Re: Hypothetical Question on 4-1/2 Smoothing Plane
Dan CLermont in Burnaby
>I assume you are looking for a BD plane.
II have owned the LV 4 1/2, LN 4 1/2 and a Berock 604 1/2
Also have played with several LV BU smoothers and own a LN BU Jack
As far as the BD planes go. I am not a fan of the adjuster used on the LV. Also don't find the tote to be comfy at all. I sent the plane back after a week.
Bedrock 604 1/2 is/was a good plane. Had that nostalgia feel and I quite enjoy the Bedrock frog adjustment style. Plane works well but lacks the heft of the LN in tricky grain situations
The LN 4 1/2 is a nice plane with A2 blade (cyrogenically treated which is a process LV does not do). Plane is heavy and handles well in difficult woods. If you can find a LN 4 1/2 Bronze and don't mind weight they are also very nice but pricey
The LN BU Jack plane is very nice but lacks adjustability on the fly. The lower bedding angle gives more wear on the bevel (same goes for the LV). This style of plane gives you infinite blade angle possibilities providing you have inifinite blades. Lacks weight compared to BD planes
The LV BU Jack has a don't bash the blade when your seating it screw but the screw is placed right at the front of the mouth so be careful you don't bash the blade on the screw. Again the totes on the LV are not my favorite although I prefer Cocobolo to the Cherry LN puts on their planes (LN will upgrade your plane to Cocobolo for $25)
My favourite is the LN 5 1/2 york pitch cause of the extra weight. The length makes it a good jointer for short boards and the high angle frog handles all of the woods I throw at it.
Merry Christmas
Dan Clermont