Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

Posts

KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#1

KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

bill tindall

>From time to time on this Forum it has been stated that the KD standards in some countires outside the US are different, specifically that lumber is dried above the moisture content in use, while in the US lumber is dried below this level. While I have no insight in KD practices outside the US, I have contacts in the US that export world wide. I contacted a friend at Hunterville Hardwood, a large exporter of hardwood lumber( and most relaible supplier we ever dealt with). (The US is the largest exporter of hardwood lumber) He said that all their lumber is dried to the same standard, 7% MC. In fact it is overdried and then steamed to bring it to 7% and relax stress. It is a good bet that all US exporters dry to this same standard. I would find it strange if this was not the standard where ever commercial lumber is dried for furniture use.

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#2

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

Sgian Dubh

>Bill, in front of me is the book, Timber drying manual by GH Pratt because I am writing on the subject of timber technology. It's sort of the British Bible of timber seasoning.

Most timber in the UK is air dried to about 20- 25%MC depending on the season followed by kiln drying to somewhere around 10%MC. Most houses in the UK hover between about 40% RH in the winter to 60% RH in the summer. 10% MC therefore represents about the middle of the range that timber would normally experiences inside British homes. I can see why kiln operators in the UK don't normally kiln wood drier than this figure. I am aware that the Americans typically kiln wood drier than here-- to about 6.5- 7% MC. Slainte.

Recommended Wood Moisture Content (MC) and Usage.

Timber Fibre Saturation Point (FSP)---25-30% MC

Dry rot safe, ie, fungi will not grow---b.20% MC and below

Air dried timber (in Great Britain.)---17- 25% MC (seasonal.)

Wood for making outdoor furniture and external joinery---14-19% MC

Wood for construction joinery, e.g., joists, studwork, doors, framing, church work, etc..---12- 16% MC

Kiln Dried Timber (typical MC that furniture grade wood is kiln dried to in Great Britain.)---8%- 11% MC

MC figures below are only a guide to the typical MC range wooden furniture and structures will hover between in British buildings. Note that local weather conditions, building structure, heating preferences, insulation et cetera will cause differences to the percentage figures given.

Buildings with poor insulation, single glazing, minimal or no heating, etc.. E.g., Barns, sheds, rarely heated workshops, churches, etc..---15-19% wood MC

Buildings with intermittent heating giving room temperatures between 12- 21�C ---10-14% wood MC

Habitable buildings�offices, houses, etc., with double glazing, good insulation, heated to ~21�C.---9-11% wood MC

Buildings and rooms kept very warm (21�C+) e.g., hospitals, storage facilities, museums, or wood used near radiators, fires, south facing sun rooms, etc..---6- 8%wood MC

Note. Figures given above are based on recommended wood moisture content for various locations and situations as described in British Standard, BS EN 942 1996 Class J30.

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#3

the strange findings

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Bill,

Here's the proof you were looking for me to provide to you.

http://www.softwood.org/Hem%20Fir%20Web/eHemFir/EN/HemFir_2.htm - last line

http://www.timber.org.au/NTEP/menu.asp?id=82

http://www.pinesolutions.com.au/news/developments_pine/moisture_content.pdf

The stranger thing is that the way I put furniture together was taught to me by a German tradesman. Is this a consequence of air drying timber, which results in timber MC being above equilibrium for the first few years?

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#4

Clickable URL's

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Bill,

Here's the proof you were looking for me to provide to you.

http://www.softwood.org/Hem%20Fir%20Web/eHemFir/EN/HemFir_2.htm - last line

http://www.timber.org.au/NTEP/menu.asp?id=82

a general summary of where things are at as far as drying

The stranger thing is that the way I put furniture together was taught to me by a German tradesman. Is this a consequence of air drying timber, which results in timber MC being above equilibrium for the first few years?

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#5

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

Sgian Dubh

>Bill, as both Andrew and I have shown in our responses, kiln operators in both the UK and Australia don't follow the American convention of drying wood to 7%MC.

As a follow up, are there reasons why the US practice is to dry timber to 7%MC when we in the UK, for example, only dry to about 10%MC? For example, taking out that extra 3%MC requires more time in the kiln, additional energy consumption, and slower throughput. It could be argued that profitability might be compromised due to such practices. Slainte.

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#6

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

Wiley Horne

>Hi Richard,

Your reference is excellent and highly specific. Thank you.

Down toward the bottom of the reference, the recommendation for rooms and buildings which are typically heated to above 21C is 6-8%MC. Now 21C works out to 69.8F. This is guesswork of course, but I would guess that many if not most US homes and buildings are heated to something north of 70F (21C).

Don't know if that factor accounts for the different KD practice, or if something else is at work. But it's plausible.

Wiley

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#7

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Bill, Richard and Wiley,

Following on from Richard's comments, it also could be postulated that the timber is dried to a level where it will remain stable in the workshop - at 70-75% humidity and comfortable temperatures, timber contains approximately 13.5% moisture. It has to be stable in here to allow the thing to be made accurately. We just design to have it move as it gets drier (eg: airconditioned environment at 40% RH.)

US Forest Products laboratory - data source

Just another possible data point.

Cheers,

Andrew

Working in about 80-90% humidity outside at the moment and losing the fat from the christmas pudding quickly (he says with hope.)

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#8

speculating why.....

bill tindall, E. TN.

>I read what your book said, but have you checked with a lumber production operation supplying to furniture factories to see what in fact is practiced? I can't imagine that they are receiving 7% lumber from the US and something different elsewhere given the concern US factories have over uniform moisture content (MC) of their materials.

The simple answer to your question is that the US practices result in the most stable and stress free product as determined by the customer, which are the furniture factories. They determine the grading and manufacturing standards in the US. I know for a fact that factories are very picky about the MC of lumber and rough lumber parts going to them, and factories are typically humidity controlled. We are insignificant customers for the hardwood lumber industry although there are small operations that cater to our desires. And of course small operations not dependent on factory orders could do as they please. In my experience they often under dry lumber and it is not as stable as the lumber from larger operations. I have never seen warping or cupping in stacks unless the lumber coming to us was underdried, in which case I have seen these problems.

I have searched for a publication that was part of a class on kiln operation but can't find it. I think (and given my memory don't discount the I think part) that it was stated that there is hysteresis in wood drying. That is to say if wood is over dried it regains to a lower MC than if it was dried to the MC at a given humidity. I can further imagine that with the additional cell collapse that would occur with over drying that the lumber would not expand back as much with moisture regain and thereby be more stable. This is all speculation on my part but it is consistent with our kiln operation practices of over drying and steaming back to 7% . I suppose someone has found that 7% is about the median for where furniture lives.

The bottom line is that every large operation we have dealt with dries the same way and if they are drying with steam heat (steam generated from lumber waste) they over dry and steam back to reduce stress. Small dehumidification kilns may not have the steam option. If you are using lumber from US production it likely was dried well under 10%.

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#9

Re: speculating why.....

Andrew F in Australia

>HI Bill,

I don't know what they dry it to, but the US cherry I use occasionally is at 14% by the time it's finished its voyage halfway around the world.

Drying to 7% then reconditioning seems like a waste of time and money, unless it's specific to the US - eg; all timber is dried as though it's going to Arizona.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#10

Should have added...

Andrew F in Australia

>Sorry Bill,

In a rush to post and get back outside before.

I did read and understand your bit on overdrying then reconditioning. In my experience, everything is done for a valid reason. Just sometimes there's and equally valid reason not to.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#11

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

Sgian Dubh

>Something else is at work, Wiley.

Your musings on temperature and wood MC are certainly relevant. But there's an element that you haven't really tied into your thinking. If you go back to the numbers I provided in the chart (which are numbers based on the British Standards (BS) not exact quotes), you'll see there are certain conditions attached to those numbers. For example, there's mention of insulation, or lack of it, etc..

Temperature alone does not cause wood to shrink or expand. I'm hoping I've prompted you (and anyone else that's interested) to delve a little deeper into what's going on.

The reason why US kiln operators dry wood to 7%MC has quite a simple explanation in the end. It'll probably be one of those 'smack the forehead with the palm of the hand' things when you find out why. Bill is nudging around the reason, but I don't think he's quite got there yet.

If no-one gets the answer by tomorrow night-- Sunday night UK time-- I'll reveal all. I'm not trying to be difficult or a tease here. I'm hoping people might do a bit of digging to find out what's going on. Information found that way seems to stick pretty well. Slainte.

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#12

Re: speculating why.....

Sgian Dubh

>That is to say if wood is over dried it regains to a lower MC than if it was dried to the MC at a given humidity.

Bill, hysteresis is an interesting phenomena that affects the speed at which wood takes on and loses moisture. Hysteresis basically means to �lag.� In the case of wood, hysteresis means that the fibres don�t immediately react to the drying or wetting forces surrounding them. An interesting effect of hysteresis is that, after a time delay, wood cells gain moisture from damp air faster than they lose it in response to dry air. Hysteresis doesn't prevent wood from reaching any particular state of MC or moisture gradient throughout its thickness and width.

I can further imagine that with ---cell collapse that would occur with over drying that the lumber would not expand back as much with moisture regain and thereby be more stable.

There's truth in this, but I don't think it's the case that cell collapse itself necessarily leads to increased stability. Indeed, it might be argued that cell collapse leads to weakening of the wood, because after all, it's essentially the cellulosic material that forms the bulk of wood's strength.

I suppose someone has found that 7% is about the median for where furniture lives.

That's not actually the case. 7%MC of wood is below the normal range of MC that wood will experience inside most north American houses and offices, whether that be in Houston, Phoenix, Vancouver, Nome, Montreal, or Boston. See if you have the time to do a bit more digging and find the reason for that 7% figure. As I mentioned in my response to Wiley, you'll probably go, "Duh," or something like that when you find out, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#13

Large commercial kiln drying in the US

Sgian Dubh

>Wiley, I meant to get back to this last night, Sunday, but commitments elsewhere prevented my doing so. Anyway, I see no-one is biting regarding the wee puzzle I left you with, so here goes.

Why dry to 7% MC (in the US)?

General commercial practice in the US is to kiln dry wood for some products, such as flooring and furniture, to a slightly lower moisture content than the wood will see in service. This is in large part because major users of timber (e.g., furniture factories and flooring manufacturers) expect an increase in MC during storage, shipping, working the wood and making the piece.

7% wood MC equates to an atmospheric RH of approximately 35%. This is a rather low RH figure in my experience for most houses anywhere in the north American continent. I lived in Houston for 10 years and, although I didn't monitor the RH in my house closely and keep accurate daily records, I was aware that RH hovered between about 40% in what were laughably called the winter months, and about 60% in the season some called summer, but I knew as Hell on Earth, ha, ha.

If anyone that visits this forum lives in a house that typically maintains RH percentages between about 30% and 40%, then 7%MC of the wood is nigh on perfect for your conditions.

Now, having lived in Houston for 10 years I also regularly purchased kiln dried hardwoods such as cherry, maple and walnut. Not once did I buy a piece that measured less than 10% MC. My workshop had no air conditioning and Houston has an average outside RH of about 80%, which equals about 16% MC in wood. Conditions inside the workshop tended to be a little drier so wood mostly settled out at about 12-13%, equivalent to about 60- 70% RH.

If freshly kilned 1" thick wood is shipped close stacked in sealed containers, average moisture content gain is about to 0.2% or less per month.

The rise in moisture content for one inch thick timber (at 7% MC) close stacked in a roofed but open storage facility in humid conditions, e.g., 80-90% RH is usually roughly 1% per month . In about two months wood at 7%MC stored in such a way will usually have risen to about 9%.

An enclosed storage shed in similar RH conditions will usually hold moisture gain down to about 0.3% per month.

There's more on this moisture regain stuff, but to save boring everyone to tears with pernickety and anal minuteae, I think that will probably do for now.

Anyway, I hope that's enough to be going on with. Slainte.

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#14

Re: Large commercial kiln drying in the US

Wiley Horne

>Thanks, Richard! That's very enlightening, and I like details, as I think most here do. The idea of overdrying to compensate for regain during shipping, storage, milling, furniture build, makes sense.

I am also impressed by Bill's point about hysteresis, as well as by your point that enclosed buildings will hold moisture gain to 0.3% per month. The thing I am curious about is how this figure pertains to wood movement in the finished piece of furniture. Our climate here in Southern California is classed as 'Mediterranean', in other words, very mild. But we do have seasonal moisture swings, and yet I never experience the wood movement in finished furniture that is predicted by engineering data on tangential and radial movement. Drawers can be closely fit, yet do not bind in moist periods. I am guessing that the finish, though it is not a moisture barrier, does slow the rate of moisture gain, until the next dry period rolls around. Therefore, the wood is always moving, but never moves very much before the next season rolls around, and starts it moving the other way. So the net movement year-round is very slight. Is this your experience? Or no? Insights from professional experience are of great value.

Wiley

Re: KD lumber standards in Europe & elsewhere

#15

Re: Large commercial kiln drying in the US

Sgian Dubh

>I suspect what you're experiencing or obversing, Wiley is a combination of a fairly equable climate, conditions maintained in offices and residences in that area, and the water vapour blocking effect that polish has on wood. Add all this to hysterisis, and, as you surmise, I think what's happening is that swings in wood MC are reduced due to all these factors.

A useful generalisation is that it takes a change of between 3% and 4% in wood MC to cause an average 1% change in wood dimension. Therefore if you have a drawer front that is 100 mm tall (about 4") at 12% MC, then reducing that MC to between 8% and 9% will result in the drawer front shrinking in height to 99 mm (whatever those figures equate to in Imperial measurements.) That's not a very big amount really, and if the change in MC is delayed somewhat due to hysteresis and the effect of polish, then perhaps as you surmise, the season changes before the effect is fully felt.

I think it can be a bit of a mistake to slavishly follow the changes that could occur in the least favourable conditions. For example, I think most of the figures used in many charts and replicated in various ways in online calculators such as the Shrinkulator use numbers to be expected if bare wood is exposed to changes in RH.

On the other hand, I think it's imprudent when building furniture (for indoor use for example) to ignore the extremes that could occur. For instance, I always tend to build indoor furniture on the basis that wood just might experience an MC range from about 7% to 14%. Also, the rough rule of thumb figure I gave above (1% change in width per 3-4% MC change) is too much for American mahogany, and too little for European beech or European/American white oak.

All these factors need to be accounted for in the planning stages. Slainte.