Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

What's different with this edge plane?

Posts

What's different with this edge plane?

#1

What's different with this edge plane?

HC Sakman

>Perhaps some would remember.... Here in this forum, I suggested Rob Lee that Veritas should make the LH version. Well, here it is!

It's very well machined and improvements are ingenious as well as being functional. Larger palm resting area makes a big difference. I guess Derek Cohen will go over the details.

It's worth every penny I paid and probably more.

Thanks for listening Rob.

Chico...


img

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#2

Geez...

Rob Lee

>... those aren't available yet!!! :o

Stock won't hit the stores/warehouse for another three weeks or so.... Chico got an early one, 'cause he pushed us into it...

It's not the only thing he's pushed for either.... ;) (no Chico - you can't tell yet!) :)

Don't know if Derek has to say anything.... just read his previous comments while looking at the images with a mirror....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#3

Spending money?

Charles R. Smith

>So Chico, you go over to Vancouver to deliver that gorgeous wine cabinet and then you take the money to the nearby Lee Valley store and get a new plane? Why don't you just sell a wine cabinet to Rob Lee and get him to pay you with Lee Valley toys??!?

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#4

That's a plan! Thanks Charles! ;-)

HC Sakman

>

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#5

Hey! Cool!

John in New Mexico

>I never bought the LN adjustable block plane, 'cause though its a lot sexier than my Stanley, its just too darn small for my paws.

I'm guessing at least one of LV's tool designers has hands my size ;).

John

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#6

Re: Geez...

Ernie Miller

>what else has he pushed for? only little things LIKE A STORE!

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#7

Not a review

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I have not seen or used the new LV (left hand) edge plane. I have briefly owned and used the right hand version, and compared this to the LN version in a thread last year. I do not know how to link to a specific post in the archive, so have pasted my response below (with a couple of minor edits).

Subject: A little about the LV vs LN versions

Date: Friday, 8 September 2006, at 10:33 p.m.

In Response To: New Iron Edge Trimming Plane from Lee Valley (Richard A. Gillespie, Jr.)

"I have had the right- and left hand LN set since January this year.. They are nicely made and I am happy with them. Useful tools.

I did start out with the LV version, and chose this in preference to the LN option at the time. In handling them in the store I thought that the extra size cut of the LV (full 1" width) would be more useful, that the fit and finish was slightly better on the LV (yes that is LV) than on the LN, and that the design modification was an improvement on the Stanley-based #95 original (the mouth is set slightly further back, providing better registration).

Back in my workshop I found the LV to be ultra reliable and do what it needed. However I began to be increasingly aware that I needed both RH and LH versions. This must be understood in the light that I hand shape/dimension all my wood, and some boards will be very slightly out of square at different points along the edge. Trimming the other side of a board by turning the edging plane around (to cut with the grain) is not an option. Since a different handed LV was not available, nor was there any indication of one forthcoming, I returned the single LV and bought the LN twin set.

In practice there is little difference between the LN and LV. I don't notice the reduced cutting width (7/8" for the LN verses the 1" of the LV), and the other factors have recessed into memory. I am happy with the LN set but view the new improved LV design with the new blade adjuster to be a desired feature (the LN and earlier bronze LV versions use a lever - similar to a Stanley #78 - which is likely to be less precise). I do not have a beef with either of the fences - both the LN and LV were perfectly square on mine. If anything I prefer the slightly narrower LN version since, as this does not affect accuracy, it allows a slightly wider range of board widths that I can use it on.

Incidentally, the #95 was the first tool produced by LN, the one that started them on their journey."

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#8

Clarification

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>We really need an edit facility. I stabbed what I thought was the "preview" button and actually hit the "post" one.

What must be understood is that my comments above were in regard to the bronze LV and bronze LN #95s. It was the fit and finish of the bronze LV that I preferred over that of the bronze LNs. I have neither handled nor used the new iron LV #95-derived planes. The latter have a further modification to the blade adjuster, one that I will predict to be a big improvement over the lever action of the bronze LN and LV versions. In practice, there is not much adjustment that needs to be made once it is set, but the lever is a rather primitive way of adjusting depth of cut. Play with a Stanley #78 and you will understand what I mean.

Can we get an Edit Button please?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#9

"No edit" keeps people on their toes...! ;-)

HC Sakman

>

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#10

The LV is much more comfortable than the Stanley

Don in Northern Arizona

>My hands are only a little bigger than average, but most Stanley totes and handles aren't quite shaped right for me. LV and LN both do better, but LV may accomodate big hands the best. I hope the iron LV has a smooth handle more like the bronze LV rather than the Stanley shown in the picture.

Don


img

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#11

I don't doubt it...

John in New Mexico

>but I was talking about the 60 1/2 block plane and LN's version. Much as I like LN stuff, the two I've tried out have insufficient length between the ball of the cap casting and the finger hollows on the sides for comfortable one handed use (for me that is).

Re: What's different with this edge plane?

#12

Oh, but Derek

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>lacking an "edit" button gives the opportunity to practice the art of graceful apologies.

On one or two occasions, I've committed great blunders, usually saying something unintentionally insulting or inflammatory, and have found the moderators willing to edit. For mistakes, I think a follow up mea culpa is more appropriate.