Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

Posts

Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

#1

Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

Norman (Metcalfe, Ont.)


>This article in "The New Atlantis" was pointed out to me by a friend.

It appears to be an excellent dissertation on the state of crafts

and specifically hand work , manual labor , the trades, and woodworking in today's world.

The author has done an admirable job of summarizing the trend that many of us have been observing over the past few years and decades.

Some day the consumer wave will have crested and a greater appreciation for handmade crafts and the trades will result, much more so than today.

I've had many conversations with folks around this very same subject

over the years and am glad to see that others are noticing what I suspected is occuring with the state of manual trades, hand work, etc. I read this and gained some inspiration and motivation in pursuing what I enjoy most to do, woodworking..

Enjoy,

Norman


Shop Class as Soulcraft

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

#2

Wow

Gary B in Central NY


>that's the most in-depth article I've read since college, not for the faint of heart, but worthwhile. But, why do I feel I could make more in another trade other then cabinetmaking? why is it that cabinetmaking is underminded as a trade, unlike an electrician or plumber, darned the popularity of this trade as a hobby (no offense, just rambling)

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

#3

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft..

thomd


>Well the bottom line is that he gave up the satisfying work of motorcycle repair for wind baggery as postdoctoral fellow at the Institute for Advanced Studies in Culture. Take that as you will.

I'm not sure where you get this:

"Some day the consumer wave will have crested and a greater appreciation for handmade crafts and the trades will result, much more so than today."

He says on a parallel line that:

"To expect otherwise is to hope for a reversal in the basic logic of the modern economy�that is, cognitive stratification. It is not clear to me what this hope could be based on"

I hope you are right, but as you accurately point out, what is needed is a change in consumer attitudes. It sometimes strikes me how low our expectations are. Go to some place called something like "mall of america", and look at the blotted bodies stagering around in glorified underwear and ask yourself what ever happened to good food or good clothing. One of the triumphs of the new manufactured goods is that where they have not succeeded in producing good qulity replacement products, they have simply changed the conversation so that some fat old cherub will believe the vast expanse of denin makes him look like Jame Dean not Don Vito of Bam fame. Now Don Vito in a tailored suit might look a gentleman, whatever the actual case.

Also this is a profoundly romantic piece, it mainly looks from the vantage point of the arts and crafts movement into industrialization and beyond. Craft before arts and crafts was, for instance, the quite extraordinary social control required to produce cotton or wool fabric. All those pretty pictures of folks spinning by the fire are not all they seem. The modern world has choice in it, and it's possible to make it in craft, or other fields. So it may be wise as he suggest, to keep one's options open.

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

#4

Thought Provoking Article -- Thanks

Mike Fitterling

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

#5

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft..

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>I'm hoping against hope that as energy becomes ever more expensive and as manufacturing reaches its point of diminished returns (that is, even with our exploding population demanding more resources, manufacturing capability easily produces much more than we can consume), large scale manufacturing will be less profitable. The energy required to ship things around the world will make the goods too expensive, and local production will come back. Along with that, our cult of celebrity will yield to the prominence of local performers. And so forth. At that time, local arts and crafts people can charge a living wage.

Pam

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

#6

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft..

thomd


>I could see the cost of shipping reducing the appeal of far flung places as manufacturing centers. On the other hand I think there are many options in shipping like the trend in small scale nukes that could step in (when the world reaches a state of perfect peace).

I was too young to be a hippy, but I remember thinking all this stuff would kick in as a result of the counter culture, and look what happened... I could still see it happening in small areas where people realy want it. A different thread from the where is the best place to make a living, but rather where is the best place to make a difference in craft or be part of an integrated craft culture.

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

#7

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft..

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>I'm old enough to have been a hippy, but was not. In fact, I'm more of one now than ever. I simply think that we're at a significant crossroads with globalization and online communications. It will be interesting to see how it plays out. Fortunately, Austin is very concerned with locally produced food, goods, and entertainment.

Pam

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

#8

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft..

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)


>I was reading just recently that the younger generation is beginning to appreciate the value of handcrafted items. It seems they are placing emphasis on durable items of furniture rather than expendable , disposal furniture. This is one of those things that has exhausted itself, the need to acquire inexpensive furniture items. I'm glad at this point to even see a discussion on the merits

of handcrafted vs. factory furniture.

Sometimes it helps to look at the picture from a birds' eye vantage,we have a better relationship to our present and future.

This is hopefully what the author is accomplishing here.

Let's not forget, many of out livelihoods depend on how much our clientele appreciate the products we produce in comparison to assembly line furniture or case goods.

This article. in a superlative sense, disseminates the message many of us are all striving to preach.... that handcrafted good quality is beyond anything acquired through large department stores.

Norman

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft.. *LINK*

#9

Re: Inspiration and the state of our craft..

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Well, I don't know how much effort people will put into furniture purchasing, you have to learn stuff; but I sure hope you're correct. It would be so wonderful to be able to earn a living doing creative things like making quality furniture.

Pam