Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

planing end grain on hard maple....

Posts

planing end grain on hard maple....

#1

planing end grain on hard maple....

George in Lowell, Mich.

>I'm trying to plane some end grain and no matter which plane I grab none seem to "cut the mustard".

The planes I've tryed were all very sharp and set very thin, but they seem to just skip over the wood. they were :

Stanley #4 with A2 blade

low angle BU smoother

various block planes (normal & low angle)

2 different shoulder planes (1" wide blades & low angle)

#6 Stanley with 1/4" thick blade (my hybrid)

The only thing that I didn't try (I thought of this as I was typing) was a scrapper plane.

What do you people think?? 6" x 6" surface I need to remove about 1/32" deep My last resort is a pneaumatic disk sander. This is hardly "galootish" but it will definitely remove the offending wood.

HELP!!!!

Work safe

George in cold (10* F w/ a 20mph wind on top of that) & snowy Lowell, Mich.

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#2

It might be the wood

Steve Elliott

>The last piece of hard maple I bought turned out to be so hard that even planing the sides of the board were almost beyond the ability of my best planes. On my first try I thought I must have put the blade in the plane upside down. Eventually I was able to take very thin shavings with a very sharp blade, but gave up on planing that particular piece of maple.

Planing end grain is of course much more difficult, so it may not be your tools or your technique that are the problem. And 1/32" of end grain over a 6 x 6" surface is a lot of planing in any case.

If I couldn't use a (power) saw to trim the end of the board I'd probably be thinking of how I could jig up a router to take off that 1/32.

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#3

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

JEFF J ,ABBEVILLE.SC

>I would be supprised if a scraping plane would do any good.If a low angle block plane wont do the trick,i think sandpaper would be my next option too.

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#4

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

Clint Jones

>Do you have a plane with a skewed blade? I would try that first. If you dont have a skewed plane. Try a LA plane and tilt it as if it were skewed. It may just be the wood though not the plane or method of use.

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#5

Couple ideas

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Mind you, I haven't tried any of this personally, but I will have a 24" x 24" endgrain maple butcher block to work on later this year, so I have a particular interest in this. If I'm out to lunch our experts here will chime in I'm sure.

From my limited experience, taking thin shavings on end-grain is very difficult because the grain at the edge of the board bends a bit when hit by the plane blade, therefore making the plane skip. I would surmise that the softer the wood the more this is prone to happen, so planing maple should help here. 1/32" is 0.03125", quite a bit to remove 0.001" at a time, notwithstanding the above issue for the moment. I would thus suggest taking a 0.01" cut, quite rank for face grain but it will allow the blade to bite on the edge of the work piece.

Now taking a 0.01" cut is difficult, even on face grain. One way to lessen the effort would be to skew the plane (or use a skew plane), but I'm not sure this will be enough. A second option, one which IMO would work better is to put a sizeable camber on the blade. The combination of a low angle blade and good camber will allow you to push the plane through while taking a rank cut. I'm not talking scrub blade camber here, something less severe that will take something like 1/2" - 3/4" wide shavings at a depth of 0.01.

Once this is done you will end up with a somewhat scallopped surface, whick will be easier to finish-plane with a sharp, finely set low angle plane (skewed if needed).

A toothed blade might also work instead of a camber, as the width of cut is half the blade width in theory.

The numbers above are educated guesses, experience will dictate the actual numbers.

Let us know if this works out, or whatever other solution that works for you.

Good luck,

DC

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#6

Re: Couple ideas

David Charlesworth

>I would be very surprised if you could take a shaving of more that 0.002" off end grain, OK maybe 0.003" max.

Some Maple I have had seems to have "stony" type mineral deposits in small areas.

Are your edges breaking down after one or two shavings?

David

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#7

a diffficult task

bill tindal, E.TN

>Others with more experience may disagree, but I have never been successful taking a full width shaving on end grain of a very hard wood, and maple fits that category. (I am presuming that you are trying to take a full width shaving on this 6 x 6". Things begin to get difficult at around 1". I expect things would work well if you used a very sharp plane with a pronounced curvature on the iron.

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#8

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

Tom Stockton

>A trick I taught was to lightly moisten the end grain, it can help a lot.

Tom

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#9

Common situation for an Aussie

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I'm trying to plane some end grain and no matter which plane I grab none seem to "cut the mustard".

The planes I've tryed were all very sharp and set very thin, but they seem to just skip over the wood. they were :

Stanley #4 with A2 blade

low angle BU smoother

various block planes (normal & low angle)

2 different shoulder planes (1" wide blades & low angle)

#6 Stanley with 1/4" thick blade (my hybrid)

The only thing that I didn't try (I thought of this as I was typing) was a scrapper plane.

What do you people think?? 6" x 6" surface I need to remove about 1/32" deep My last resort is a pneaumatic disk sander. This is hardly "galootish" but it will definitely remove the offending wood.

Hi George

On the assumption that your blades are good-and-sharp (on second thought, don't assume - can your blade shave softwood endgrain without any signs of break out?) and the wood is good-and-hard, then the problem is (a) that the plane/sole/blade edge are not being presented to the wood surface in an even, consistent way, and (b) that you plane without sufficient directed "power" ("b" is also related to "a", but more shortly).

Firstly, you can use any cutting angle to plane end grain, but you will get a better finish and have an easier time (all other factors held constant) if you use a low cutting angle, for example the 25 degree bevel on a 12 degree bed such as in your BU smoother. As the wood becomes harder, my priorities shift to increased heft, so that the momentum of the plane stroke is as great as you can get. A low cutting angle and heft together is ideal, but if you can only have one, then go with heft. Your Stanley #6 may be your best bet at this point. BUT the iron must be razor sharp!

There is a second reason why the #6 is to be preferred, and this relates to registering the plane.

With a 6" x 6" surface, what follows is just an illustration. Here I am shooting end grain using a shooting board.

In the first example the plane is a high angle (60 degree) HNT Gordon Trying plane and the wood is a relatively soft mahogany. This presents very little challenge but demonstrates that end grain is easily cut with a high cutting angle:



and close up ..



Now here I am shooting rock hard Jarrah end grain. This stuff is truly like concrete!



And here is a close up. The shavings are very fine, about .001" at a guess.



Of course, you are not able to use a shooting board, but your plane's registration, stability and a smooth, even downforce are essential to work your piece of end grain. Work from the outside inwards.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#10

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

Frank D. in Montreal

>I forget who said it already, but I think skewing the plane will help a lot, if you didn't already try it (and as most have said a really sharp blade). This reduces sipping because the blade has a chance to bite as it enters the cut gradually. I'd use the #4 with the A2 blade for this. LA planes have a tendency to skip after a few strokes on end-grain maple, at least mine do. I use hard maple more than any other wood (I'm no pro, but I always have a project on the go that involves hard maple) and IME you should be able to plane the end grain, especially freehand if you can skew the plane. In a shooting board is another story (problems with skipping or jamming) because you can't ease into the cut.

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#11

how about a yari kanna?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I have one that I use more as a carving tool when on end grain. It leaves a beautiful surface and I suppose that with a bit of practice it could even leave a smooth surface.

Robin Corell

Re: planing end grain on hard maple....

#12

Re: read all the ideas, here's my plan

George in Lowell, Mich.

>Wow!!! Alot of good suggestions!

Here's my plan of attack:

Resharpen all planes just to make sure.

Skew the planes.

Moisten the wood with mineral spirits or water, although water may really make the wood expand and not evaporate quickly.

Try a "micro radius" for a sort of scrub plane affect. Or even slight angles on each side of the cutting edge in the middle of the blade which I will reduce to about 1/2" wide. I will probably do this to my hybrid plane because of its heft. Also to one of my low angle planes.

Make a toothed blade. Then if it works, plane off the narrow rows of wood which "should" be easy.

I will let you know which gives good results especially with one of you going to make a butcher block soon.

Thanks

Work safe,

George in cold (0*) Lowell, Mich.