WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Unkown treasure or a fluke?

Posts

Unkown treasure or a fluke?

#1

Unkown treasure or a fluke?

Dave Mount, NE Minnesota

>Over the years I've picked up an assortment of stray gouges when opportunity presents itself. Recently I decided that I needed to prune down to those I would actually use and sell the rest. I put this 1" Buck gouge up on you know where. I started it at $0.99 hoping I might get a ten spot out of it (I paid $5 for it). To my surprise, it went for over $38, and this wasn't two people duking it out, it was two high bids placed when the price was at $5. The eventual winner placed a high bid well before closing, then someone tried to snipe at $37 and didn't beat the earlier bid (makes me wonder how high that was).

The maker's mark is Buck Bros Cast Steel with the deer head in the middle. It didn't draw this money based on looks -- is there something special about this gouge that I was unaware of, or just one of those things that happens in auctions sometimes?

Best,

Dave


img

Re: Unkown treasure or a fluke?

#2

Re: Unkown treasure or a fluke?

DickL

>Wow! Dave, that is a one of a kind, special Buck gouge. One just sold at an antique tool auction for $15,650. Just kidding. Don't have a clue - I think you did well. NE Minnesota - isn't that Wisconsin?

Regards,

Dick

Re: Unkown treasure or a fluke?

#3

Re: Unkown treasure or a fluke?

Mike G.

>A couple of years ago, before I decided I wanted to start carving, my wife sold several Buck Bro.'s gouges on the 'Bay and I believe she got between 25 and 40 bucks for each one. I think we had about a dozen or so. The same bidder won nine of them from us.

Mike G. in SC

Re: Unkown treasure or a fluke?

#4

Re: Unkown treasure or a fluke?

Phil Joines Krum,TX

>We have some early Bucks from about 1870ish. I haven't checked into the company but they came from a 70 year old gent. They were his father's, an architectural carver. They hold an edge much better then any of the new ones we've tried.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.