Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

Posts

Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#1

Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

Roy Anderson


>Whoo haa! Number one son finally moved out of the basement and I can take over his room, which joins right onto my shop. An empty nester at last!! Yesss!!

I want to turn the new room into a glue up and finishing room. I will end up with 1) a dirty room for rust removal, sharpening, clean-up, solvent mixing, etc., 2) a middle room for planing, sawing, and other sawdust and chip generating activities and 3) a clean room for assembly, glue-up and finishing.

First, I would appreciate any thoughts on what would go into such a room and second, I have to make a bookshelf and I want to lay it out and finish it at a convenient working height. I was thinking about making a couple of saw horses for this. I must have seen a zillion designs for saw horses. Any favorite recommended plans would be appreciated.

TIA.

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#2

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>I'd like to have hot and cold running water and a very large (like wall length) sink in an assembly/finishing room. Also a huge square table kind of low to the ground and another regular bench height. A raking strong light source plus bright overheads. Cabinets above the sink for supplies. Floor to ceiling shelf unit.

Yes, I've designed a special finishing/assembly room for my new-shop-to-be, right next to the bathroom.

Pam

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#3

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>And probably a good dust collection system if you'll be sanding.

Pam

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#4

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

thomd


>You don't want any sanding in there might as well not bother with a separate room.

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#5

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Yeah, that's something I've been wrestling with. OTOH, how can you have an assembly/finishing room without a bit of sanding?

Pam

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#6

some thoughts on horses and dust

bill tindall


>First, nothing beats getting them off the payroll!

a major source of dust moving around a shop/house is clothing. After sanding or other dusty operations your clothes will scatter dust across the land.

The horses pictured are typical of what we use for handling lumber. they will easily hold 500 bdft.(a ton). The splay angle is 17 degrees. The leg 2 x 4 is cut 17 degrees and screwed and or bolted to horizontal. The strength comes from the 3/4" plywood brace across the top of the legs. As you can see, they stack which is nice feature.

These hroses have been used for spraying Kilz, hence their white appearance.


img

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#7

PS: brace is screwed and glued

bill tindall

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#8

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

thomd


>Not sure, but if it's a clean type room then you are basically dealing with stuff that is past the dust phase, so assembly etc... has to take place alsewhere. I have normally contented myself on furniture with hand applied finishes that are not all that dust sensitive, be they oils or french polish or hand finished lacquers and varnishes, so I haven't needed a finishing room, though it would be nice. I guess if I was making furniture commercially I would want spray. Even spaying oil is so much faster.

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#9

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Then you'd take the piece out of the room to do any between finishes/layers sanding, too?

Pam

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#10

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

thomd


>Your right. In practical terms I try to do stuff like that outside, well it's practical for the 10% of the time it's possible.

I suppose for the small amount of sanding that is required to dull a finish, you could do it with downdraft tables. But when it comes to a major sanding on the wood, I get so covered with dust I wouldn't want me in the finishing room. I did used to have a ROS with dust extration built in, connected to a hepa filter, which was pretyt clean. But in a real finishing room you don't even want to stir up the dust that comes from the blower on an electic motor.

A good model is in automotive where they have a spray booth that is pretty sanitary, and usually the sanding, blocking and all that goes on in a dirty room.

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#11

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>I find this issue a true quandry. On the one hand, Jewitt was wet sanding away in his finishing room on the video. On the other hand, it makes more sense from a dust control standpoint to take things to the next room, but that's impractical when the finish is wet and you don't have a good, clean table. In short, I'm about to come to the conclusion that in a hand tool shop where any machines are segregated in their own room, it makes more sense to have a finish/assembly corner than a seperate room. I'd also put any sharpening station in the machine room.

What do you think?

Pam

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#12

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

thomd


>Even wet sanding can be a problem because when it dries it needs to be tacked down.

To be commercially viable both from the point of view of "Quality" finish, and finishing speed, one needs to spray. If one sprays high VOC then one needs a spray booth with filtration (which I assume is not an issue here). Spray booths receive a lot of overspray, and the finish doesn't like any dust, so usually only spray goes on in spray booths.

(by the way: a) HVLP is down to 30 bucks for a gun where it used to cost hundreds, even here in Canada; b) the Dresner tape shows how to set up a spray booth with minimal materials. So does the KLausz tape.)

Any time one does a wet look finish the zero dust requirement is also in place.

Beyond that on has a lot of alternatives where a little dust isn't a big deal: hand applied oils, french polishing (wet sanding is integral to finish application), and brush-on finishes that may require hand rubbing. These things are slow and messy, but fire prottection is usually a bigger issue. By the way, fire is another reason not to mix initiators with fuel sources and sparks.

I remember seeing this statue of man as how he perceives the world through his senses, so hands and lips are enormous etc... In my perception of woodwork, finishing is a complete afterthought, like some spot in the middle of my back I can't feel. When it comes to selling it's a really big deal. Everything else is secondary. Now in natural wood furniture the wood sellection and some joinery plays a part in what the buyers sees too, so it's a little harder to separate the components. None the less a separate place for just spraying, or laying out work would be a real asset, I have never had that.

As far as grinding is concerned i would say two things: It does throw off a lot of localized dust that usually falls in the immediate area, however there is often a lot of engine blast from cooling fans. Also any overspray would be a problem. You don't even want to be walking into the area stuff is drying in to sharpen a tool, let alone the rest of it. Second is that the ideal grinder is a belt sander, and they are a little messier still, not bad but they produce fine grit, and the belts need a clean environment to remain sharp.

Anyway, there are so many issues; what a guitar maker needs is different from a chairmaker. Lots of room for personal adaptations.

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#13

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Yes, and I've got to deal with those evil sprays at some point soon I suppose. Today I ordered enough parts to build two Martin dreadnaughts, minus the back and sides. Got a real deal on this, they're parts from the Martin factory, seconds and the like, but my guy claims he'll only send good stuff. Even after buying sides and back, it will only cost about $120 per in materials.

It will be interesting to see how good a planed surface is for finishing. If/when I end up spraying, most likely a big, vented cardboard box will do just fine. I'd love to be able to try the Taylor UV finish, but doubt they've released the formula. Any sanding can be done outside.

Anyhow, I was thinking of isolating the dust producers rather than victims. If I can keep the machines and sharpening stations in a closed off room, that should go a long way toward isolating the rest of the shop from dust.

Pam

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#14

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

thomd


>Hand planing guitar tops is fun you will never plane better wood. It is bookmatched however, so one needs to be allert along the joint line. On thing I like to do is build a plywood box box with lots of bulheads so that it will not flex, and drill a lot of 1/4" holes in it you can place your wood on top of this and turn on the vac and plane the top right down to whatever thickness you like and it will stay perfectly in place.

When it comes to jointing the tops or backs. there are a bunch of trick for jointing the tedges, but I bet you have your opinions on that already. I use the OVerholtzer rubbed joint. FIrst you need to anlyse where you want the joint to fall and mark the ends of the joint somehow, because when you plane it you sometimex can't tell where th joint is sometimes it's obvious. You need to prepar the twp halve so they match given the kelf loss... Anyway the O method works wonderfully and it very simple. You find a flat surface and cover with a release material. You lightly clamp the first half to this surface. Then youapply glue to both edges, rub them together so they want to grab, and then you just walk away (be sure the joint is at the correct up down point. Let it dry overnight, and the following day you take it off. Once it is planed it will be invisible. Glue is titebond or the LMII white glue.

How are you bending your sides?

Are you doing the dovetail neck?

What type of top and bottom molds are you using and are you doing an open assembly or using a body mold.

I freehand the frets with an eclipse hacksaw.

Anything... let me know.

I bought about 10 sets of rosewood for 40 bucks each. Rosewood sells for a huge upcharge, and is cheaper than mahogany or maple, depends on the market, but that can be true.

Quite a few famous guitar builders, including the likes of Linda Manzer, send their instruments out for finishing. That's an option. If you have a good car finish place nearby with a smart painter, that can be a good option. Nitro is a great sounding finish. I don't use it but there are lots of people outside cali who shoot it. We have a lot fo famous local makers and mostly they shoot nitro. The average guitar is made of some pretty questionable materials, and yet probably does less enviro damage than the average garden gate.

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#15

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>That box sounds really cool, excellent idea, much better than buying one of those molds; and you could size the bulkheads to provide the radius, although might be a stretch to simulate a 25' radius. And it would make a great base for a go bar jig. Thanks.

Right now I don't have too many ideas how to do much of anything about making instruments. I simply wanted a great sounding guitar without lightening my wallet excessively. I found a wrecked Seagull CW Duet II on ebay and bought it, but the seller decided not to ship it. After much perusing, I really want a Gibson Songwriter Deluxe, but haven't seen a cheap one. So I decided to make a Martin since these parts were available.

As to the Overholtzer rubbed joint, wouldn't you need a radiused mold to clamp one side and rub the joint? Otherwise, the radiused back (or top, except my top is already jointed) would be a very mild W shape.

Don't know how I'll build the sides, either lamination or steam/hot water bending. One neck (Spanish cedar) at least is what the seller calls a M&T bolt on. I'm hoping he'll come across a dovetail one.

I'd love to use your box concept for assembly. Frets are too far out, have no idea how I'll radius the neck, apply fretboard, do the fretting, etc. I'm pretty sure I'll learn a lot about radiusing.

So you want to part with a couple of rosewood back/side sets? I haven't bought any yet, may hold off because there's a vendor called Colonial Tonewoods in Williamsburg, would be real handy to pick them up in January.

Getting an outside vendor to do the lacquer shooting is a truly great idea. I'll check with the local luthier (a mile or so from the house there's this great shop with five instrument specialists each doing business, kind of a consortium, although that sounds much bigger than they are). I want to keep the finish as minimal as possible so the parts can move and make noise.

Pam

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#16

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

thomd


>It's true that if you joint it straight and then bend it you won't have a perfect curve, but last I heard nobody was bothering to join it at a curve. In fact one of my inspirational builders only actually bothered to bulge the area below the sound hole/under the bridge. All that is really at stake is A) get enough arch in there to provide a little support so the bridge doesn't rock so far forward it cause an S curve, and B) most inmportant of all, ensure that with some mild variation in humidity the guitar never cracks. If you think about it a 2-3 mm top pushed into a mold where in one direction the thing is stiff and another it's a noodle is not going to hold the mold shape. But if you build it in as if it where, you end up with advantages A&B.

I turned my own molds out of baltic birch ply. Which I was just able to do because my lathe will turn a full size top piece to whatever curve I want, however classical guitars are smaller and I couldn't turn a full sized Dreadnaught. I could probably do it outboard if I built a new bed there. I didn't like the idea of spending big bucks for a piece of MDF. Actually I did make my first mold with hand tools I just hollowed out a pieces with a compass plane.

For now I should probably hang onto my rosewood. I can't imagine it would work out that great getting it to you over the border, and then it's expensive for me to get it back if I need more for LMII. But I'm sure if you keep an eye on the sales you will find some good prices. LMII is always blowing stuff out. For instance right now they are selling engleman tops for as little as 13 dollars. That's a good tonewood. It's amazing what you can get for low bucks. A lot of the art guitars use really expensive wood (still only 80 buck compared to 4K and up for the instrument) with very tight grain, but a few of the best builders today look for the opposite, and most of the great guitars of the past were built with a much more open grain. Afterall the top does have to vibrate to make any sound. So musically speaking expensive tops are not necesarry. Though... the search for perfect wood like the perfect finish is something the punters can understand. At 13 bucks, that's the kind of thing where I would buy 10. It depends on your objective. But certainly for some tops that use laminated construction the very nice wood is wasted on the outside. They have Sitka, which makes a nice steel string, for as little as 12.50-78.00. you can get a jumbo for 15 bucks. As I say you buy several you will probably love 60%-80% and use the rest for all kinds of thing you also need stock for.

They have rosewood for as little as 50 bucks, that's a 500 dollar upcharge on a lot of factory guitars.

The original Martins weren't built all fancy in molds, so I'm not sure one needs to do it that way, and it is a lot more complicated, though once you have it nailed it can be integrated into a jigs process that is pretty quick. By hand, flat would be a lot faster, and that is the sound and construction that brings the big bucks in the old market, if not the new

I'm not knowledgeable enough about Martins but your neckwood sounds a little light, though they sell it for necks for SS so it's probably just my nellie factor showing through. I like Mahogany necks, but anyway it's mostly the adjustible truss, that takes the tension in a steel string. I usually order my Mahog necks from Stu Mac. Though I still have quite a few left and haven't ordered in about 5 years. I think there are some nice domestic options for necks, though as far as selling necks is concerned... Mahog or maple seem to rule.

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#17

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing

thomd


>I should have mentioned that I use both hot pipe and a machine for bending. Either approach is pretty reliable. Hot pipe takes practice. Not billions but you would be wise to plane a few thin pieces of cheery, or somethign like it to practice on.

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#18

Re: Guitar building

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Yeah, see, you're trying to make me think this all through before my new stuff arrives. As usual, I imagine all sorts of solutions without problems. :)

The top is supposed to be radiused on 28', but it might not actually be that, won't know until next week. BTW, my tops only cost $10 each, the neck $25 pegged and routed, bridge $1, the two blocks $7 each, rosewood fingerboard $5. I'm a happy camper. I guess I could go to $35-50 for the back/sides set. The back braces were the most expensive thing at $40 a set. But they're already radiused correctly and ready to glue. I checked on ebay, where all the prices were much, much more.

I agree, you should keep your rosewood. I found a very nice Sapele set for $35, an African mahogany set for $50, and maybe a claro walnut set for $25 (although this is likely to go much higher). Interesting data on the woods used and why.

I like mahogany necks, too, but the Spanish Cedar looks nice and will probably be strong enough, will find it in a few months when I string it up. Of course, it was much cheaper than the ones online in various places. Also, I've got a big block of mahogany just waiting for an excuse to be cut up.

Pam

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#19

Will do, assuming I can afford one of them.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#20

Re: Guitar building

thomd


>It does sound from the LMII site as if the there is nothing unusual about a Spanish Cedar Neck. It's just me. An ebony fingerboard and rosewood backs and sides are a big step up in appearance for the guitar and don't cost that much, so it might be a nice touch for your second set. Rosewood fingergoards in particular kinda looks cheap, even though it's a more interesting looking material, and plays fine. I want to do an all maple classical at some point.

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#21

Re: Will do, assuming I can afford one of them.

thomd


>I made a fox bender from a kit. But it would have been smarter to have just built all the parts. It uses lightbulbs as a heat source, my version of the easybake oven.

I got a closeout price on a violin hot pipe, but they can be made out of very cheap materials. A piece of pipe and an electric BBQ starter, or a pipe and a propane torch.

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#22

Cool, thank you.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#23

Re: Guitar building

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Yes, I agree. I'll use a Sapele back/sides set for the first one, probably, still an option of African Mahogany. Sapele looks about the same as Spanish Cedar, or they do in the web photos. I expect to muck up big time at least once, which is why I got the second set of stuff, will have to see what's left after #1, think I'll call him Primo, and how good Primo plays.

I don't want another classical right now, have this ancient Goya that's good enough; so probably a traditional rosewood back/sides, mahogany neck, ebony fingerboard, and a good spruce top will be Secundo if there is a Secundo. I bet it's the combo of the silver frets and the rosewood fingerboard that offends you. A flat surface fret, if there is such a thing, would look a lot better.

Pam

Re: Help needed-planning my glue up and finishing room

#24

Re: Guitar building

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Geesh, procrastination may pay off. I just remembered that 20" diameter X 8' long black walnut log I have just waiting for something special. Better get busy riving that honey the minute the temperature drops.

Pam