Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus *LINK*
Dave Mount, NE Minnesota
>Hey Scott--
Can't you just get Todd Hughes to ship you one from his fleet?
Surf on over to the link below, the anvilfire.com FAQ list, and read the anvil selection FAQ and the associated materials.
I got mine at an estate auction; its an unmarked vintage anvil with seemed to be of good quality to my relatively inexperienced eye/touch. Well after the purchase it was evaluated by those who know and they pronounced it a good quality vintage anvil of unknown origin -- quality judged by its ring and apparent durability of the face. Everything else I will tell you is what I learned through my process of researching the question you are asking.
I'm assuming you are intending to do actual smithing. If so, any new anvil selling for less than $4 or $5/lb is not worth buying. On the anvilfire the refer to the cheap anvils you see on Ebay or import tool dealers as "ASOs" which stands for "anvil-shaped objects". . .meaning they may look like an anvil, but they aren't *really* an anvil. They are made of cast iron or soft steel and won't stand up to hammering and won't rebound your hammer either. Quality anvils are expensive to make and they don't come cheap as a result.
One of the most suggested routes to getting an anvil is to find a local smithing group and ask around that group. You can find lists of ABANA chapters on the web with contact info.
The older quality anvils are wrought iron with a hardened steel face forge welded on. Later quality anvils are cast steel or a casting with a hardenable face welded on. There's all kinds of debate on the relative merits of different types, but the basic thing is, it has to have a face of hardened steel, not mild steel or cast iron. Peter Wright is the standard of vintage English style anvils. Other popular makers include Hay-Budden, Fisher, and Trenton. That's not to say you can't have a good quality vintage anvil outside these, or even unmarked, like mine.
I won't try to describe the process of evaluating a vintage anvil -- the anvilfire FAQ goes through that.
The two names of new anvil makers that seem to be at the top of the class in the world of opinions are Nimba and Rat Hole Forge -- you can Google either of them up. There are other new anvils which seem to be regarded as good quality, such as Delta and Peddinghaus. Prominent sellers of new anvils and forging tools include:
www.blacksmithdepot.com
www.piehtoolco.com
www.blacksmithsupply.com
www.centaurforge.com
The general impression I've gotten from my reading is if those sellers say it is a serviceable anvil, it is. Not necessarily top quality, but at least adequate.
Glad to hear you're going to join in the fun!
Dave
Anvilfire FAQs