Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Holdfasts with a twist

Posts

Holdfasts with a twist

#1

Holdfasts with a twist

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>A few members of our local association had holdfasts make by a blacksmith somewhere around town (and I don't remember the name, terrible, I know, Terry, are you around?).

In any case, every time I've seen pictures or videos of holdfasts in action, the user always put a piece of scrap wood between the holdfast and the work piece. I've always thought, how inefficient...

So I decided to do something about that. I drilled the holdfasts' pad with a 7/32" bit, and attached a countersunk piece of white birch (not too soft, not too hard) with a #10 screw, with a spring, washer and nylon locknut. Tried the result on the softest piece of wood I had lying around (spruce), and even with whacking the holfast very hard, no indentations whatsoever on the workpiece. Works great!

DC


img

Re: Holdfasts with a twist

#2

Re: Holdfasts with a twist

TiO

>I knew I should have charged more for those holdfasts. Myabe then you'd have been tempted to try double sided tape before drilling holes in them.

Anyway, glad they're holding fast for you. Do you think Bob will follow your lead?

Re: Holdfasts with a twist

#3

Re: Holdfasts with a twist

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Geez Terry, didn't know I was committing heresy :-)

Double sided tape wouldn't have held up in use, I'm afraid. With the spring inserted, it allows the wood pad to conform to the piece being held, which is a nice feature. My bolts should be a bit longer, though (I used what I had around at the time).

I guess one could take a less "invasive" approach and use some kind of rubber band to hold the wood pad in place.

As for Bob, I'll have to post a pic on our association's group, I don't think he visits here very often (although he should...)

DC

Re: Holdfasts with a twist

#5

I have to respond

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Denis,

I can see the advantage of an attached block of wood to protect the stuff you are working on. I work almost exclusively with pine and use holdfast regularly and need the protection.

I have tried leather, cork and thin wood glued to the pad of the holdfast but if it is not big enough it still leaves a blossom. A dedicated piece of wood semi-permanently attached to the holdfast would be a hinderance, especially holding small pieces.

One design problem I see with those holdfasts is the thickness of the pad. Most old holdfasts, existing examples and those depicted in original illustrations and paintings show holdfasts with thin and wider pads. With a low thin pad it is easier to work over the top of the holdfast. The low profile is out of the way if it is holding a stop block for planing.

Another method of using a holdfast to secure your work is with a beam or bridge board. The stuff being held is positioned, a piece of wood the same thickness is placed as a pier away from the work stuff. The beam or bridge is a stiff piece of wood that spans the pier and the stuff and the holdfast in between holds the beam and never contacts the stuff.

Stephen

Re: Holdfasts with a twist

#6

Re: I have to respond

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I had thought of adding cork (but not leather), my metal vises are actually coated with cork and they work fine.

What the picture doesn't show is that the wood pad is free to rotate and swivel, so it always lies flat on the work piece. I also relieved the corners of the pad so that no sharp edges can get in contact with the work piece.

Regarding holding small pieces, I don't know how small you have in mind, but there's nothing to keep one from shaping the wood pad so that one side projects less than the other, if that's necessary to provide clearance. With use I'll find out if I need to change the shape of the wood pad. I could also use a softer species, time will tell if either is needed.

I agree with you that the holdfast pad/tip would be better if made thinner. To my knowledge this is the first batch that the blacksmith built, and I know that he will appreciate the feedback.

Cheers,

DC

Re: Holdfasts with a twist

#7

food for the blacksmith

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Holdfasts are indespensible as far as I am concerned, I have 4 and could always use more. I have holes in the posts that hold up my shop and can fix anything to them. I also have holes in my saw horses to accept the holdfasts. I also use them on the apron and front legs of my workbench to hold stuff as I do not have a permanent vice on my workbench, they get in the way most of the time.

As for the shape, the classic design with the nice gooseneck looks the best but those (and there are a number of originals with this shape) that are L-shaped, 7-shape do show up. While they look funky they are very servicable and the lack of the elogant gooseneck helps as it doesn't get in the way of your work.

Also the neck should be thinner to allow for some spring when it is driven tight. The pad should be wide to distribute the weight, slightly convex so the edges don't leave marks and smooth as any irregularities will be left as marks in the blossum.

I try and use the holdfast to hold work I need to do, prior to flat planing the surfaces, so blossums don't matter much, they can be removed. When I am planing first then using the holdfast, I always protect the surface with a piece of scrap wood of a softer species (or same species) that I am working on.

Stephen