deep, and probably 2" forward of the blade, for hte shavings to curl into. You can put your fingers in there to pull out shavings as it fills up.

Then patch the thing to get a nice tight mouth.

Re: Patching a Transtional planes mouth

#6

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Patching a Transtional planes mouth

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Since the sole(s) have undoubtedly worn down, and may have even been planed smooth (again) by a previous owner, your plans may be significantly shorter than they started out. This also causes the mouth to get wider.

Consider adding a new sole plate. Make it out of something hard and durable. Goncalo alves, lignum vitae, even hard maple or cherry all work very well. Just use your jointer (I mean your #7 or #8, not the power one!) to get the sole clean and flat, then glue on the new sole and cut the mouth through it. You end up with a plane that's actually better than new.

I have an old #35 that had had a full 3/8" taken off it before I got it. I put a goncalo alves sole on it, and it became one of my favorite users.

Jim D.