Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

why 45 degrees on miter plane?

Posts

why 45 degrees on miter plane?

#1

why 45 degrees on miter plane?

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I fooled around with my shooting board this weekend and came away thinking a dedicated plane might make sense. And just in time, Woodwork comes out with a shooting board article that explores planes a bit. It acknowledges the benefit of a lower angle iron for end grain work. Duh.

So imagine my surprise at seeing the LN #9 comes with an effective angle of 45 degrees! Why would they do that? I am inclined (ha ha) to stick with my #62.

Re: why 45 degrees on miter plane?

#2

Re: why 45 degrees on miter plane?

mikew

>Because for most hard woods, a low angle doesn't matter as much mass and sharp. And it will stay sharper longer due to a more obtuse bevel angle.

In order to get edge retention which mimics a BD plane on a shooting board with a BU plane, the effective cutting angle hits 40 degrees anyway.

This only is an issue with denser timber which is hard on a BU plane with a low effective cutting angle. With softer woods, the lower angle does cut more cleanly and with less effort.

There are other issues such as what type of steel the blade is made from--but for A2 and O1, I'll take shooting more and sharpening less.

At least, in my limited experience.

Take care, Mike

Re: why 45 degrees on miter plane?

#3

Clearance?

Frank D. in Montreal

>Well my experience is much more limited than yours Mike,

But I've always wondered if clearance wasn't an issue too. I'm no plane expert, but many specialized shooting planes seem to be either bevel up bedded at 20 degrees, or bevel down and skewed, bedded at 45. IME (again, very limited) the low angle of a LA plane gives me clearance issues on hard woods relatively quickly because the plane starts skipping/stops biting (that's when I reach for my bench planes to shoot, which I actually prefer to my LA planes).

Just some thoughts in case anyone has any ideas on this.

Re: why 45 degrees on miter plane?

#4

Re: experience

dave brown

>Mike,

I agree with everything you said --- except the part about limited experience! =P