Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

Posts

Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#1

Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi.

If you had money burning a hole in your pocket and you could get either the Lee Valley 4-1/2 smoothing plane or the Lie-Nielsen 4-1/2 smoothing plane, which would you get and why?

This hypothetical question assumes you already have, say a few typical Stanley planes, and you are looking for a special go-to plane for that very last bit of planing prior to finishing. It also assumes you work mostly with Cherry and some figured Maple. Oh, and it also assumes you are pretty much a hand tool noob and rely a great deal on the information and opinions you receive at WC.

So, again, which would you get and most importantly, why?

Thank you.

Joe

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#2

Coke or Pepsi?

woodburnbob

>I must be in a foul mood. I read this sincere and relevant on-topic post from you, Joe, and immediately thought, "not again". But I didn't post something like, "Joe, it's been done ad infinitum, just do a search." I realize you must be genuinely ambivalent and hope to settle it from current and fresh testimonials and redigested ad copy.

Really, I wanted to post a new thread, asking the related question: "Hypothetically what's better: another TV news story on the relentless travails of Britney Spears or instead 30 seconds of a silent black screen"? But that's too sarcastic. I'd just get a lot of flack and everyone would hate me for seeming to be the mean-spirited guy I really am. So I didn't do it.

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Joe,

That question has been asked many times here. Both are excellent planes of high quality and pretty much equal as far as performance.If you do a little searching you can find reviews on the subject. I believe it's just a matter of taste.Veritas planes are a unique,new design with alot of nice features.Lee Nielsens are on the other hand very nice looking tools.You really need to either try them out yourself or hunt for some reviews.Flip a coin!!You can't go wrong with either.---Jack

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#4

Between those two

Bill Houghton, 24 deg F today, Sebastopol, CA

>I'll take the burning Yule log.

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#5

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>What's a noob? Close to a newbie?

Anyhow, as Bob and Jack say, this is an old topic, and I don't see that the answers have changed in the last month or two. Get whichever one you want.

I do have to say that if you're looking for the best plane to polish (last bit of planing), you shouldn't necessarily limit your search to metal western planes. C&W deserve a look, as do the Japanese smoothers, made of wood, with great burnishing capabilities for the polishing phase.

Pam

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#6

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

paul womack

>Given the EXACT question you ask, I would choose the LN with a HAF, because it's prettier, and will give less tear out.

Given your budget, I'd buy the LV Bevel up smoother which isn't what you asked about :-)

BugBear

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#7

Re: LV BU Smoothing Plane

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>It's a great plane, and, with an extra, higher angle blade, offers additional options for the woodworker. I have a 'tweaked-as-far-as-I-can' old Stanley 4.5 on the shelf as well.

My question is - do you _need_ another plane, or are there still open spots in the cabinet to fill? Are we accelerating down the slope? Not that that's wrong. Just that perhaps we should do it fully aware of the old van, down by the river...

I'm just a hobby guy with a habit.

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#8

Ditto

Jerry Nicholson

>My choice is the LV Bevel Up smoother too. You get low angle, high angle, whatever. And I have 3 Stanley 4.5s, one with an LV blade and a Hock chip breaker. I use the 4.5s for rough work (relatively speaking) and the LV for the final touchup. Caveat: No one should imply from my comments that I actually think I am an accomplished wood smoother. Why do I have 3 Stanley 4.5s you might ask? Simple - I just got carried away. And they look nice next to the 3s, 4s, 5s, 5.25s, 5.5s, 6s, 7s, and the old rusty #8.

Jerry

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#9

Uh. Thanks?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>That's what WC is all about isn't it? Same questions over and over if you think about it. Just like the ww magazines. Same articles month after month with different pictures.

Difference is I don't have any friends at FWW. I do here. I could have searched. But then I wouldn't have a reason to keep coming back to see if anybody responded and/or what my friends have to say, oh and I wouldn't have noticed any adds that I might check out which then might help Ellis.

I can't think of many questions asked here where you couldn't find an answer by searching first.

I was just trying to start some conversation... besides, what if a few weeks ago, somebody posted the same questions, bought whatever, then didn't like it. I ask the same question and that person lets me know what they got and maybe why they were unhappy with it. What if I wasn't too computer literate and did my search wrong and didn't get the right results?

Now I'm in a foul mood.

Merry Christmas.

P.S.

Diet Coke is best. No question about it.

:)

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#10

Hadn't considered that option. Thanks.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Thanks. Hadn't considered that option. Glad I asked.

I'll do some searches on that topic.

Joe

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#11

Re: Hadn't considered that option. Thanks.

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon

>And if you ask, LV vs LN - the answer from me is. LV/Veritas

I won't rehash it here, but I've posted quite a number of times comparing both. I owned both, actually.

I sold the LN to buy the LV. For me, it's that much better.

(And if you're looking to zoom down the slope, the irons are all interchangable on the LV heavy smoother, jack and jointer - so now you have an excuse for all three!)

Cheers,

Greg

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#12

Re: Hadn't considered that option. Thanks.

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon

>Oops, in case it isn't clear by thread position, I'm referring to the bevel up LV vs. LN. The Jack specifically, though the same applies at least mostly, to the smoother and jointer too.

-Greg

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#13

Get a Bedrock 604 1/2

Clint Jones

>

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#14

ya, sorry, Joe

woodburnbob

>Turns out that I feel lots better about everything now. The sun's out and it's kinda warm. At this moment, I wouldn't think of responding the way I did a few hours ago. I kinda wish my keyboard had a lock of some kind, like a breathalizer gizmo. I'd have to breath in and it would only click open in the absence of the vapors.

I've got the LN-164, which in my novice hands exceeds everything else I have, including a bunch of infills. I drink Coke exclusively and won't come near Pepsi.

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#16

You missed the boat...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>You should have got the Anniversary LN bronze 4-1/2. I think you can still get one from LN down under (OZ that is). I prefer the look and feel of LN's to LV, but that's just me.

A lot of people really like the LV bevel up smoother. Might be worth a look...

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#17

They cost too much!

Jerry Nicholson

>I keep looking for the little old widow lady with the #1 and #2 still in the box that belonged to her late lamented husband who only bought them for weights to flatten his collection of rare stamps but I haven't found her yet. I plan to offer her $17.50 each when I find out where she lives.

Jerry

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#18

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

Dan CLermont in Burnaby

>I assume you are looking for a BD plane.

II have owned the LV 4 1/2, LN 4 1/2 and a Berock 604 1/2

Also have played with several LV BU smoothers and own a LN BU Jack

As far as the BD planes go. I am not a fan of the adjuster used on the LV. Also don't find the tote to be comfy at all. I sent the plane back after a week.

Bedrock 604 1/2 is/was a good plane. Had that nostalgia feel and I quite enjoy the Bedrock frog adjustment style. Plane works well but lacks the heft of the LN in tricky grain situations

The LN 4 1/2 is a nice plane with A2 blade (cyrogenically treated which is a process LV does not do). Plane is heavy and handles well in difficult woods. If you can find a LN 4 1/2 Bronze and don't mind weight they are also very nice but pricey

The LN BU Jack plane is very nice but lacks adjustability on the fly. The lower bedding angle gives more wear on the bevel (same goes for the LV). This style of plane gives you infinite blade angle possibilities providing you have inifinite blades. Lacks weight compared to BD planes

The LV BU Jack has a don't bash the blade when your seating it screw but the screw is placed right at the front of the mouth so be careful you don't bash the blade on the screw. Again the totes on the LV are not my favorite although I prefer Cocobolo to the Cherry LN puts on their planes (LN will upgrade your plane to Cocobolo for $25)

My favourite is the LN 5 1/2 york pitch cause of the extra weight. The length makes it a good jointer for short boards and the high angle frog handles all of the woods I throw at it.

Merry Christmas

Dan Clermont

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#19

Now that you are in a better mood

Ernie Miller

>What do you think Tails or pens first? and come to think about it why do they call them pins and tails? if you look at them they all kind of look like tails if they are talking about bird tails? Why not male and femle? Ha bob did I forget to say merry Christmas and a Rockin good New Years!! I love this place and every one who visits.

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#20

OZ

Dean Lapinel

>I don't think the Oz ones are available anymore. I wrote and was told they were all spoken for. I wish I had bought one.

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#21

You are either rich, single or both.

Roy Anderson

>How come you get so many toys? I'm sweating the decision to get one more plane and you have all of them. I feel a tantrum coming on.

Anyway, as for Joe's original question, since I don't own either of them and only drool over the pictures, my opinion is pure fantasy. However...

I really like the traditional appearance of the LN.

On the other hand, the LV gets high gismosity marks. It is very cutting edge (is that a drive by pun?).

The LV is noticably cheaper.

What to do? What to do?

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#22

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

dave caudill

>Well I for one don't necessarily think I need to nuy a go to plane because my "Typical" Stanley is not up to the task. In fact my Stanley planes ARE my go to planes for the most part. So while you make it sound as though you are newish to this I wouldn't make any assumtions that you can't do exemplary work with the run of the mill Stanley. I will say that not all Stanley planes are of equal quality or performance. I have several #4s and a couple are great one is so so and another just does not want to tune up for me. They were not all created equal as maybe the new LN or LV planes are. It may take some looking to find one of the really good ones but they are out there and are worth the time and trouble. I have several of the typical Stanley planes that I would not trade for either of above said brands. I guess the moral of the story is don't short sell the oldies and assume you have to shell out lots of money to get a good performing smoothing plane.

Dave

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#23

Re: You are either rich, single or both.

Dan CLermont in Burnaby

>Hi Roy

I have very few hand planes and two young kids

The Bedrock 604 1/2 paid for the LN 4 1/2 Bronze (part of it). The LN 5 1/2 was my Birthday / Christmas gift. The LN Low angle jack was also a Christmas gift.

Some people like to have 5 smoothers at their disposal, 3 jack planes a coupla jointers, etc. I don't have the space so I only have the planes I use.

The LV plane 4 1/2 I only had for a week and I probably would have replaced my Bedrock 604 1/2 with it if the LV plane worked better for me but it didn't. So I kept the Bedrock and the LV went back

Good Luck with your decision.

Dan C

Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane

#25

Re: :-)... Make that #2 corrugated too!

Clint Jones

>I have them all and corrugated. The odd numbers too they just couldnt make it to the shoot !!!Gloat!!!


img