Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

Posts

I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#1

I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Ol' Verdi has me thinking it's time to get a anvil. What does one look for in a anvil? Cast, hardened steel? What do I look for and what should I avoid. Who made (makes) a good one.

I don't need anything too big, I'm thinking 100-200 lbs.

What does the ye chorus think...

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#2

Depends

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>on what you want to do. I use a 55# HF anvil and love it. Easy to move around, works great. But all I do is straighten plane blades and stamp plane blades with numbers. This thing is probably too soft for serious smithing work.

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#3

Re: Depends

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I can vouch for the HF anvil being not suitable for any real blacksmith work. I bought one years ago and when I hit it with a hammer it dented! I gave it to a buddy of mine who wanted an anchor for a small boat.

I don't think you can go wrong as long as you buy an old anvil, but I am certainly no authority on the them either. Thbe names Fischer and Hay-bidden come to mind, but they usually go for good money. coarse, buy quality and cry once as always applies here as well.

There are plenty of Blacksmithing websites and I'm sure you could gain alot of info from them. There are many different styles of anvils as well to watch for. you'll want to get one for thespecific wants that you plan on doing with an anvil/blacksmithing. Research, research, research.

T.O.

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#4

Dude!

Scott in Douglassville

>What the hell are you gonna do with a 200 pound anvil?!

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#5

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus *LINK*

Dave Mount, NE Minnesota

>Hey Scott--

Can't you just get Todd Hughes to ship you one from his fleet?

Surf on over to the link below, the anvilfire.com FAQ list, and read the anvil selection FAQ and the associated materials.

I got mine at an estate auction; its an unmarked vintage anvil with seemed to be of good quality to my relatively inexperienced eye/touch. Well after the purchase it was evaluated by those who know and they pronounced it a good quality vintage anvil of unknown origin -- quality judged by its ring and apparent durability of the face. Everything else I will tell you is what I learned through my process of researching the question you are asking.

I'm assuming you are intending to do actual smithing. If so, any new anvil selling for less than $4 or $5/lb is not worth buying. On the anvilfire the refer to the cheap anvils you see on Ebay or import tool dealers as "ASOs" which stands for "anvil-shaped objects". . .meaning they may look like an anvil, but they aren't *really* an anvil. They are made of cast iron or soft steel and won't stand up to hammering and won't rebound your hammer either. Quality anvils are expensive to make and they don't come cheap as a result.

One of the most suggested routes to getting an anvil is to find a local smithing group and ask around that group. You can find lists of ABANA chapters on the web with contact info.

The older quality anvils are wrought iron with a hardened steel face forge welded on. Later quality anvils are cast steel or a casting with a hardenable face welded on. There's all kinds of debate on the relative merits of different types, but the basic thing is, it has to have a face of hardened steel, not mild steel or cast iron. Peter Wright is the standard of vintage English style anvils. Other popular makers include Hay-Budden, Fisher, and Trenton. That's not to say you can't have a good quality vintage anvil outside these, or even unmarked, like mine.

I won't try to describe the process of evaluating a vintage anvil -- the anvilfire FAQ goes through that.

The two names of new anvil makers that seem to be at the top of the class in the world of opinions are Nimba and Rat Hole Forge -- you can Google either of them up. There are other new anvils which seem to be regarded as good quality, such as Delta and Peddinghaus. Prominent sellers of new anvils and forging tools include:

www.blacksmithdepot.com

www.piehtoolco.com

www.blacksmithsupply.com

www.centaurforge.com

The general impression I've gotten from my reading is if those sellers say it is a serviceable anvil, it is. Not necessarily top quality, but at least adequate.

Glad to hear you're going to join in the fun!

Dave


Anvilfire FAQs

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#6

Straightening plane blade Q

Chuck Nickerson

>Do you need to heat the blade to soften it first? I accidently bought some bent millwright chisels (I hate buying used tools). I'd love to be able to reclaim them.

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#7

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

ThomD

>If you can leave the anvil in place, then weight shouldn't bother you. More weight is better if you want to really move some metal around. In most cases though, people who do that kind of thing use power somethingorothers.

An anvil is a serious tool, and you need to consider form, condition, materials and heat treating, seriosuly just as you do with anything. Basically grab the first freebie you see in your travels.

You can make your own anvil but you need a freeish source of materials and that is becoming ever more rare as the price of metal rises. There is an interesting video on making your own anvil. I would love to try it, but I don't have the slug required.

If you live near Port Townsend, you could scoop up one of these:

http://www.anvils.nimbaforge.com/

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#8

Cold work

jim reed @ tallahassee

>Heating would make the job easier, but I just bash away. My guess is that your chisels are hardened only a few inches from the tip. You can find out using a pocketknife. It should skate along the tip, but begin to dig in as you move up toward the handle. Once you determine where the soft is and where the hard is, you know what to avoid with the hammer. I think putting them in the sun on a hot day would warm them up enough to bash them back into shape. Good luck.

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#9

Re: Dude!

Phil Joines Krum,TX

>200 lb is on the light side for serious hot work. Most of the guys really into smithing around here have them in 5-700 lb range. Mine's 150 but

I don't do forge welding or work on large pieces, mostly 5/8 or smaller.

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#10

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus *LINK*

Andrew Lunn

>Hi Scott,

I've attached a link to the FAQ page at anvilfire.com. Look under anvil selection; it will answer lots of your questions. Also, your library might have a copy of this book--Anvils in America, by Richard Postman. It is a great resource for knowing what it is you are looking at when you see an older anvil.

Good luck!

Andrew


anvilfire FAQ page

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#11

I wanna Todd Huges!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Put some black powder under it, light it, and RUN!

Kidding aside, that seems to me to be on the high end of what I'd be using it for.

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#13

Thanks Everyone!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>You all gave me a bit of homework to do. Lot's of good information too! Just looking on the DaBay and holy cow, some sure go for big bucks.

Thanks again!

Maybe one of these days I'll remember to spell check my posts;^)

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#14

Re: Thanks Everyone!

ThomD

>I know what you mean, after seeing them dropped on cartoon characters all those years. But some of them are ncely shaped variably hardened steel just like a really good chisel, but a lot heavier. and then the scrap value of steel alone these days... At retail it's about 2 bucks to 9 bucks a pound around here for mild steel (we are getting gypped)

Re: I wnt to play in the Anvil Chorus

#15

Yea, whatever happened to...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>The ACME anvil company? Guess it went the way of Buggy Bunny...