Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

OT - finish shelf life

Posts

OT - finish shelf life

#1

OT - finish shelf life

Bill Houghton, retired fun in Sebastopol, CA


>As I clean up/organize my shop (yay retirement! I'm finally getting to set it up sort of properly - properly would involve expanding it in size about 400%), I find I've got several cans of various finishes - Watco, Minwax, polyurethane, varnish, etc. I marked the date of purchase on one, but the others are of indeterminate ages. If they're too old to be trustworthy, it'd sure be nice to make more room in the two kitchen cabinets that keep all my various chemical things.

Anyone know of any good charts on shelf life of finishes? I tried Google, and got mostly individual company listings, and the almost 2 million total hits were just a bit much to work through.

Re: OT - finish shelf life

#2

Re: OT - finish shelf life

thomd


>Shelf life is meaningless, it mostly reflects how long they tested it for. If they tested it for a year and it was good they may mark it as a 1 year shelf life. It could be wonderful 20 years later.

The manufacturers are soimewhat trapped, if they say the shelf life is 10 years people will blame them for anything that goes wrong if their can has turned, if they say it's only good for 1 year people just figure they want to sell more. That isn't even mentioning different air volumes in the can.

I built a canoe around 1980, and refinished it @ 2000 with the bottom third of the can of Z-spar captain's varnish I had used originally. it was just as wonderful as when I first opened the can.

Test it and see what it's like.

Re: OT - finish shelf life

#3

Re: OT - finish shelf life

Dan Donaldson


>When I consider the amount of work and prep in a project against the cost of the finish, there is usually no comparison. Trying to get the last bit of life out of a can of finish, to me, is a false economy. If I have any doubt at all, I dump it. (Actually recycle, not literally dump ;-)) I don't think it is worth the risk for the cost of a can of finish.

Re: OT - finish shelf life

#4

Re: OT - finish shelf life

Dave Thompson


>I think many finishes you can tell when you open the can.

I've had shellac turn dark on me. More often though, the alcohol just evaporates and my 2lb cut feels like a 3+ lbs cut.

I've had poly go bad after 3 years, and some other poly as good as new after 8 years. The stuff that went bad became solid along the sides of the can and unusually gloppy elsewere, similar to the way PVA glue gets old.

I would suggest not going by date, but rather by opening it up and taking a look.

Dave

Re: OT - finish shelf life

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: OT - finish shelf life

Dale Lenz


>Not meaning to hijack this thread. The other night in the shop after recalling the discussion on glue shelf life, I just purchased my new bottle of glue that normally last one year. I did the math and the glue cost is <0.001% of the project's value. I'd think finishes, unless you are spraying it, would be in the same ballpark.

Re: OT - finish shelf life

#6

Dale Lenz

Re: OT - Oops, my bad

Dale Lenz


>make that >0.01%, : ' >. Still a trifle cost to gamble with.

Re: OT - finish shelf life

#7

easy solution

bill tindall


>test on a piece of glass, like a bottle or sheet. If the finish has not thickened it means it has not begun to cure. If when applied to glass it dries and cures to an acceptable film then it will do so on wood. I have varnish that is 15 years old, carefully stored in absence of oxygen, and it is still fine.