Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

Posts

Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#1

Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

Dave Mount

>With my increasing interest in making tools, I'd like to have a good way to do some simple slotting in relatively thin (1/16" to 3/16" annealed O1). I'm know very little about metalworking, but I understand that if one is willing to torture electrons, an end mill is a tool to use for this purpose. I have a drill press which, though maybe not designed for lateral forces can be used for my limited needs. I have an XY vise for it.

However, when I went to MSC to see about buying an end mill, I was flabbergasted by the variety. Could any of the metal workers out there steer me to the specific bit I need?

Thanks.

Dave

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#2

No help here but...

Dean Lapinel

>Just wanted to let you know I'm two steps behind you. I'm starting to make my rabbets now and preparing for a panel raising plane BUT...I'm already looking at metal working for them fancy infills!

I'll just follow your lead-

Dean

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#3

Where do I start?

jim reed @ tallahassee

>No no no. No milling in a drill press. You will annoy the DP and possibly hurt yourself and your project will not end successfully. If you need a *simple* slot, by the way--there are no simple slots, you need a mill in which to insert the end mill.

Here is another alternative using your drill press: drill the end points of the slot using appropriately sized drill bits in your drill press. Fasten the metal in a vise and use several drill sizes to sneak up on the final hole. Use an abrasive cut off wheel to cut the long sides and connect the two holes. If your project is small a Dremel may work. Lastly, use a file to clean everything up.

Sounds pretty ambitious. Good luck.

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#4

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end m

woodburnbob

>I'm a little bit of an amateur home-shop kind of guy sometimes and know just about enough to keep myself from letting a machine jam a piece of steel through my skull and into my frontal lobes.

One issue depends on the drill press you have and the tool holder you plan to use. You put an end mill in an end mill holder that has a taper that will match the taper of your drill press spindle. I'm sure you're not thinking of putting it into a common drilling chuck. Right? Most modern home shop drill presses have a morse #2 or #3 taper. A big difference is that a drill press usually doesn't have a hollow spindle and a milling machine spindle is hollow. In a mill, a long bolt (called a drawbar) is passed through the spindle and threaded into the end mill holder, which effectively bolts the end mill holder male taper to the mill's female spindle taper. For instance, one would secure a Morse #3 end mill holder for a 1/4" end mill into a Morse #3 milling spindle.

If you haven't done anything like this, try an experiment with your drill press. Chuck a 1/2" round into it that's about 4 inches long. Turn it on. Use a wrench or something to press radially and tap against the spinning round bar. Your chuck and round will fall out of the spindle. The reason it doesn't fall out when drilling is that axial forces hold the male holder in the female spindle. The chuck doesn't fall out when you're using stay-brite or wire-wheels because the radial forces and vibrations are tiny compared with what you'll generate with endmills in steel.

If you simply put an end mill into a drill press chuck and try to mill as your first experiment, under a little side stress the chuck or chuck adaptor will loose it's grip. Since your work piece won't allow it to drop, it will wobble and twist and probably seize. This will first break off the end mill teeth you paid so much money for. Then it will jerk the work peice loose, break your spindle, or something else. Shards of endmill will fly around the room. No telling what else will break or fly around. This is a very bad idea and potentially expensive and dangerous.

If you have some other idea about how to securely and rigidly fix the end mill to the drill press spindle, please do share it. The only problem then would be how rigid your whole arrangement is. That and how much runout your spindle has, the speed and feed you intend to use, etc. I'm not so sure the bearings issue is the biggest deal. I'm not so sure you'll ever get to the point that the bearings will be put to a test.

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#5

Re: OK, plan B

Dave Mount

>Well, I guess I'm glad I asked!

Thanks for explaining why this is not the route to go. Funny, I was just sure I'd seen posts here or on BP about using end mills in drill presses. Perhaps I'm remembering someone using it to mill wood rather than metal. That sounds kind of familiar.

At any rate, I got my answer -- the end mill I need is "none." But Jim's Dremel-based suggestion sounds do-able.

Looks like I need to make friends with someone with the appropriate metalworking knowledge and equipment. . .

Thanks.

Dave

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#6

Unimat sl

Dean Lapinel

>I have a unimat sl and while I've never tried it I believe it works as a milling unit when mounted vertically. I may be wrong with this but if I'm correct , they aren't that expensive on e-bay.

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#7

The reason I don't make

jim reed @ tallahassee

>many bench plane blades is that the slot is difficult to make. It takes a 1/2" solid carbide end mill. They are not cheap. One end mill will last for about ten blades. At $50 a pop, the tooling comes out to $5 per blade. Smaller endmills are cheaper, but require more passes. Cutting out waste saves the end mills, but that takes lots of time. There are a half dozen good methods, but each is a trade off of time and money. There are those who complain about the high cost of Hock blades who probably would not if they understood the mfg process.

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Standard bench plane slot

Jim in Burlington On

>It takes me about a hour to make a blade with a slot. I drill a hole at both ends on the slowest speed my DP will go then use a hack saw with a Cobalt blade in it. Little filing to fit it perefectly to that plane. Just make sure to cover your work bench so you don't get metal filing imbeded into it. I tried making the slot with a bi-metal blade in my jig saw but there never seemed to be a good way to clamp it down.

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#9

Re: Sure you can - bunch of nellies.

thomd

>You certainly can mill in a drill press but it's not the best idea. It somewhat depends whether you want to mill slots in a guitar bridge made of ebony and about 3/32" wide, or whether you want to make a 1/2" slot in tool steel. That's a pretty heavy cut for a mill let alone a non-mill. You may not have considered this, but you would need a cross slide table for your drill press. This allows you to use the t-slots in the table to position your blade, and the x/y controls to apply the lateral force required to mill your slots. Once you attach this to your drill press table, you will find that it may not be strong enough to resist the 3 axis pressures involved, so you will have to start fabricating something to hold it in place... By now you are probably wondering "why don't I just make one of these":

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/multimachine/

I think the simplest way to bust out a slot is to drill your two holes for the end, and then use an electric hack saw, be that a variable speed jigsaw, a recip saw (probably too big), or an abrassive wheel, to bust out the tab. Once it's out, use a nice big mill file to square everything up. This is pretty fast, and will give equal results to a mill without all that nasty lubricant smelling up the shop.

Before you do this consider:

1) why do I need this slot? A lot of planes are better without a breaker.

2) Do I need that breaker hole? When I made my O1 blade for my LV plane I dumped the whole breaker and just indexed the hole off the main blade.

3) Do you need all of that slot? At the rate at which any metal guy is aquiring blades for new ideas and projects, are you really going to sharpen away miles of the blade do you need a slot much longer than overlaping drill holes?

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#10

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end m

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>...and know just about enough to keep myself from letting a machine jam a piece of steel through my skull and into my frontal lobes.

Woodworkers are not known for their forward planning and impulse control anyway ... < grin >

... Use a wrench or something to press radially and tap against the spinning round bar. Your chuck and round will fall out of the spindle. The reason it doesn't fall out when drilling is that axial forces hold the male holder in the female spindle.

Bob, your observations are spot on. I recognise the need to get an end mill/metal lathe now that I am working increasingly with metal as well as wood. With a drill press, even one that has about 1 HP as mine does, there is no substitute for the correct tools. So far I use a series of drilled holes, along with a Dremel, and a 4" hand-held angle grinder (sometimes in a stand - does that still permit it to be called "hand-held"?) with a thin cut off disk when I have to machine slots, etc.

Dave, one might also take some small comfort in the knowledge that, as far as I am aware, guys like Wayne Anderson do not use end mills - they do it all with hand files.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#11

metal talk

woodburnbob

>Phineas Gage with his bilateral, home-shop-style cingulotomy has always been a sort of hero to me. Would that more people might try it out.

I think the British have great home-shop metal machines. Here's a shot of my Tom Senior mill, that made it from England to Oregon. I got it off Ebay for $800 some years back. I'm thinking there are probably more British mills and lathes in Australia/NZ than the US. Check out the for sale pages of www.lathes.co.uk


I've got a chance to pick up a surface grinder this weekend, but I have no room. If I could part with this mill in the garage, I'd have room.




Alas, I got it with a large cache of tooling for $250 and after spending weeks derusting and repairing, it's hard to think of letting it go even though I seldom use it.

Re: Hey metalworkers - plz help me choose an end mill

#12

Impressive

Jim Reed @ tallahassee

>That's some pretty impressive iron you have. Did I notice a little house tilt in the pictures? 8-) Too bad about the surface grinder as they can be pretty handy.