Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Hand Saw Question

Posts

Hand Saw Question

#1

Hand Saw Question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level


>First, I should say that I do not buy old tools to collect. I only buy tools to use for my furniture building. Their collection value is not terribly important to me yet I guess it's interesting to know about it. Having said that I have a saw question:

I just took 2 saws to a sharpener for some work. One is an old Simmonds rip saw and one is a very old Disston crosscut. In talking with the sharpener I decided to have him alter the set on the rip saw and to change the Disston from an 8 to a 10 tooth. What is important for me is the performance for my work. But I was curious, does changing the teeth like that kill the value of a saw?

Tommy

Re: Hand Saw Question

#2

Need more Info

Todd Hughes


>If your old Disston was a very nice older no. 12 with the factory teeth still what you did could hurt the vaule a good bit...if it is a common D8 in common condition probably doesn't do anything to the vaule and could even make it worth more to sombody that wanted a 10 ppi saw.

More then likely you started out with $5 or $10 saws and still have $5 or $10 saws.

Personaly have to wonder why pay to have a 8 PPI retoothed to 10 instead of just picking up a nice 10 PPI saw and keeping the 8 PPI too.....Todd

Re: Hand Saw Question

#3

Re: Hand Saw Question

mikew


>Hi Tom,

My feelings about tools some find disturbing. And that is to pretty much make any changes necessary or desired to do one's work.

Odds are your saws are not in the rare category. But for another person to make a value statement, more info would be needed.

If I were to have a tool which was valuable or rare [I don't own any], I would sell them for more than I paid and buy tools I could use. The tools I would purchase to replace them might be new or vintage--but I wouldn't hesitate to alter those if it was something needed.

Take care, Mike

Re: Hand Saw Question

#4

Re: Hand Saw Question

dennis mcdonaugh


>Not on a user. It definitely can on a collectable saw if the tooth count is stamped on the heel of the blade. If the stamp is missing or unlegible, then its anybodys guess what the original tooth pattern was and probably won't hurt the value.

Take a look at the disstonian site to see if you have a collectable saw or a good user.

Re: Hand Saw Question

#5

Re: Need more Info

dennis mcdonaugh


>I like Todd's line of thinking. Old saws are pretty easy to find locally or on e-bay for very little cash.

Re: Hand Saw Question

#6

Saw I.D.'s

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level


>Folks, thanks for the input.

When I get the saws back I will shoot pictures and post them here. I'm sure you hand tool gurus can I.D. them and that would be fun. I doubt they are valuable ones though.

Tom

Re: Hand Saw Question

#7

Re: Hand Saw Question

jmohnike


>In my opinion it makes no diff. You are not a collector, if you left the saw the way it was, and left it hanging on the wall, unused, then it would be "worthless" to you. If by modifying it and you use it and it does the job you intended it to do, it is worth its weight in gold, to you.

Re: Hand Saw Question

#8

"AMEN !" from the back of the room !

Steve Mackay