Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

If you have a 45, why a 50?

Posts

If you have a 45, why a 50?

#1

If you have a 45, why a 50?

Bill Houghton, colder than Anchorage, CA No. Coast

>Is there some advantage to a 50 over a 45?

Re: If you have a 45, why a 50?

#2

Re: IME

paul womack

>The #50 (in my case #050) is lighter to handle and simpler to setup/adjust.

BugBear

Re: If you have a 45, why a 50?

#3

Of course

Jim Reed @ tallahassee

>The #50 is smaller and lighter. If you have both planes it means that you can use them where their best features shine. Most importantly, you can leave the cutter alone. I am really picky about cutter setup and do not like to change it. That is why I gather up lots of bodies and load them with cutters at the start of a project. Never changing cutters saves time and frustration.

Re: If you have a 45, why a 50?

#4

Cart Before Horse

David Miller from Iowa

>The reasons a rust hunter would need a 50 is because you don't already have 5 or more - you can figure out what to do with it later:)

Re: If you have a 45, why a 50?

#5

Re: Of course

Christopher Fitch@Memphis

>Wow I never thought about that...

Almost sounds like you have a set of metal plough planes...all based on the 050.

:)

Re: If you have a 45, why a 50?

#6

Re: Of course

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>" That is why I gather up lots of bodies and load them with cutters "...guess that deserves a YOU SUCK!

Course with your skills making cutters that isn't an issue either:-)

JR

Re: If you have a 45, why a 50?

#7

Dealing with the orphans

Jim Reed @ tallahassee

>A complete combination plane is just a starting point. Those extra bodies that come up for sale cheap are very useful. Think about it--fence not needed for dados, extra skate not needed unless cutter is larger than 3/8". All a combo plane needs to be a dynamite dado plane is a body, a cutter, and a working depth stop. It is also nice to have a body dedicated to 1/8" cutter. When you add it all up, you can make your combo plane very handy if you surround it with some of those orphan bodies. I say let them hunt in a pack.

Re: If you have a 45, why a 50?

#8

Exactly !

jim reed @ tallahassee

>Collect 'em all now and sort 'em out later.

Re: If you have a 45, why a 50?

#9

Price and availability.

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>Around this part of the world 45s are not as common as 50s. A usable 50 is fairly easy to find and a 45 isn't.

Most of the local rust sellers know nothing about planes but have cottoned on to the fact that 45s are collectable, so they are priced way up in the stratosphere. Now a 50 is just an old clunker to the same rust sellers, so they don't bother with them much and haven't run up the prices to the same extent.

regards

Angus Barclay

(owner of a cheap modern 13-050 that works just fine)