Workbench
Rusty Miller
>I'm curious, where do you put your workbench? Up against a wall under a window or out in the middle of the shop floor.
Thanks,
Rusty-Tye, TX
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Workbench
Rusty Miller
>I'm curious, where do you put your workbench? Up against a wall under a window or out in the middle of the shop floor.
Thanks,
Rusty-Tye, TX
Against a wall, under a window
Dave Thompson
>I have tools all over the wall next to the bench within hands reach that I find pretty handy. Ofcourse, the window is for light and air. The negative for this is when it rains, and I forget to close the window when I leave the shop. It's only happened a few times that I can think of. hmm.... I guess the other negative is when the mud dawbers and paper wasps get in the shop and can't find their way out again. They tend to hang out on the window, and once in a while I'll feel one crawling on my neck as I'm distracted doing something else. A box fan in the window helps for this.
I can't remember the last time (if ever) I wanted to approach my bench from the opposite (wall) side.
Dave
Re: Workbench
Glenn Madsen - on the road from SF
>Mine's in the middle of the used-to-be-a-garage shop. All the walls are covered with shelves, wood storage and electron eaters.
It works well. Provides workspace and infeed support to the table saw, but leaves plenty of room for the more enjoyable, and quieter, hand tool work. The handtool cabinet hangs on the wood rack, and keeps the planes, saws and marking tools close at hand.
You do what fits. Yes, I'd like a bigger shop, but it won't happen this year.
Neither
Jack Guzman from Maine
>I have mine against a wall with shelves. Most of my commonly used tools are handy from the bench. The window is behind me to give light.---Jack
Re: Workbench (rambly, but hey, I'm retired)
Bill Houghton, retired fun in Sebastopol, CA
>My shop is 11 feet square, with one door. Since I'm a hybrid woodworker - both electron-killing tools and cholesterol-killing tools - I have to allow room for a table saw, bandsaw, and drill press (and sometime this winter, I hope, a lathe), I have to fit the workbench into available space.
It's complicated by the fact that I'm also a try-to-be-self-sufficient homeowner and car owner, so those tools take up three rollaways and two top chests.
"Available space" turns out to be against the wall adjacent to the door, so that I can (and have) run long pieces out the door. Since it is against the wall, I lagscrewed the top to a ledger that is, in turn, lagscrewed to the framing; this is one rigid bench, one advantage of against-the-wall placement.
The windows in the shop are high on the opposite wall.
I've been doing some handwork on the window frame I'm building, including pulling a sawhorse into the shop to do some handsaw work during a rainstorm yesterday, and I've realized that, if I felt I had the time and endurance to get rid of the power tools, 121 square feet would make a pretty decent hand tool shop. Even if I did, the bench would be against the wall - there's no working room for a mid-shop bench in this small a space.
Re: Workbench
Roy Anderson
>This is a good question. I'm always thinking about ergonomics since my rotator cuff surgery. I don't want to reach too much. Now I have my bench against a wall near a corner, so I have shelves in front of me and a peg board within arms length to my right. There's just enough room at the right end of my bench to squat down and sight on my winding sticks. The only issue I'm having here is that it is just a little to far to reach across my bench to the shelves in front if I have to do it too often, so I am constantly calibrating what objects should be on the shelves and what should be on the peg board.
I think being fixated on ergonomics goes hand in hand with Neanderthalism, right up there with being fixated on sharpening. It's all part of the same disease.
I also think that time spent considering the position of your bench and the things that surround it and interact with it is just as productive if not more than obsessing over the details of your bench design, which we see in so many posts here. Just my opinion.
Re: Workbench
Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod
>Rusty -
I can walk around my bench. It's 7' long x 30" wide. I have a quick action vise on the front, an Emmert on the back, and a Veritas tail vise.
Sometimes I'll set up two workstations, one on the front and one on the back. It's helpful for some clamping operations to be able to work from both sides of the bench. With large work on the bench it's often easier to walk around it rather than rotate the work.
For many years I had a 5' long by 24" wide bench against a wall and managed to get things done but given a choice I prefer the walk around.
Ed
As a room divider
jim reed @ tallahassee
>in the middle of the floor. Against the wall gets it out of the way, but I find it much more useful in the middle of the floor. Often projects extend beyond the sides.
Middle of the room...
John in New Mexico
>Or at least not against a wall for me.
Last shop I actually worked for had them all lined up against the walls with assembly tables about 3 feet away forming a central isle between all the tables. That worked pretty well on the whole, though it made me think my ideal set up would be a heavy bench with vises in place of the table and a narrower bench (like 18" or less) against the wall with hanging tools or whatever above.
My current shop is in a basement, so I have to just longingly consider where to place relative to windows :).
John
Under my pillow. I'm still dreaming of it.
V Parisian
Against wall, under window
Dean J in MN
>Currently my bench is against a wall, under a window. In the previous space it was first in the center of the shop, then migrated against a wall. I found the wall to be an advantage for my bench and work style. I use holdfasts and battens; being able to bank the battens against the wall is nice. I was worried I'd miss the "rear" access to my bench, but in use I did not.
I now have a window over the bench, just above the bench top height. The raking light sure is nice to have.
-Dean
Re: Workbench
Rusty Miller
>Thanks everyone for the replys. I have room in the shop to do it either way but just wanted some feedback from others to see how you all did it.
I do like being able to get all around the bench but I also like the extra floor space. Right now it's in the floor but I think a may move it against a wall and see how I like it.
Again thanks for the input.
Rusty-Tye, TX
Smack dab in the middle
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA