Scrubs, carpentry, and gratuitous Faulkner link *LINK*
Bill Houghton, rain today, Sebastopol, CA
>There have been frequent references to scrub planes being carpenter's planes rather than furnituremaker's planes. Apparently, at least by WWII, they weren't entirely respected among carpenters. I just picked up, from our local Friends of the Library booksale, a copy of "Carpentry Craft Problems" by H.H. Siegele, whose major modern fame among woodworkers is as author of "The Steel Square," which teaches how to use the steel framing square to measure board footage, lay out rafters, solve geometric problems, calculate the trajectory of the Lunar Orbiter, etc.
In it, he says, "Sometimes, too, doors run from 1/8 to 1/4 of an inch wider than the specified width. When this is true...a great deal of extra work must be done. Some carpenters use what is called a scrub plane to take off this surplus wood and finish the planing with a jack plane and jointer....A pretty good job of door fitting can be done with a jack plane only, and many carpenters do not use anything else." Clearly not a big fan of the #40/41 planes. He then, incidentally, goes on to tout the fore plane and recommend the jointer as the proper tool to finish fitting a door.
At the beginning of the book, he introduces his recommended tool list with, "It is fitting and proper that this work, which is to benefit...particularly the apprentice carpenter, should open by suggesting a set of tools..." He then goes on to list tools, including a smoothing, jack, fore, AND jointer plane, but no scrub (or plow/plough, although he later refers to it when discussing window frames and sash; but I take it that his list is meant for the apprentice, who would not be assigned to make window frames or sash by him/herself).
In the course of confirming my memory that Siegele did indeed write "The Steel Square," I found the link below, which goes into great detail about how a box of tools in Faulkner's "As I Lay Dying" relates to the members of the family. Nice to see a university instructor who takes the time to research tools in some detail. Thought I'd include it for others who need a dose of academic perspective on our entertainment/craft/obsession.
Cash Bundren's toolbox in "As I Lay Dying"