Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

8000 grit water stone - worth it?

Posts

8000 grit water stone - worth it?

#1

8000 grit water stone - worth it?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi.

I use a 1000/6000 King combo stone right now for sharpening my chisels and plane irons. After using the 6000, I sometimes use a white Nagura stone on the 6000 and sharpen a bit more. Not sure I should be doing that or not... Sometimes I'll use sandpaper as well as a last step. I forget right now what the paper is but it's that plastic backed self stick something or other micon stuff. I think it's by 3M. The stuff is super smooth, not even sure it's doing anything. :)

I was thinking about getting an 8000 stone too. My thought is that I would use the 8000 right after the 6000 stone and not bother with the paper.

Will I gain much? They seem pricey. Upwards of $90 or so. Unless you know of something/somewhere cheaper.

So, is an 8000 grit stone worth the money?

Thank you.

Joe

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

#2

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Joe

Using a 8000 after a 6000 is not a significant jump (1.2 microns verses 2.0 microns, respectively). If you go on to hone on Veritas green rouge (0.5 microns), then there will be no gain at all.

Another trick with the 6000 King is to continue honing as the stone dries, honing in the dry paste. This breaks down and works at a higher than 6000 level.

If you were choosing between the 6000 and 8000, then my choice is the 8000. Not only is it a nice stone to use, working quickly and producing a great edge, but it is actually as cheap or cheaper than the King 6000 when you take into account that it is more than twice the size of the 6000.

I currently use the King 8000 Gold and previously used the King 6000.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

#3

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

david.m.brown

>I've got a Norton 1000/8000 combo stone & love it. If you already have a 6000 grit stone, $90 is a chunk of change for a small improvement. Of course, YMMV

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

#4

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

Rob Lee

>Hi Joe -

I'd skip it personally.

Different things work for different people - so you'll get a lot of different answers.

I think the biggest bang for the buck you can get is to add a chromium oxide buffing compound to your current lineup... and use it manually...

I scribble the green stuff on wood (or paper, or cloth, or leather) and pull blades (trailing stroke) through it... it cuts aggressively enough that you don't need power - and it will improve the edge left from a 6000x King stone (or an 8000x for that matter).

Hand sharpening - I only use 800x, 4000x, chromium oxide...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

#5

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

Paul Kierstead

>I don't think using a 8000 after a 6000 will be very productive; very little gain for the work. I'd wait till I wore out the 6000 or needed a stone out all the time or the like.

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

#6

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I "inherited" a 6000 stone, and to my taste it doesn't give a shap enough edge. I have a Norton 8000, and this one does the job (this is my go-to stone for "normal" honing), although the green stuff does kick it a notch higher in terms of finish. I've used the sheets from LV, I have to try the stick on wood, as Rob suggests.

I've purchased 0.3 micron PSA paper from Japan Woodworker, haven't tried it yet (the peel-off backing is rougher than the grit face...).

DC

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

#7

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I like the 8000 grit for plane blades on smoothers. Not necessary for chisels and "roughing" planes.

Quite like the new glass backed Shapton 16000 grit but don't know if I could justify it as I am happy with the surface with my 8000.

If you feel the surface from your 6000 combo stone still needs touching up then by all means get an 8000. I personally think they are worth it.

Or buy one after you wear out your 6000

Dan Clermont

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

#8

Thanks all. Green goop on order with Lee Valley

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Think I'll give that a try.

Thank you.

Joe

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

#9

Re: Thanks all. Green goop on order with Lee Valle

thomd

>As far as I know it's an intentional step it's not just a different shade of brown. Those are two stones in a series. Even if one says there is only x micron difference it sounds like 66 percent to me. And in reality it's more than that like the difference between a 2 foot square snow shovel and a 1.2 foot square one

My experience with the king stones is that the 8000 is the real deal and significantly higher performance, and that you need a few well spread out steps to get there. So for me it It's never a mater of whether you need the 8000, that's the destination and I have tried a variety of methods of getting there. I can get a .0004 shaving with that stone. As mentioned, you can work a stone dry to great effect. the only problem is if the drying up paste runs out of cutting power before you run out of stuff to cut. It's a finite amount of cut before it glazes over, so it's something I don't mind happening at the end of a sequence but I don't rely on it to take out medium scratches.

I use a Nagura for one thing only, to deglaze a stone. i don't use it to make mud, or flatten, or get an extra degree of polishing power. In fact, as regards the last point, if it frees up the surface it might reduce the final polish I tiny fraction. So if my finish stone is clogged I nagura it, otherwise I don't bother.

Re: 8000 grit water stone - worth it?

#10

Since you are, consider the alternative

woodburnbob

>By all means give the CrO was a try. Certainly one bar is a lifetime supply...and then some.

But since you're evidentally trying out methods for the last step in polishing, I might suggest you also experiment with sub-micron diamond paste on the sole of a cast iron plane. I've been playing with this the last couple weeks and it seems to add something to my former last step.

If you are old enough to recall the Brylcreem slogan A Little Dab'll do Ya, you'll find a little redolence in using diamond paste on cast iron. A little rice-sized dab of diamond paste, embedded into the sole of a #4 behind the mouth by spreading and pushing down with a harder-than-cast-iron, hardened, steel, blade face, has lasted me through a dozen blades and is still polishing.