Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Continuing my education...

Posts

Continuing my education...

#1

Continuing my education...

Edward in Vancouver


>Picked up Ian Kirby's Dovetail book at LV few months ago, the more I read his stuff, the more interested I get. Found a series of 12 of his books (more like school manuals) at the public library, on the 2nd one now. Since I'm trying to educate myself on the basic essentials I'm hanging on to every word he prints, but I'm a bit confused with marking guages and cutting guages.

Oh I know the physical diferences, seen enough of them and held enough of them. Kirby writes that marking guages are only for with the grain and cutting guages are only across the grain, and elaborates bit about not being cheap and trying to combine both tools. Thing is, I've got and really appreciate the round style of cutting gauge (yeah a LV one..)with the circular blade. I find this works very well for both grain directions, the wheel tends to pull the guage's fence in snug. Is there much of a difference? Do most of you make a big deal out of it?

Re: Continuing my education...

#2

Re: Continuing my education...

Gary B in Central NY


>I think what he's writing only applies to the "old" guages. not really sure though. I have the LV guage, and concur with your opinion.

Re: Continuing my education...

#3

Re: Continuing my education...

thomd


>I use the cutting gages for everything. In fact one propular way to sharpen the pin style essentially makes it into a cutting gage. I agree with David Charlesworth on his suggestion that a left and right bevel is a good supplement because depending on which way you are working the line, the bevel side of the mark can kinda fade out for you. I don't know whether Kirby's advice is traditionally true, because when I started about the only English style gage you could get, and the only one my dad used was a pin gage.

Kirby is a good writer. His equipment advice is not the best in my view. Years ago I took up his idea about using the jointer in place of many other planes, which was a bit disappointing. I also took a swing at his sharpening bench, because it is a clever way to build a bench, but it was a really messy sharpening system.

I think there are two good learning systems: either stick with a complete system like all Japanese, German or whatever, where you know it's internally complete. Or just make up your own by learning rom everything which is possibly more fun.

Re: Continuing my education...

#4

Re: Continuing my education...

Edward in Vancouver


>Good, I'll continue using the LV circular guage. That, and the saddle square, are probably the best aids/devices that I've used so far to give me SOME sense of accuracy.

In his "Sharpening with waterstones" book Kirby describes his sharpening bench. Makes alot of sense, but as space is limited I was thinking of making an "attachment" that would sit ontop of my sawhorse, diligently copied (with a few embelishments/deviations) from Chris Schwartz's model in a woodworking mag. One alteration to Kirby's sharpening bench would be a "drip tray" that would slide under the stones, probably an aluminum baking tray.