We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>With the recent changes e-bay has made in requards to not knowing whom youre bidding against, or to able to see what competing bidders buying history is I'm ready to move on. It's only been a few weeks since the changes, and I really hate it enough to just want to leave e-bay altogether. Seems all they want is money, money, money. Well you know what, @#uck 'em.
So what else is out there that has a good reputation?
>I don't know but if you find a place I will start listing there. The rates keep going up and up to the poing they will soon be making more than me on the stuff I sell. I got a box of a dozen or so planes that even you could not zap into respectability.
>Yeah, I'm just fed up with this new idea e-bay as come up with. Call it silly on my part, but as the customer I like to see some info with the folks I am bidding against. Why? I dunno, Human curiousity I guess. Let's say I',m interested in a stone, I'll look at the other bidders History and fiqure my "strategy". Now, is it a real stragety, that could open to debate, but to me it is and is a part of the "game". If the current High Bidder has a history of buying stones, AND not afraid to shell out some long green for them, than I need to decide how hard I'm going to fight for this stone.
There is nothing on e-bay that I buy that I Need, it is all Want stuff, and by God, if I can't find some enjoyment in it other than simply placing a bid and leqaving it at that, than not only do I not need it, but I don't need it.
Bottom line is that it just seems to me that some of the fun and enjoyment of buying on e-bay has been taken away, and hey, if it's no longer as much fun as it used to be than I'll just take my nickles somewhere else.
Am I the only one that feels this way?
Ahhhhhhhhhhh well Ernie, you've gotta handle a lot of rust to find the jewel, which will make finding the jewel so much sweeter.
>There have been a few start up auction sites over the years, but they never get off the ground. Ebay has such a large base now that I doubt if any new startup can compete with them. I received an email from one a few months ago wanting me to list with them. A couple months later their site was gone. They sent the email through Ebay in response to one of my ads. I suspect someone complained to Ebay about that practice and Ebay squashed them. Ebay has adopted the Microsoft model quite successfully. You'll probably either play by Ebay's rules for the forseeable future, or not participate at all.
>Teah, from what I'm seeing and hearing about e-bay they are getting the Stanley Syndrome, in which, if we can't compete with them that we'll either buy 'em out or squash them altogether. I really hate that mentality, and me being the cusomer, albeit a very small one, I'm not going to be forced into "play by my rules or else".
I'm any easy going, flexable, try to compromise type of guy, but this new thing really rubs me the wrong way, and if I have to take my green and leave the playground I can and will do just that.
>The only other auction site I've used is Yahoo Auctions. I've bought stuff, but never sold on there.It's got a lot of junk, but occasionally something good shows up.
>If you know what you're asking for something, and if you've got a Craiglist in your area, it's good for some items. Not so much, perhaps, for the kind of stuff in which this crowd is interested, since the market for obscure planes and even more obscure sharpening stones is kinda limited, but for some stuff, it seems good, and it's free.
>I just starting seeing what Ebay selling is like. So far I find it enormously time-consuming and generally disappointing...though not as disappointing as put a good handplane on the WC classifieds. I suspect street-sweeping or boxing groceries are vastly more profitable.
A few years back I wanted to learn the real-world market price on an old Remington 10 gauge from my grandfather. Ebay, of course, was no help. But I did find a firearms specific auction. Perhaps more than one.
At some point, a guy like Ellis, or some other entrepreneur, is going to buy an auction software suite and create an old-tools specific auction site. What would get in the way is that volume and price of what we're interested in conspire to make it unprofitable. Maybe one of the big tool clubs could get not-for-profit status and provide such a service for the civic good.
My impression is that Ebay is much more like the IRS than like WalMart. Jeez, hope that comment doesn't get me banned from Ebay or trigger an audit.
>Ebay made these changes so you can't see the other bidders names because of the very real problim of spoof back up bidder offers where people pretending to be the seller contacts the back up bidders to offer to sell them the item which of course they don't even have. I have had this happen to more then a couple of my auctions....I imagine if you got burned on one of these bogus back up bid offeres you would not be so keen on everybody to know what you are bidding on eh?..
....I'm surprised they didn't do this years ago, though it might be debatable , but I think it could end up making less money for the sellers [and Ebay]since it could lead to things going for less since I think just like at a real auction some people don't like to get outbid and build up personal grudges against certain bidders who out bid them and as such leads to higher bids. I certainly don't see how this new change will lead to more money for ebay or thier sellers unless maybe it will make more people trust back up bid offers.
Ebay is less face it is really the only game in town and can't imagine anybody ever taking them on....I sure can't see me ever listing anything I can sell on the Ebay on another site. With 100s of millions menbers on ebay looking to buy why would I ? I think Ebay is for the most part very well run, easy to use and charges such cheap fees I don't understand how people complain about it. I know I don't begrudge them what they charge esp. since it is so small and you do so well...and my ebay bill as seller is about $300 a month too....
Don't believe me? Take your stuff to a local auction where it will be exposed to maybe a few hundered people, they will charge you 20% or more commision to sell it and then more then likely charge the person buying it a 10% buyers penalty..and I bet it will sell for much less then what it would on the ebay..still think Ebay is such a bad place?
...Nothing perfect including the Ebay....I would like to see thier auctions keep running till no one bids like real life auctions and some other on line auctions....but I do think they had an idea that has changed the world and do about as good with it as you could hope....Todd
>Bob wrote..."I just starting seeing what Ebay selling is like. So far I find it enormously time-consuming and generally disappointing.... I suspect street-sweeping or boxing groceries are vastly more profitable"
I can tell you straight it is very possiable to not only make a very good living selling on the ebay but with out to much of what I would consider work too. Of course like anything else you do you have to know what you are doing and what you are buying and selling.
... Lots of sellers on the ebay don't do well because they don't know this. They either pay to much for what they buy, don't know what to buy or don't know how to describe it and sell it so it is no surprise they don't do well. If you do know all this then it is very easy to do well there. Is certainly not hard to find stuff to sell on it for a good profit that is for sure .....Todd
>I think, as in almost everything, there is a big difference in the attitudes held by those who participate as professionals and amateurs. Professionals rationalize fee increases as still being cheaper than somewhere else, still low enough to help them make money. Amateurs see fee increases as money grubbing. Both are right and wrong.
But ebay is a business, which pretty much took online auctions and financial transactions completely under control, at least in the US, when they bought Paypal. So most likely everyone will be more comfortable taking a professional's attitude. It's no longer a game or experiment.
>I know some people gripe about the fees ebay might charge them...but I think if they look at it honestly they would have to see it really is very low.
An example....Recently I sold on ebay a set of chisels for $886.00. Now this cost me $2.40 to list, 35 cents for a gallery fee, 50 cents for a subtitle and then after they sold a 27.00 vaule fee [commission]....all told came to $30.39 I believe. Now does anyone really believe that I was gouged by the ebay over this? I know I sure don't!
Now if I took them to about any live auction [like the one I bought them at for $100 !] they would charge me probably 20 % and if they did sell as high as on the ebay [and folks that is about an impossiable "if" I think] the auction house would then charge me a $177 fee. Also many auctions charge buyers a percentage too and while they don't like to admit it that fee really comes out of the sellers pocket since bidders take that into account and won't bid as high.
Tell you the truth I think Ebay's fees would still be cheap at double thier prices .....Todd
>Yeah Todd, I hear ya' but you know, if one wants to bad enough they'll still find some way to pull a scam, and perhaps even use this "blind bidders" idea to their advantage some how. I'm sure that the change was made with good intentions, but it has deminished some of the fun of e-bay for me at least, and from the sounds of it several others as well. This decrease will ulimately affect my buying interests.
The creators of e-bay have done very well for themselves that's for sure, and pratically overnight to the point of becoming part of the Language. I do hate tho, that when a company like this gets so big that it starts crushing others. Seems to me that e-bay makes enough money that they could leave a few crumbs for others. Name recognition is their biggest Asset, just as it was for Stanley, and also Wal-Mart now.
Hopefully they'll change their minds about this idea, and just let the people be wary of the slicksters. I can speak for myself that if I didn't win an Auction outright, and then recieved an e-mail from somebody saying that they where the seller and would agree to sell it to me for what I had bid, my response would be, "Thanks, but no Thanks, relist it and I'll try my luck again". Ahhhhhhhhhhh well, that's me I guess.
>I don't disagree that 3.5% is reasonable. Personally, I hate the free for all on ebay, in which any vindictive buyer/seller can wreck havoc on another's ratings with no effective overview by ebay. They really should have some better way of handling retaliatory feedback, perhaps bad feedback should have to be approved prior to posting.
>on this change. But I hear where you're coming from Todd, because I had a similar reaction when I first saw the new format. It's definitely a move away from the original touchy-feely "ebay community" idea. And it's also a move away from transparency. More like you're getting processed in a game controlled by somebody behind the curtain.
My specific concern with the new format was whether it would make gaming the auction (especially shilling) easier or harder to detect. Because all I want to know is whether the auction is honest or not. My strategy is to think about only one thing 'what is the maximum I am willing to pay for this item?' I figure out that number and snipe with it. I am willing to win or lose with that one bid, and will have no regrets either way, and if I win, no regrets about what I paid--so long as I feel the auction is honest!
Well, I have now seen the outcome of an auction I was tracking, and believe that this ebay change is OK, because it gives you enough information to judge whether someone was gaming the auction or not. But you do have to wait til after the auction to get the info.
I have included a link to the auction I was watching. It was for a Mathieson plough plane. The first page of the completed auction lists the moniker of the winner. If you then go to the 'bid history', and click on any one of the other bidders, you won't find their moniker, but you will find a host of data about their bidding patterns--how many feedbacks they have; how many different categories they bid in; how many bids they've placed recently; the elapsed time between their last bid and the end of auction (i.e., do they snipe?); do they tend to bid this particular seller's items a lot, or no; and more.
All told, Ebay provides enough info for me to judge whether, say, Bidder X really was an authentic bidder, or whether Bidder X might have been gaming the auction.
So I am impressed with the amount of summary information about each bidder that ebay provides, even though they don't reveal the monikers, except for the winning bidder.
>Nope, still no good. I seen that info before, but damn it, I don't want to see it AFTER the auction, I want to it DURING the auction. what a freakin' aggravation this is to me, I find something that I really enjoy and they've gt to go twiddle with it. FRB's!
Bottom Line, unless I can see whom I'm bidding against than I ain't bidding on NOTHING! period. I've drawn a line and that's that. Rarely do I draw a line, but I have on this issue and e-bay can now KMA!
>I must say I'd prefer knowing who the bidders are during the auction, too. For example, if I'm watching an item I want to know if CarlToday or JohnCussick is bidding on the item since I know they'll pay much higher prices than I. Why should I bother bidding? I suppose ebay and sellers don't like this.
I also know that I'd not necessarily have this information in a live auction, but I don't care. I don't attend live auctions.
To divorce the bidders on a given item from their base identity is alienating. Do the sellers have access to the active bidders' id's?
>yes I do have access to that info. I have several things up right now and untill Todd O said somthing about it I never knew of the change. because the look of my auctions never changed. There are alot of things bothering me about selling on eBay and this just adds to the list. It looks like they are going to force me to go back to woodworking instaed os auction hunting.
>I caught a segment of 'Antiques Road Show FYI' last evening where they visited with an auctioneer and he was talking about: 1) Listing fees, 2) photo fees and 3) sales commissions - a) seller and b) buyer. All very high. The seller still paid a significant chunk of change if the reserve price wasn't met.
As a seller, do you get notified when someone adds one of your items to their watch list? I've heard sellers can see some information about buyers watch list, but I'd like confirmation before I go off on a rant about it.